Cargando…

1705. Comparative Analysis of Luminometry -vs- Fluorescent Marker Use for Cleaning and Disinfection Processes in a Pediatric Hospital

BACKGROUND: The cleaning and disinfection process (CDP) of hospital surfaces has proven to be an effective tool in preventing healthcare-associated infections. ATP bioluminescence meters have been established as the standard for CDP evaluation. The use of fluorescent markers has also been establishe...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Londono-Ruiz, Juan Pablo, Cruz-Acevedo, Diego Andres, Gaitan-ayala, Lina Paola, Prieto-Villarraga, Liliana, Correa-Castro, Claudia Patricia, Gutierrez-Tobar, Ivan Felipe
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Oxford University Press 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10679087/
http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/ofid/ofad500.1538
_version_ 1785150510953660416
author Londono-Ruiz, Juan Pablo
Cruz-Acevedo, Diego Andres
Gaitan-ayala, Lina Paola
Prieto-Villarraga, Liliana
Correa-Castro, Claudia Patricia
Gutierrez-Tobar, Ivan Felipe
author_facet Londono-Ruiz, Juan Pablo
Cruz-Acevedo, Diego Andres
Gaitan-ayala, Lina Paola
Prieto-Villarraga, Liliana
Correa-Castro, Claudia Patricia
Gutierrez-Tobar, Ivan Felipe
author_sort Londono-Ruiz, Juan Pablo
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: The cleaning and disinfection process (CDP) of hospital surfaces has proven to be an effective tool in preventing healthcare-associated infections. ATP bioluminescence meters have been established as the standard for CDP evaluation. The use of fluorescent markers has also been established as an alternative to this. The aim of this study was to assess the concordance between luminometry measurements and fluorescent marker use in the CDP of a pediatric hospital. METHODS: A diagnostic test study was conducted in which luminometry (Clean-Trace™ LX25 - 3M™) was compared with the use of a fluorescent marker (West Scan - West Química). Joint relative light units (RLU) were taken, and a subjective scale was used to define the erasure of the fluorescent marker after the cleaning and disinfection process (completely erased, partially erased, and intact). The process was established as adequate when less than 65 ATP units were obtained in critical sites and less than 175 in general hospitalization sites. The R program v 4.2.2 was used for data analysis. RESULTS: We performed 292 paired measurements: 222 (76%) in critical areas and 70 (24%) in non-critical areas. Measurements were taken from different high-contact surfaces such as crash carts, monitor screens, worktables, dressing carts, and defibrillators, among others. The luminometries carried out in 244 (83.5%) were adequate, and the measurements with fluorescent marker showed that 187 (64%) presented total erasure, 37 (12.6%) showed partial erasure, and 66 (22%) were intact. The Kappa index between both tests for total erasure was calculated as adequate, being 0.155 (p-value 0.002). When the tests with the criteria of partial or total erasure were compared as adequate, the Kappa index was 0.007 (p-value 0.6). When they were sub-analyzed according to the areas (critical and non-critical), a kappa value of 0.141 (p-value 0.02) was found for critical areas and 0.194 (p-value 0.03) for non-critical areas. CONCLUSION: The correlation between the evaluation of the cleaning and disinfection process using a luminometer and a fluorescent marker showed slight agreement for total erasure. More studies are required to understand the reasons for this low correlation. DISCLOSURES: All Authors: No reported disclosures
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-10679087
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher Oxford University Press
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-106790872023-11-27 1705. Comparative Analysis of Luminometry -vs- Fluorescent Marker Use for Cleaning and Disinfection Processes in a Pediatric Hospital Londono-Ruiz, Juan Pablo Cruz-Acevedo, Diego Andres Gaitan-ayala, Lina Paola Prieto-Villarraga, Liliana Correa-Castro, Claudia Patricia Gutierrez-Tobar, Ivan Felipe Open Forum Infect Dis Abstract BACKGROUND: The cleaning and disinfection process (CDP) of hospital surfaces has proven to be an effective tool in preventing healthcare-associated infections. ATP bioluminescence meters have been established as the standard for CDP evaluation. The use of fluorescent markers has also been established as an alternative to this. The aim of this study was to assess the concordance between luminometry measurements and fluorescent marker use in the CDP of a pediatric hospital. METHODS: A diagnostic test study was conducted in which luminometry (Clean-Trace™ LX25 - 3M™) was compared with the use of a fluorescent marker (West Scan - West Química). Joint relative light units (RLU) were taken, and a subjective scale was used to define the erasure of the fluorescent marker after the cleaning and disinfection process (completely erased, partially erased, and intact). The process was established as adequate when less than 65 ATP units were obtained in critical sites and less than 175 in general hospitalization sites. The R program v 4.2.2 was used for data analysis. RESULTS: We performed 292 paired measurements: 222 (76%) in critical areas and 70 (24%) in non-critical areas. Measurements were taken from different high-contact surfaces such as crash carts, monitor screens, worktables, dressing carts, and defibrillators, among others. The luminometries carried out in 244 (83.5%) were adequate, and the measurements with fluorescent marker showed that 187 (64%) presented total erasure, 37 (12.6%) showed partial erasure, and 66 (22%) were intact. The Kappa index between both tests for total erasure was calculated as adequate, being 0.155 (p-value 0.002). When the tests with the criteria of partial or total erasure were compared as adequate, the Kappa index was 0.007 (p-value 0.6). When they were sub-analyzed according to the areas (critical and non-critical), a kappa value of 0.141 (p-value 0.02) was found for critical areas and 0.194 (p-value 0.03) for non-critical areas. CONCLUSION: The correlation between the evaluation of the cleaning and disinfection process using a luminometer and a fluorescent marker showed slight agreement for total erasure. More studies are required to understand the reasons for this low correlation. DISCLOSURES: All Authors: No reported disclosures Oxford University Press 2023-11-27 /pmc/articles/PMC10679087/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/ofid/ofad500.1538 Text en © The Author(s) 2023. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Infectious Diseases Society of America. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted reuse, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
spellingShingle Abstract
Londono-Ruiz, Juan Pablo
Cruz-Acevedo, Diego Andres
Gaitan-ayala, Lina Paola
Prieto-Villarraga, Liliana
Correa-Castro, Claudia Patricia
Gutierrez-Tobar, Ivan Felipe
1705. Comparative Analysis of Luminometry -vs- Fluorescent Marker Use for Cleaning and Disinfection Processes in a Pediatric Hospital
title 1705. Comparative Analysis of Luminometry -vs- Fluorescent Marker Use for Cleaning and Disinfection Processes in a Pediatric Hospital
title_full 1705. Comparative Analysis of Luminometry -vs- Fluorescent Marker Use for Cleaning and Disinfection Processes in a Pediatric Hospital
title_fullStr 1705. Comparative Analysis of Luminometry -vs- Fluorescent Marker Use for Cleaning and Disinfection Processes in a Pediatric Hospital
title_full_unstemmed 1705. Comparative Analysis of Luminometry -vs- Fluorescent Marker Use for Cleaning and Disinfection Processes in a Pediatric Hospital
title_short 1705. Comparative Analysis of Luminometry -vs- Fluorescent Marker Use for Cleaning and Disinfection Processes in a Pediatric Hospital
title_sort 1705. comparative analysis of luminometry -vs- fluorescent marker use for cleaning and disinfection processes in a pediatric hospital
topic Abstract
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10679087/
http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/ofid/ofad500.1538
work_keys_str_mv AT londonoruizjuanpablo 1705comparativeanalysisofluminometryvsfluorescentmarkeruseforcleaninganddisinfectionprocessesinapediatrichospital
AT cruzacevedodiegoandres 1705comparativeanalysisofluminometryvsfluorescentmarkeruseforcleaninganddisinfectionprocessesinapediatrichospital
AT gaitanayalalinapaola 1705comparativeanalysisofluminometryvsfluorescentmarkeruseforcleaninganddisinfectionprocessesinapediatrichospital
AT prietovillarragaliliana 1705comparativeanalysisofluminometryvsfluorescentmarkeruseforcleaninganddisinfectionprocessesinapediatrichospital
AT correacastroclaudiapatricia 1705comparativeanalysisofluminometryvsfluorescentmarkeruseforcleaninganddisinfectionprocessesinapediatrichospital
AT gutierreztobarivanfelipe 1705comparativeanalysisofluminometryvsfluorescentmarkeruseforcleaninganddisinfectionprocessesinapediatrichospital