Cargando…
2356. Close correlation of RBD with Live Viral Neutralising Capacity Across Variants and Time Supports Use of RBD Thresholds to Predict Protective Host Immunity
BACKGROUND: Although SARS-CoV-2 neutralising antibodies protect against severe COVID-19, whether circulating IgG titres reflect underlying host capacity to neutralise wild type (WT) and variants of concern (VOC) and what IgG threshold reflects sufficient neutralising capacity remains unclear. METHOD...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Oxford University Press
2023
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10679122/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/ofid/ofad500.1977 |
_version_ | 1785150519472291840 |
---|---|
author | Kenny, Grace O’Reilly, Sophie R Kelly, Neil Wrigley Negi, Riya Gaillard, Colette Marie Alalwan, Dana Saini, Gurvin Alrawahneh, Tamara Francois, Nathan Angeliadis, Matthew García-León, Alejandro Tinago, Willard Feeney, Eoin R Cotter, Aoife de Barra, Eoghan Yousif, Obada Horgan, Mary Doran, Peter Cox, Rebecca J O’Shea, Donal Olesen, Ole Landay, Alan Hogan, Andrew Lelièvre, Jean-Daniel Gautier, Virginie Cornely, Oliver A Mallon, Patrick |
author_facet | Kenny, Grace O’Reilly, Sophie R Kelly, Neil Wrigley Negi, Riya Gaillard, Colette Marie Alalwan, Dana Saini, Gurvin Alrawahneh, Tamara Francois, Nathan Angeliadis, Matthew García-León, Alejandro Tinago, Willard Feeney, Eoin R Cotter, Aoife de Barra, Eoghan Yousif, Obada Horgan, Mary Doran, Peter Cox, Rebecca J O’Shea, Donal Olesen, Ole Landay, Alan Hogan, Andrew Lelièvre, Jean-Daniel Gautier, Virginie Cornely, Oliver A Mallon, Patrick |
author_sort | Kenny, Grace |
collection | PubMed |
description | BACKGROUND: Although SARS-CoV-2 neutralising antibodies protect against severe COVID-19, whether circulating IgG titres reflect underlying host capacity to neutralise wild type (WT) and variants of concern (VOC) and what IgG threshold reflects sufficient neutralising capacity remains unclear. METHODS: In plasma from individuals in the All Ireland Infectious Diseases Cohort, we measured anti receptor binding domain (RBD) IgG and neutralising capacity by a micro-neutralisation assay, which determined the maximum plasma dilution to maintain 50% inhibition of replication (NT50) of live SARS-CoV-2, using WT and VOC (Beta and Omicron). We examined 3 groups sampled at 3 time periods: unvaccinated, prior infected (group 1, WT dominated), primary (2 dose) vaccinated (group 2) and group 3 with hybrid immunity (booster vaccine and Omicron infection). Although an NT50 ≥100 IU is considered sufficient protection in vaccine trials, as some VOC induce up to 6-fold reduction in NT50, we used NT50 ≥ 1000 IU as a cut off for WT neutralisation that would retain neutralisation against VOC. We used ROC curves to explore sensitivity and specificity and Youden Index to determine the RBD threshold associated with WT NT50 < 1000 IU. We validated the accuracy of this RBD threshold to predict NT50 < 100 IU against Beta and Omicron in groups 2 and 3 respectively. RESULTS: We included 255 participants across the 3 groups (table 1). In all groups, RBD highly correlated with WT NT50 (rho 0.81, 0.76 and 0.77 in groups 1, 2 and 3, all p< 0.001). In group 1 Youden’s Index determined RBD < 456 BAU/ml to best predict WT NT50 < 1000 IU (sensitivity 77% (95% CI 69, 84%), specificity 100% (95% CI 82, 100%)). All 99 samples with RBD < 456 BAU/ml had WT NT50 < 1000 IU; positive predictive value (PPV) 100%, (95% CI 95, 100%), and overall accuracy 80% (95% CI 73, 86%). When validated in groups 2 and 3, RBD < 456 BAU/ml retained good accuracy at predicting underlying neutralisation against VOC (group 2, accuracy 80% (95% CI 67, 90%) in predicting NT50 < 100 IU against Beta, and in group 3, overall accuracy of 87% (95% CI 77, 94%) to determine an NT50 of < 100 IU against Omicron. [Figure: see text] [Figure: see text] CONCLUSION: Host RBD titres closely correlate with NT50. An RBD threshold of < 456 BAU/ml accurately predicts a clinically relevant neutralising capacity against both WT and common VOC. DISCLOSURES: Oliver A. Cornely, MD PhD, DZIF: Advisor/Consultant|DZIF: Board Member|DZIF: Grant/Research Support|DZIF: Honoraria|DZIF: Stocks/Bonds |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-10679122 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2023 |
publisher | Oxford University Press |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-106791222023-11-27 2356. Close correlation of RBD with Live Viral Neutralising Capacity Across Variants and Time Supports Use of RBD Thresholds to Predict Protective Host Immunity Kenny, Grace O’Reilly, Sophie R Kelly, Neil Wrigley Negi, Riya Gaillard, Colette Marie Alalwan, Dana Saini, Gurvin Alrawahneh, Tamara Francois, Nathan Angeliadis, Matthew García-León, Alejandro Tinago, Willard Feeney, Eoin R Cotter, Aoife de Barra, Eoghan Yousif, Obada Horgan, Mary Doran, Peter Cox, Rebecca J O’Shea, Donal Olesen, Ole Landay, Alan Hogan, Andrew Lelièvre, Jean-Daniel Gautier, Virginie Cornely, Oliver A Mallon, Patrick Open Forum Infect Dis Abstract BACKGROUND: Although SARS-CoV-2 neutralising antibodies protect against severe COVID-19, whether circulating IgG titres reflect underlying host capacity to neutralise wild type (WT) and variants of concern (VOC) and what IgG threshold reflects sufficient neutralising capacity remains unclear. METHODS: In plasma from individuals in the All Ireland Infectious Diseases Cohort, we measured anti receptor binding domain (RBD) IgG and neutralising capacity by a micro-neutralisation assay, which determined the maximum plasma dilution to maintain 50% inhibition of replication (NT50) of live SARS-CoV-2, using WT and VOC (Beta and Omicron). We examined 3 groups sampled at 3 time periods: unvaccinated, prior infected (group 1, WT dominated), primary (2 dose) vaccinated (group 2) and group 3 with hybrid immunity (booster vaccine and Omicron infection). Although an NT50 ≥100 IU is considered sufficient protection in vaccine trials, as some VOC induce up to 6-fold reduction in NT50, we used NT50 ≥ 1000 IU as a cut off for WT neutralisation that would retain neutralisation against VOC. We used ROC curves to explore sensitivity and specificity and Youden Index to determine the RBD threshold associated with WT NT50 < 1000 IU. We validated the accuracy of this RBD threshold to predict NT50 < 100 IU against Beta and Omicron in groups 2 and 3 respectively. RESULTS: We included 255 participants across the 3 groups (table 1). In all groups, RBD highly correlated with WT NT50 (rho 0.81, 0.76 and 0.77 in groups 1, 2 and 3, all p< 0.001). In group 1 Youden’s Index determined RBD < 456 BAU/ml to best predict WT NT50 < 1000 IU (sensitivity 77% (95% CI 69, 84%), specificity 100% (95% CI 82, 100%)). All 99 samples with RBD < 456 BAU/ml had WT NT50 < 1000 IU; positive predictive value (PPV) 100%, (95% CI 95, 100%), and overall accuracy 80% (95% CI 73, 86%). When validated in groups 2 and 3, RBD < 456 BAU/ml retained good accuracy at predicting underlying neutralisation against VOC (group 2, accuracy 80% (95% CI 67, 90%) in predicting NT50 < 100 IU against Beta, and in group 3, overall accuracy of 87% (95% CI 77, 94%) to determine an NT50 of < 100 IU against Omicron. [Figure: see text] [Figure: see text] CONCLUSION: Host RBD titres closely correlate with NT50. An RBD threshold of < 456 BAU/ml accurately predicts a clinically relevant neutralising capacity against both WT and common VOC. DISCLOSURES: Oliver A. Cornely, MD PhD, DZIF: Advisor/Consultant|DZIF: Board Member|DZIF: Grant/Research Support|DZIF: Honoraria|DZIF: Stocks/Bonds Oxford University Press 2023-11-27 /pmc/articles/PMC10679122/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/ofid/ofad500.1977 Text en © The Author(s) 2023. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Infectious Diseases Society of America. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted reuse, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. |
spellingShingle | Abstract Kenny, Grace O’Reilly, Sophie R Kelly, Neil Wrigley Negi, Riya Gaillard, Colette Marie Alalwan, Dana Saini, Gurvin Alrawahneh, Tamara Francois, Nathan Angeliadis, Matthew García-León, Alejandro Tinago, Willard Feeney, Eoin R Cotter, Aoife de Barra, Eoghan Yousif, Obada Horgan, Mary Doran, Peter Cox, Rebecca J O’Shea, Donal Olesen, Ole Landay, Alan Hogan, Andrew Lelièvre, Jean-Daniel Gautier, Virginie Cornely, Oliver A Mallon, Patrick 2356. Close correlation of RBD with Live Viral Neutralising Capacity Across Variants and Time Supports Use of RBD Thresholds to Predict Protective Host Immunity |
title | 2356. Close correlation of RBD with Live Viral Neutralising Capacity Across Variants and Time Supports Use of RBD Thresholds to Predict Protective Host Immunity |
title_full | 2356. Close correlation of RBD with Live Viral Neutralising Capacity Across Variants and Time Supports Use of RBD Thresholds to Predict Protective Host Immunity |
title_fullStr | 2356. Close correlation of RBD with Live Viral Neutralising Capacity Across Variants and Time Supports Use of RBD Thresholds to Predict Protective Host Immunity |
title_full_unstemmed | 2356. Close correlation of RBD with Live Viral Neutralising Capacity Across Variants and Time Supports Use of RBD Thresholds to Predict Protective Host Immunity |
title_short | 2356. Close correlation of RBD with Live Viral Neutralising Capacity Across Variants and Time Supports Use of RBD Thresholds to Predict Protective Host Immunity |
title_sort | 2356. close correlation of rbd with live viral neutralising capacity across variants and time supports use of rbd thresholds to predict protective host immunity |
topic | Abstract |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10679122/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/ofid/ofad500.1977 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT kennygrace 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT oreillysophier 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT kellyneilwrigley 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT negiriya 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT gaillardcolettemarie 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT alalwandana 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT sainigurvin 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT alrawahnehtamara 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT francoisnathan 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT angeliadismatthew 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT garcialeonalejandro 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT tinagowillard 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT feeneyeoinr 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT cotteraoife 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT debarraeoghan 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT yousifobada 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT horganmary 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT doranpeter 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT coxrebeccaj 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT osheadonal 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT olesenole 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT landayalan 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT hoganandrew 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT lelievrejeandaniel 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT gautiervirginie 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT cornelyolivera 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity AT mallonpatrick 2356closecorrelationofrbdwithliveviralneutralisingcapacityacrossvariantsandtimesupportsuseofrbdthresholdstopredictprotectivehostimmunity |