BCI-Utility Metric for Asynchronous P300 Brain-Computer Interface Systems

The Brain-Computer Interface (BCI) was envisioned as an assistive technology option for people with severe movement impairments. The traditional synchronous event-related potential (ERP) BCI design uses a fixed communication speed and is vulnerable to variations in attention. Recent ERP BCI designs have added asynchronous features, including abstention and dynamic stopping, but it remains a open question of how to evaluate asynchronous BCI performance. In this work, we build on the BCI-Utility metric to create the first evaluation metric with special consideration of the asynchronous features of self-paced BCIs. This metric considers accuracy as all of the following three – probability of a correct selection when a selection was intended, probability of making a selection when a selection was intended, and probability of an abstention when an abstention was intended. Further, it considers the average time required for a selection when using dynamic stopping and the proportion of intended selections versus abstentions. We establish the validity of the derived metric via extensive simulations, and illustrate and discuss its practical usage on real-world BCI data. We describe the relative contribution of different inputs with plots of BCI-Utility curves under different parameter settings. Generally, the BCI-Utility metric increases as any of the accuracy values increase and decreases as the expected time for an intended selection increases. Furthermore, in many situations, we find shortening the expected time of an intended selection is the most effective way to improve the BCI-Utility, which necessitates the advancement of asynchronous BCI systems capable of accurate abstention and dynamic stopping.