Cargando…

Common analysis of direct RNA sequencinG CUrrently leads to misidentification of m(5)C at GCU motifs

RNA modifications, such as methylation, can be detected with Oxford Nanopore Technologies direct RNA sequencing. One commonly used tool for detecting 5-methylcytosine (m(5)C) modifications is Tombo, which uses an “Alternative Model” to detect putative modifications from a single sample. We examined...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Watson, Kaylee J, Bromley, Robin E, Sparklin, Benjamin C, Gasser, Mark T, Bhattacharya, Tamanash, Lebov, Jarrett F, Tyson, Tyonna, Dai, Nan, Teigen, Laura E, Graf, Karen T, Foster, Jeremy M, Michalski, Michelle, Bruno, Vincent M, Lindsey, Amelia RI, Corrêa, Ivan R, Hardy, Richard W, Newton, Irene LG, Dunning Hotopp, Julie C
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Life Science Alliance LLC 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10687253/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/38030223
http://dx.doi.org/10.26508/lsa.202302201
_version_ 1785151944147337216
author Watson, Kaylee J
Bromley, Robin E
Sparklin, Benjamin C
Gasser, Mark T
Bhattacharya, Tamanash
Lebov, Jarrett F
Tyson, Tyonna
Dai, Nan
Teigen, Laura E
Graf, Karen T
Foster, Jeremy M
Michalski, Michelle
Bruno, Vincent M
Lindsey, Amelia RI
Corrêa, Ivan R
Hardy, Richard W
Newton, Irene LG
Dunning Hotopp, Julie C
author_facet Watson, Kaylee J
Bromley, Robin E
Sparklin, Benjamin C
Gasser, Mark T
Bhattacharya, Tamanash
Lebov, Jarrett F
Tyson, Tyonna
Dai, Nan
Teigen, Laura E
Graf, Karen T
Foster, Jeremy M
Michalski, Michelle
Bruno, Vincent M
Lindsey, Amelia RI
Corrêa, Ivan R
Hardy, Richard W
Newton, Irene LG
Dunning Hotopp, Julie C
author_sort Watson, Kaylee J
collection PubMed
description RNA modifications, such as methylation, can be detected with Oxford Nanopore Technologies direct RNA sequencing. One commonly used tool for detecting 5-methylcytosine (m(5)C) modifications is Tombo, which uses an “Alternative Model” to detect putative modifications from a single sample. We examined direct RNA sequencing data from diverse taxa including viruses, bacteria, fungi, and animals. The algorithm consistently identified a m(5)C at the central position of a GCU motif. However, it also identified a m(5)C in the same motif in fully unmodified in vitro transcribed RNA, suggesting that this is a frequent false prediction. In the absence of further validation, several published predictions of m(5)C in a GCU context should be reconsidered, including those from human coronavirus and human cerebral organoid samples.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-10687253
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher Life Science Alliance LLC
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-106872532023-11-30 Common analysis of direct RNA sequencinG CUrrently leads to misidentification of m(5)C at GCU motifs Watson, Kaylee J Bromley, Robin E Sparklin, Benjamin C Gasser, Mark T Bhattacharya, Tamanash Lebov, Jarrett F Tyson, Tyonna Dai, Nan Teigen, Laura E Graf, Karen T Foster, Jeremy M Michalski, Michelle Bruno, Vincent M Lindsey, Amelia RI Corrêa, Ivan R Hardy, Richard W Newton, Irene LG Dunning Hotopp, Julie C Life Sci Alliance Research Articles RNA modifications, such as methylation, can be detected with Oxford Nanopore Technologies direct RNA sequencing. One commonly used tool for detecting 5-methylcytosine (m(5)C) modifications is Tombo, which uses an “Alternative Model” to detect putative modifications from a single sample. We examined direct RNA sequencing data from diverse taxa including viruses, bacteria, fungi, and animals. The algorithm consistently identified a m(5)C at the central position of a GCU motif. However, it also identified a m(5)C in the same motif in fully unmodified in vitro transcribed RNA, suggesting that this is a frequent false prediction. In the absence of further validation, several published predictions of m(5)C in a GCU context should be reconsidered, including those from human coronavirus and human cerebral organoid samples. Life Science Alliance LLC 2023-11-29 /pmc/articles/PMC10687253/ /pubmed/38030223 http://dx.doi.org/10.26508/lsa.202302201 Text en © 2023 Watson et al. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This article is available under a Creative Commons License (Attribution 4.0 International, as described at https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
spellingShingle Research Articles
Watson, Kaylee J
Bromley, Robin E
Sparklin, Benjamin C
Gasser, Mark T
Bhattacharya, Tamanash
Lebov, Jarrett F
Tyson, Tyonna
Dai, Nan
Teigen, Laura E
Graf, Karen T
Foster, Jeremy M
Michalski, Michelle
Bruno, Vincent M
Lindsey, Amelia RI
Corrêa, Ivan R
Hardy, Richard W
Newton, Irene LG
Dunning Hotopp, Julie C
Common analysis of direct RNA sequencinG CUrrently leads to misidentification of m(5)C at GCU motifs
title Common analysis of direct RNA sequencinG CUrrently leads to misidentification of m(5)C at GCU motifs
title_full Common analysis of direct RNA sequencinG CUrrently leads to misidentification of m(5)C at GCU motifs
title_fullStr Common analysis of direct RNA sequencinG CUrrently leads to misidentification of m(5)C at GCU motifs
title_full_unstemmed Common analysis of direct RNA sequencinG CUrrently leads to misidentification of m(5)C at GCU motifs
title_short Common analysis of direct RNA sequencinG CUrrently leads to misidentification of m(5)C at GCU motifs
title_sort common analysis of direct rna sequencing currently leads to misidentification of m(5)c at gcu motifs
topic Research Articles
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10687253/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/38030223
http://dx.doi.org/10.26508/lsa.202302201
work_keys_str_mv AT watsonkayleej commonanalysisofdirectrnasequencingcurrentlyleadstomisidentificationofm5catgcumotifs
AT bromleyrobine commonanalysisofdirectrnasequencingcurrentlyleadstomisidentificationofm5catgcumotifs
AT sparklinbenjaminc commonanalysisofdirectrnasequencingcurrentlyleadstomisidentificationofm5catgcumotifs
AT gassermarkt commonanalysisofdirectrnasequencingcurrentlyleadstomisidentificationofm5catgcumotifs
AT bhattacharyatamanash commonanalysisofdirectrnasequencingcurrentlyleadstomisidentificationofm5catgcumotifs
AT lebovjarrettf commonanalysisofdirectrnasequencingcurrentlyleadstomisidentificationofm5catgcumotifs
AT tysontyonna commonanalysisofdirectrnasequencingcurrentlyleadstomisidentificationofm5catgcumotifs
AT dainan commonanalysisofdirectrnasequencingcurrentlyleadstomisidentificationofm5catgcumotifs
AT teigenlaurae commonanalysisofdirectrnasequencingcurrentlyleadstomisidentificationofm5catgcumotifs
AT grafkarent commonanalysisofdirectrnasequencingcurrentlyleadstomisidentificationofm5catgcumotifs
AT fosterjeremym commonanalysisofdirectrnasequencingcurrentlyleadstomisidentificationofm5catgcumotifs
AT michalskimichelle commonanalysisofdirectrnasequencingcurrentlyleadstomisidentificationofm5catgcumotifs
AT brunovincentm commonanalysisofdirectrnasequencingcurrentlyleadstomisidentificationofm5catgcumotifs
AT lindseyameliari commonanalysisofdirectrnasequencingcurrentlyleadstomisidentificationofm5catgcumotifs
AT correaivanr commonanalysisofdirectrnasequencingcurrentlyleadstomisidentificationofm5catgcumotifs
AT hardyrichardw commonanalysisofdirectrnasequencingcurrentlyleadstomisidentificationofm5catgcumotifs
AT newtonirenelg commonanalysisofdirectrnasequencingcurrentlyleadstomisidentificationofm5catgcumotifs
AT dunninghotoppjuliec commonanalysisofdirectrnasequencingcurrentlyleadstomisidentificationofm5catgcumotifs