STAT3 Signaling Heterogeneity Underlies Cytokine-Expressing Fate in Th17 Cultures

The polarization of naive Th cells into differentiated subsets in vitro was a powerful approach to define the development and function of Th cells in vivo. Th cell cultures identified cytokines that promote polarization and defined the phenotype and stability of differentiated cells. One of the limitations of this approach is the heterogeneity of the differentiated culture, essentially with regard to what proportion of the culture is secreting the hallmark cytokine of interest. This heterogeneity has always been puzzling because all cells in the culture have been exposed to identical culture conditions. We examined this phenomenon using an Il17f lineage-tracing allele (Cost, Cre on seventeen transcript) crossed to stop-flox Rosa-YFP (yellow fluorescent protein) mice. We found that less than half of the cells in a Th17 culture become lineage-positive during a differentiation culture and that it is primarily cells that are lineage-positive that produce cytokines when cultures are restimulated after differentiation. We sorted and analyzed YFP-positive and YFP-negative cells and found similar expression of many Th17 transcription factors, although YFP-negative cells had increased expression of other lineage-defining transcription factors. We observed that YFP-negative cells had diminished expression of Stat3 and Il6ra, as well as decreased STAT3 activation. YFP-negative cells transduced with active STAT3 had significant increases in IL-17A expression, without increases in Th17 transcription factors. Taken together, these data suggest that there is a threshold of STAT3 activation that is required for efficient Th17 differentiation, and that even in a culture of homogeneous naive T cells there is heterogeneity in the receipt of early cytokine signals.