Cargando…
Predicting survival of Iranian COVID-19 patients infected by various variants including omicron from CT Scan images and clinical data using deep neural networks
Purpose: The rapid spread of the COVID-19 omicron variant virus has resulted in an overload of hospitals around the globe. As a result, many patients are deprived of hospital facilities, increasing mortality rates. Therefore, mortality rates can be reduced by efficiently assigning facilities to high...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Elsevier
2023
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10696006/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e21965 |
_version_ | 1785154479174189056 |
---|---|
author | Ghafoori, Mahyar Hamidi, Mehrab Modegh, Rassa Ghavami Aziz-Ahari, Alireza Heydari, Neda Tavafizadeh, Zeynab Pournik, Omid Emdadi, Sasan Samimi, Saeed Mohseni, Amir Khaleghi, Mohammadreza Dashti, Hamed Rabiee, Hamid R. |
author_facet | Ghafoori, Mahyar Hamidi, Mehrab Modegh, Rassa Ghavami Aziz-Ahari, Alireza Heydari, Neda Tavafizadeh, Zeynab Pournik, Omid Emdadi, Sasan Samimi, Saeed Mohseni, Amir Khaleghi, Mohammadreza Dashti, Hamed Rabiee, Hamid R. |
author_sort | Ghafoori, Mahyar |
collection | PubMed |
description | Purpose: The rapid spread of the COVID-19 omicron variant virus has resulted in an overload of hospitals around the globe. As a result, many patients are deprived of hospital facilities, increasing mortality rates. Therefore, mortality rates can be reduced by efficiently assigning facilities to higher-risk patients. Therefore, it is crucial to estimate patients' survival probability based on their conditions at the time of admission so that the minimum required facilities can be provided, allowing more opportunities to be available for those who need them. Although radiologic findings in chest computerized tomography scans show various patterns, considering the individual risk factors and other underlying diseases, it is difficult to predict patient prognosis through routine clinical or statistical analysis. Method: In this study, a deep neural network model is proposed for predicting survival based on simple clinical features, blood tests, axial computerized tomography scan images of lungs, and the patients' planned treatment. The model's architecture combines a Convolutional Neural Network and a Long Short Term Memory network. The model was trained using 390 survivors and 108 deceased patients from the Rasoul Akram Hospital and evaluated 109 surviving and 36 deceased patients infected by the omicron variant. Results: The proposed model reached an accuracy of 87.5% on the test data, indicating survival prediction possibility. The accuracy was significantly higher than the accuracy achieved by classical machine learning methods without considering computerized tomography scan images (p-value <= 4E-5). The images were also replaced with hand-crafted features related to the ratio of infected lung lobes used in classical machine-learning models. The highest-performing model reached an accuracy of 84.5%, which was considerably higher than the models trained on mere clinical information (p-value <= 0.006). However, the performance was still significantly less than the deep model (p-value <= 0.016). Conclusion: The proposed deep model achieved a higher accuracy than classical machine learning methods trained on features other than computerized tomography scan images. This proves the images contain extra information. Meanwhile, Artificial Intelligence methods with multimodal inputs can be more reliable and accurate than computerized tomography severity scores. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-10696006 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2023 |
publisher | Elsevier |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-106960062023-12-06 Predicting survival of Iranian COVID-19 patients infected by various variants including omicron from CT Scan images and clinical data using deep neural networks Ghafoori, Mahyar Hamidi, Mehrab Modegh, Rassa Ghavami Aziz-Ahari, Alireza Heydari, Neda Tavafizadeh, Zeynab Pournik, Omid Emdadi, Sasan Samimi, Saeed Mohseni, Amir Khaleghi, Mohammadreza Dashti, Hamed Rabiee, Hamid R. Heliyon Research Article Purpose: The rapid spread of the COVID-19 omicron variant virus has resulted in an overload of hospitals around the globe. As a result, many patients are deprived of hospital facilities, increasing mortality rates. Therefore, mortality rates can be reduced by efficiently assigning facilities to higher-risk patients. Therefore, it is crucial to estimate patients' survival probability based on their conditions at the time of admission so that the minimum required facilities can be provided, allowing more opportunities to be available for those who need them. Although radiologic findings in chest computerized tomography scans show various patterns, considering the individual risk factors and other underlying diseases, it is difficult to predict patient prognosis through routine clinical or statistical analysis. Method: In this study, a deep neural network model is proposed for predicting survival based on simple clinical features, blood tests, axial computerized tomography scan images of lungs, and the patients' planned treatment. The model's architecture combines a Convolutional Neural Network and a Long Short Term Memory network. The model was trained using 390 survivors and 108 deceased patients from the Rasoul Akram Hospital and evaluated 109 surviving and 36 deceased patients infected by the omicron variant. Results: The proposed model reached an accuracy of 87.5% on the test data, indicating survival prediction possibility. The accuracy was significantly higher than the accuracy achieved by classical machine learning methods without considering computerized tomography scan images (p-value <= 4E-5). The images were also replaced with hand-crafted features related to the ratio of infected lung lobes used in classical machine-learning models. The highest-performing model reached an accuracy of 84.5%, which was considerably higher than the models trained on mere clinical information (p-value <= 0.006). However, the performance was still significantly less than the deep model (p-value <= 0.016). Conclusion: The proposed deep model achieved a higher accuracy than classical machine learning methods trained on features other than computerized tomography scan images. This proves the images contain extra information. Meanwhile, Artificial Intelligence methods with multimodal inputs can be more reliable and accurate than computerized tomography severity scores. Elsevier 2023-11-08 /pmc/articles/PMC10696006/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e21965 Text en © 2023 The Author(s) https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/). |
spellingShingle | Research Article Ghafoori, Mahyar Hamidi, Mehrab Modegh, Rassa Ghavami Aziz-Ahari, Alireza Heydari, Neda Tavafizadeh, Zeynab Pournik, Omid Emdadi, Sasan Samimi, Saeed Mohseni, Amir Khaleghi, Mohammadreza Dashti, Hamed Rabiee, Hamid R. Predicting survival of Iranian COVID-19 patients infected by various variants including omicron from CT Scan images and clinical data using deep neural networks |
title | Predicting survival of Iranian COVID-19 patients infected by various variants including omicron from CT Scan images and clinical data using deep neural networks |
title_full | Predicting survival of Iranian COVID-19 patients infected by various variants including omicron from CT Scan images and clinical data using deep neural networks |
title_fullStr | Predicting survival of Iranian COVID-19 patients infected by various variants including omicron from CT Scan images and clinical data using deep neural networks |
title_full_unstemmed | Predicting survival of Iranian COVID-19 patients infected by various variants including omicron from CT Scan images and clinical data using deep neural networks |
title_short | Predicting survival of Iranian COVID-19 patients infected by various variants including omicron from CT Scan images and clinical data using deep neural networks |
title_sort | predicting survival of iranian covid-19 patients infected by various variants including omicron from ct scan images and clinical data using deep neural networks |
topic | Research Article |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10696006/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e21965 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT ghafoorimahyar predictingsurvivalofiraniancovid19patientsinfectedbyvariousvariantsincludingomicronfromctscanimagesandclinicaldatausingdeepneuralnetworks AT hamidimehrab predictingsurvivalofiraniancovid19patientsinfectedbyvariousvariantsincludingomicronfromctscanimagesandclinicaldatausingdeepneuralnetworks AT modeghrassaghavami predictingsurvivalofiraniancovid19patientsinfectedbyvariousvariantsincludingomicronfromctscanimagesandclinicaldatausingdeepneuralnetworks AT azizaharialireza predictingsurvivalofiraniancovid19patientsinfectedbyvariousvariantsincludingomicronfromctscanimagesandclinicaldatausingdeepneuralnetworks AT heydarineda predictingsurvivalofiraniancovid19patientsinfectedbyvariousvariantsincludingomicronfromctscanimagesandclinicaldatausingdeepneuralnetworks AT tavafizadehzeynab predictingsurvivalofiraniancovid19patientsinfectedbyvariousvariantsincludingomicronfromctscanimagesandclinicaldatausingdeepneuralnetworks AT pournikomid predictingsurvivalofiraniancovid19patientsinfectedbyvariousvariantsincludingomicronfromctscanimagesandclinicaldatausingdeepneuralnetworks AT emdadisasan predictingsurvivalofiraniancovid19patientsinfectedbyvariousvariantsincludingomicronfromctscanimagesandclinicaldatausingdeepneuralnetworks AT samimisaeed predictingsurvivalofiraniancovid19patientsinfectedbyvariousvariantsincludingomicronfromctscanimagesandclinicaldatausingdeepneuralnetworks AT mohseniamir predictingsurvivalofiraniancovid19patientsinfectedbyvariousvariantsincludingomicronfromctscanimagesandclinicaldatausingdeepneuralnetworks AT khaleghimohammadreza predictingsurvivalofiraniancovid19patientsinfectedbyvariousvariantsincludingomicronfromctscanimagesandclinicaldatausingdeepneuralnetworks AT dashtihamed predictingsurvivalofiraniancovid19patientsinfectedbyvariousvariantsincludingomicronfromctscanimagesandclinicaldatausingdeepneuralnetworks AT rabieehamidr predictingsurvivalofiraniancovid19patientsinfectedbyvariousvariantsincludingomicronfromctscanimagesandclinicaldatausingdeepneuralnetworks |