Cargando…

A Method for Subsampling Terrestrial Invertebrate Samples in the Laboratory: Estimating Abundance and Taxa Richness

Significant progress has been made in developing subsampling techniques to process large samples of aquatic invertebrates. However, limited information is available regarding subsampling techniques for terrestrial invertebrate samples. Therefore a novel subsampling procedure was evaluated for proces...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Doğramaci, Mahmut, DeBano, Sandra J., Wooster, David E., Kimoto, Chiho
Formato: Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: University of Wisconsin Library 2010
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3014723/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20578889
http://dx.doi.org/10.1673/031.010.2501
_version_ 1782195380322041856
author Doğramaci, Mahmut
DeBano, Sandra J.
Wooster, David E.
Kimoto, Chiho
author_facet Doğramaci, Mahmut
DeBano, Sandra J.
Wooster, David E.
Kimoto, Chiho
author_sort Doğramaci, Mahmut
collection PubMed
description Significant progress has been made in developing subsampling techniques to process large samples of aquatic invertebrates. However, limited information is available regarding subsampling techniques for terrestrial invertebrate samples. Therefore a novel subsampling procedure was evaluated for processing samples of terrestrial invertebrates collected using two common field techniques: pitfall and pan traps. A three-phase sorting protocol was developed for estimating abundance and taxa richness of invertebrates. First, large invertebrates and plant material were removed from the sample using a sieve with a 4 mm mesh size. Second, the sample was poured into a specially designed, gridded sampling tray, and 16 cells, comprising 25% of the sampling tray, were randomly subsampled and processed. Third, the remainder of the sample was scanned for 4–7 min to record rare taxa missed in the second phase. To compare estimated abundance and taxa richness with the true values of these variables for the samples, the remainder of each sample was processed completely. The results were analyzed relative to three sample size categories: samples with less than 250 invertebrates (low abundance samples), samples with 250–500 invertebrates (moderate abundance samples), and samples with more than 500 invertebrates (high abundance samples). The number of invertebrates estimated after subsampling eight or more cells was highly precise for all sizes and types of samples. High accuracy for moderate and high abundance samples was achieved after even as few as six subsamples. However, estimates of the number of invertebrates for low abundance samples were less reliable. The subsampling technique also adequately estimated taxa richness; on average, subsampling detected 89% of taxa found in samples. Thus, the subsampling technique provided accurate data on both the abundance and taxa richness of terrestrial invertebrate samples. Importantly, subsampling greatly decreased the time required to process samples, cutting the time per sample by up to 80%. Based on these data, this subsampling technique is recommended to minimize the time and cost of processing moderate to large samples without compromising the integrity of the data and to maximize the information extracted from large terrestrial invertebrate samples. For samples with a relatively low number of invertebrates, complete counting is preferred.
format Text
id pubmed-3014723
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2010
publisher University of Wisconsin Library
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-30147232012-02-09 A Method for Subsampling Terrestrial Invertebrate Samples in the Laboratory: Estimating Abundance and Taxa Richness Doğramaci, Mahmut DeBano, Sandra J. Wooster, David E. Kimoto, Chiho J Insect Sci Article Significant progress has been made in developing subsampling techniques to process large samples of aquatic invertebrates. However, limited information is available regarding subsampling techniques for terrestrial invertebrate samples. Therefore a novel subsampling procedure was evaluated for processing samples of terrestrial invertebrates collected using two common field techniques: pitfall and pan traps. A three-phase sorting protocol was developed for estimating abundance and taxa richness of invertebrates. First, large invertebrates and plant material were removed from the sample using a sieve with a 4 mm mesh size. Second, the sample was poured into a specially designed, gridded sampling tray, and 16 cells, comprising 25% of the sampling tray, were randomly subsampled and processed. Third, the remainder of the sample was scanned for 4–7 min to record rare taxa missed in the second phase. To compare estimated abundance and taxa richness with the true values of these variables for the samples, the remainder of each sample was processed completely. The results were analyzed relative to three sample size categories: samples with less than 250 invertebrates (low abundance samples), samples with 250–500 invertebrates (moderate abundance samples), and samples with more than 500 invertebrates (high abundance samples). The number of invertebrates estimated after subsampling eight or more cells was highly precise for all sizes and types of samples. High accuracy for moderate and high abundance samples was achieved after even as few as six subsamples. However, estimates of the number of invertebrates for low abundance samples were less reliable. The subsampling technique also adequately estimated taxa richness; on average, subsampling detected 89% of taxa found in samples. Thus, the subsampling technique provided accurate data on both the abundance and taxa richness of terrestrial invertebrate samples. Importantly, subsampling greatly decreased the time required to process samples, cutting the time per sample by up to 80%. Based on these data, this subsampling technique is recommended to minimize the time and cost of processing moderate to large samples without compromising the integrity of the data and to maximize the information extracted from large terrestrial invertebrate samples. For samples with a relatively low number of invertebrates, complete counting is preferred. University of Wisconsin Library 2010-03-25 /pmc/articles/PMC3014723/ /pubmed/20578889 http://dx.doi.org/10.1673/031.010.2501 Text en © 2010 http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.5/ This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
spellingShingle Article
Doğramaci, Mahmut
DeBano, Sandra J.
Wooster, David E.
Kimoto, Chiho
A Method for Subsampling Terrestrial Invertebrate Samples in the Laboratory: Estimating Abundance and Taxa Richness
title A Method for Subsampling Terrestrial Invertebrate Samples in the Laboratory: Estimating Abundance and Taxa Richness
title_full A Method for Subsampling Terrestrial Invertebrate Samples in the Laboratory: Estimating Abundance and Taxa Richness
title_fullStr A Method for Subsampling Terrestrial Invertebrate Samples in the Laboratory: Estimating Abundance and Taxa Richness
title_full_unstemmed A Method for Subsampling Terrestrial Invertebrate Samples in the Laboratory: Estimating Abundance and Taxa Richness
title_short A Method for Subsampling Terrestrial Invertebrate Samples in the Laboratory: Estimating Abundance and Taxa Richness
title_sort method for subsampling terrestrial invertebrate samples in the laboratory: estimating abundance and taxa richness
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3014723/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20578889
http://dx.doi.org/10.1673/031.010.2501
work_keys_str_mv AT dogramacimahmut amethodforsubsamplingterrestrialinvertebratesamplesinthelaboratoryestimatingabundanceandtaxarichness
AT debanosandraj amethodforsubsamplingterrestrialinvertebratesamplesinthelaboratoryestimatingabundanceandtaxarichness
AT woosterdavide amethodforsubsamplingterrestrialinvertebratesamplesinthelaboratoryestimatingabundanceandtaxarichness
AT kimotochiho amethodforsubsamplingterrestrialinvertebratesamplesinthelaboratoryestimatingabundanceandtaxarichness
AT dogramacimahmut methodforsubsamplingterrestrialinvertebratesamplesinthelaboratoryestimatingabundanceandtaxarichness
AT debanosandraj methodforsubsamplingterrestrialinvertebratesamplesinthelaboratoryestimatingabundanceandtaxarichness
AT woosterdavide methodforsubsamplingterrestrialinvertebratesamplesinthelaboratoryestimatingabundanceandtaxarichness
AT kimotochiho methodforsubsamplingterrestrialinvertebratesamplesinthelaboratoryestimatingabundanceandtaxarichness