A Laparoscopic Simulator Tool for Objective Measurement of Residents' Laparoscopic Ability

OBJECTIVE: We sought to develop an objective measurement of residents' laparoscopic ability by using a laparoscopic simulator assessment tool. METHODS: An inexpensive laparoscopic simulator was developed. Three laparoscopic assessment procedures were created: 1) bead/pom-pom drop, 2) checkerboard drill, and 3) bead manipulation. Two minimally invasive surgeons and 8 PGY 3/4 and 15 PGY 1 residents were timed performing the 3 procedures. Ten of the PGY 1 residents were retested at the end of their PGY 1 year. RESULTS: The minimally invasive surgeons completed the laparoscopic drills in approximately half the time of the PGY 3/4 (P=0.02), and PGY 3/4 were 60% faster than PGY 1 (P=0.01). PGY 1 completed the drills in half the time at the end of the PGY 1 year (P=0.005). As an objective measurement of residents' laparoscopic surgery competency, by the completion of the academic year, all PGY 1 residents must be able to complete the drills as fast as or faster than the original PGY 3/4 times. CONCLUSION: We developed an inexpensive, objective, simple laparoscopic simulator assessment tool for measurement of residents' laparoscopic ability.