Cargando…

The ATXN1 and TRIM31 genes are related to intelligence in an ADHD background: Evidence from a large collaborative study totaling 4,963 Subjects

Intelligence is a highly heritable trait for which it has proven difficult to identify the actual genes. In the past decade, five whole-genome linkage scans have suggested genomic regions important to human intelligence; however, so far none of the responsible genes or variants in those regions have...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Rizzi, Thais S, Arias-Vasquez, Alejandro, Rommelse, Nanda, Kuntsi, Jonna, Anney, Richard, Asherson, Philip, Buitelaar, Jan, Banaschewski, Tobias, Ebstein, Richard, Ruano, Dina, Van der Sluis, Sophie, Markunas, Christina A, Garrett, Melanie E, Ashley-Koch, Allison E, Kollins, Scott H, Anastopoulos, Arthur D, Hansell, Narelle K, Wright, Margaret J, Montgomery, Grant W, Martin, Nicholas G, Harris, Sarah E, Davies, Gail, Tenesa, Albert, Porteous, David J, Starr, John M, Deary, Ian J, St. Pourcain, Beate, Smith, George Davey, Timpson, Nicholas J, Evans, David M, Gill, Michael, Miranda, Ana, Mulas, Fernando, Oades, Robert D, Roeyers, Herbert, Rothenberger, Aribert, Sergeant, Joseph, Sonuga-Barke, Edmund, Steinhausen, Hans Christoph, Taylor, Eric, Faraone, Stephen V, Franke, Barbara, Posthuma, Danielle
Formato: Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Wiley Subscription Services, Inc., A Wiley Company 2011
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3085124/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21302343
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ajmg.b.31149
_version_ 1782202596036968448
author Rizzi, Thais S
Arias-Vasquez, Alejandro
Rommelse, Nanda
Kuntsi, Jonna
Anney, Richard
Asherson, Philip
Buitelaar, Jan
Banaschewski, Tobias
Ebstein, Richard
Ruano, Dina
Van der Sluis, Sophie
Markunas, Christina A
Garrett, Melanie E
Ashley-Koch, Allison E
Kollins, Scott H
Anastopoulos, Arthur D
Hansell, Narelle K
Wright, Margaret J
Montgomery, Grant W
Martin, Nicholas G
Harris, Sarah E
Davies, Gail
Tenesa, Albert
Porteous, David J
Starr, John M
Deary, Ian J
St. Pourcain, Beate
Smith, George Davey
Timpson, Nicholas J
Evans, David M
Gill, Michael
Miranda, Ana
Mulas, Fernando
Oades, Robert D
Roeyers, Herbert
Rothenberger, Aribert
Sergeant, Joseph
Sonuga-Barke, Edmund
Steinhausen, Hans Christoph
Taylor, Eric
Faraone, Stephen V
Franke, Barbara
Posthuma, Danielle
author_facet Rizzi, Thais S
Arias-Vasquez, Alejandro
Rommelse, Nanda
Kuntsi, Jonna
Anney, Richard
Asherson, Philip
Buitelaar, Jan
Banaschewski, Tobias
Ebstein, Richard
Ruano, Dina
Van der Sluis, Sophie
Markunas, Christina A
Garrett, Melanie E
Ashley-Koch, Allison E
Kollins, Scott H
Anastopoulos, Arthur D
Hansell, Narelle K
Wright, Margaret J
Montgomery, Grant W
Martin, Nicholas G
Harris, Sarah E
Davies, Gail
Tenesa, Albert
Porteous, David J
Starr, John M
Deary, Ian J
St. Pourcain, Beate
Smith, George Davey
Timpson, Nicholas J
Evans, David M
Gill, Michael
Miranda, Ana
Mulas, Fernando
Oades, Robert D
Roeyers, Herbert
Rothenberger, Aribert
Sergeant, Joseph
Sonuga-Barke, Edmund
Steinhausen, Hans Christoph
Taylor, Eric
Faraone, Stephen V
Franke, Barbara
Posthuma, Danielle
author_sort Rizzi, Thais S
collection PubMed
description Intelligence is a highly heritable trait for which it has proven difficult to identify the actual genes. In the past decade, five whole-genome linkage scans have suggested genomic regions important to human intelligence; however, so far none of the responsible genes or variants in those regions have been identified. Apart from these regions, a handful of candidate genes have been identified, although most of these are in need of replication. The recent growth in publicly available data sets that contain both whole genome association data and a wealth of phenotypic data, serves as an excellent resource for fine mapping and candidate gene replication. We used the publicly available data of 947 families participating in the International Multi-Centre ADHD Genetics (IMAGE) study to conduct an in silico fine mapping study of previously associated genomic locations, and to attempt replication of previously reported candidate genes for intelligence. Although this sample was ascertained for attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), intelligence quotient (IQ) scores were distributed normally. We tested 667 single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) within 15 previously reported candidate genes for intelligence and 29451 SNPs in five genomic loci previously identified through whole genome linkage and association analyses. Significant SNPs were tested in four independent samples (4,357 subjects), one ascertained for ADHD, and three population-based samples. Associations between intelligence and SNPs in the ATXN1 and TRIM31 genes and in three genomic locations showed replicated association, but only in the samples ascertained for ADHD, suggesting that these genetic variants become particularly relevant to IQ on the background of a psychiatric disorder. © 2010 Wiley-Liss, Inc.
format Text
id pubmed-3085124
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2011
publisher Wiley Subscription Services, Inc., A Wiley Company
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-30851242011-05-13 The ATXN1 and TRIM31 genes are related to intelligence in an ADHD background: Evidence from a large collaborative study totaling 4,963 Subjects Rizzi, Thais S Arias-Vasquez, Alejandro Rommelse, Nanda Kuntsi, Jonna Anney, Richard Asherson, Philip Buitelaar, Jan Banaschewski, Tobias Ebstein, Richard Ruano, Dina Van der Sluis, Sophie Markunas, Christina A Garrett, Melanie E Ashley-Koch, Allison E Kollins, Scott H Anastopoulos, Arthur D Hansell, Narelle K Wright, Margaret J Montgomery, Grant W Martin, Nicholas G Harris, Sarah E Davies, Gail Tenesa, Albert Porteous, David J Starr, John M Deary, Ian J St. Pourcain, Beate Smith, George Davey Timpson, Nicholas J Evans, David M Gill, Michael Miranda, Ana Mulas, Fernando Oades, Robert D Roeyers, Herbert Rothenberger, Aribert Sergeant, Joseph Sonuga-Barke, Edmund Steinhausen, Hans Christoph Taylor, Eric Faraone, Stephen V Franke, Barbara Posthuma, Danielle Am J Med Genet B Neuropsychiatr Genet Research Article Intelligence is a highly heritable trait for which it has proven difficult to identify the actual genes. In the past decade, five whole-genome linkage scans have suggested genomic regions important to human intelligence; however, so far none of the responsible genes or variants in those regions have been identified. Apart from these regions, a handful of candidate genes have been identified, although most of these are in need of replication. The recent growth in publicly available data sets that contain both whole genome association data and a wealth of phenotypic data, serves as an excellent resource for fine mapping and candidate gene replication. We used the publicly available data of 947 families participating in the International Multi-Centre ADHD Genetics (IMAGE) study to conduct an in silico fine mapping study of previously associated genomic locations, and to attempt replication of previously reported candidate genes for intelligence. Although this sample was ascertained for attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), intelligence quotient (IQ) scores were distributed normally. We tested 667 single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) within 15 previously reported candidate genes for intelligence and 29451 SNPs in five genomic loci previously identified through whole genome linkage and association analyses. Significant SNPs were tested in four independent samples (4,357 subjects), one ascertained for ADHD, and three population-based samples. Associations between intelligence and SNPs in the ATXN1 and TRIM31 genes and in three genomic locations showed replicated association, but only in the samples ascertained for ADHD, suggesting that these genetic variants become particularly relevant to IQ on the background of a psychiatric disorder. © 2010 Wiley-Liss, Inc. Wiley Subscription Services, Inc., A Wiley Company 2011-03 2010-12-16 /pmc/articles/PMC3085124/ /pubmed/21302343 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ajmg.b.31149 Text en Copyright © 2011 Wiley-Liss, Inc., A Wiley Company http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.5/ Re-use of this article is permitted in accordance with the Creative Commons Deed, Attribution 2.5, which does not permit commercial exploitation.
spellingShingle Research Article
Rizzi, Thais S
Arias-Vasquez, Alejandro
Rommelse, Nanda
Kuntsi, Jonna
Anney, Richard
Asherson, Philip
Buitelaar, Jan
Banaschewski, Tobias
Ebstein, Richard
Ruano, Dina
Van der Sluis, Sophie
Markunas, Christina A
Garrett, Melanie E
Ashley-Koch, Allison E
Kollins, Scott H
Anastopoulos, Arthur D
Hansell, Narelle K
Wright, Margaret J
Montgomery, Grant W
Martin, Nicholas G
Harris, Sarah E
Davies, Gail
Tenesa, Albert
Porteous, David J
Starr, John M
Deary, Ian J
St. Pourcain, Beate
Smith, George Davey
Timpson, Nicholas J
Evans, David M
Gill, Michael
Miranda, Ana
Mulas, Fernando
Oades, Robert D
Roeyers, Herbert
Rothenberger, Aribert
Sergeant, Joseph
Sonuga-Barke, Edmund
Steinhausen, Hans Christoph
Taylor, Eric
Faraone, Stephen V
Franke, Barbara
Posthuma, Danielle
The ATXN1 and TRIM31 genes are related to intelligence in an ADHD background: Evidence from a large collaborative study totaling 4,963 Subjects
title The ATXN1 and TRIM31 genes are related to intelligence in an ADHD background: Evidence from a large collaborative study totaling 4,963 Subjects
title_full The ATXN1 and TRIM31 genes are related to intelligence in an ADHD background: Evidence from a large collaborative study totaling 4,963 Subjects
title_fullStr The ATXN1 and TRIM31 genes are related to intelligence in an ADHD background: Evidence from a large collaborative study totaling 4,963 Subjects
title_full_unstemmed The ATXN1 and TRIM31 genes are related to intelligence in an ADHD background: Evidence from a large collaborative study totaling 4,963 Subjects
title_short The ATXN1 and TRIM31 genes are related to intelligence in an ADHD background: Evidence from a large collaborative study totaling 4,963 Subjects
title_sort atxn1 and trim31 genes are related to intelligence in an adhd background: evidence from a large collaborative study totaling 4,963 subjects
topic Research Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3085124/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21302343
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ajmg.b.31149
work_keys_str_mv AT rizzithaiss theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT ariasvasquezalejandro theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT rommelsenanda theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT kuntsijonna theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT anneyrichard theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT ashersonphilip theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT buitelaarjan theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT banaschewskitobias theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT ebsteinrichard theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT ruanodina theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT vandersluissophie theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT markunaschristinaa theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT garrettmelaniee theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT ashleykochallisone theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT kollinsscotth theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT anastopoulosarthurd theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT hansellnarellek theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT wrightmargaretj theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT montgomerygrantw theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT martinnicholasg theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT harrissarahe theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT daviesgail theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT tenesaalbert theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT porteousdavidj theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT starrjohnm theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT dearyianj theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT stpourcainbeate theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT smithgeorgedavey theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT timpsonnicholasj theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT evansdavidm theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT gillmichael theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT mirandaana theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT mulasfernando theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT oadesrobertd theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT roeyersherbert theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT rothenbergeraribert theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT sergeantjoseph theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT sonugabarkeedmund theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT steinhausenhanschristoph theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT tayloreric theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT faraonestephenv theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT frankebarbara theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT posthumadanielle theatxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT rizzithaiss atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT ariasvasquezalejandro atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT rommelsenanda atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT kuntsijonna atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT anneyrichard atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT ashersonphilip atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT buitelaarjan atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT banaschewskitobias atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT ebsteinrichard atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT ruanodina atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT vandersluissophie atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT markunaschristinaa atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT garrettmelaniee atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT ashleykochallisone atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT kollinsscotth atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT anastopoulosarthurd atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT hansellnarellek atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT wrightmargaretj atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT montgomerygrantw atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT martinnicholasg atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT harrissarahe atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT daviesgail atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT tenesaalbert atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT porteousdavidj atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT starrjohnm atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT dearyianj atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT stpourcainbeate atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT smithgeorgedavey atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT timpsonnicholasj atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT evansdavidm atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT gillmichael atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT mirandaana atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT mulasfernando atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT oadesrobertd atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT roeyersherbert atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT rothenbergeraribert atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT sergeantjoseph atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT sonugabarkeedmund atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT steinhausenhanschristoph atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT tayloreric atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT faraonestephenv atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT frankebarbara atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects
AT posthumadanielle atxn1andtrim31genesarerelatedtointelligenceinanadhdbackgroundevidencefromalargecollaborativestudytotaling4963subjects