Cargando…

A Robust Method of Measuring Other-Race and Other-Ethnicity Effects: The Cambridge Face Memory Test Format

Other-race and other-ethnicity effects on face memory have remained a topic of consistent research interest over several decades, across fields including face perception, social psychology, and forensic psychology (eyewitness testimony). Here we demonstrate that the Cambridge Face Memory Test format...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: McKone, Elinor, Stokes, Sacha, Liu, Jia, Cohan, Sarah, Fiorentini, Chiara, Pidcock, Madeleine, Yovel, Galit, Broughton, Mary, Pelleg, Michel
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Public Library of Science 2012
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3484147/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23118912
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0047956
_version_ 1782248111431745536
author McKone, Elinor
Stokes, Sacha
Liu, Jia
Cohan, Sarah
Fiorentini, Chiara
Pidcock, Madeleine
Yovel, Galit
Broughton, Mary
Pelleg, Michel
author_facet McKone, Elinor
Stokes, Sacha
Liu, Jia
Cohan, Sarah
Fiorentini, Chiara
Pidcock, Madeleine
Yovel, Galit
Broughton, Mary
Pelleg, Michel
author_sort McKone, Elinor
collection PubMed
description Other-race and other-ethnicity effects on face memory have remained a topic of consistent research interest over several decades, across fields including face perception, social psychology, and forensic psychology (eyewitness testimony). Here we demonstrate that the Cambridge Face Memory Test format provides a robust method for measuring these effects. Testing the Cambridge Face Memory Test original version (CFMT-original; European-ancestry faces from Boston USA) and a new Cambridge Face Memory Test Chinese (CFMT-Chinese), with European and Asian observers, we report a race-of-face by race-of-observer interaction that was highly significant despite modest sample size and despite observers who had quite high exposure to the other race. We attribute this to high statistical power arising from the very high internal reliability of the tasks. This power also allows us to demonstrate a much smaller within-race other ethnicity effect, based on differences in European physiognomy between Boston faces/observers and Australian faces/observers (using the CFMT-Australian).
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-3484147
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2012
publisher Public Library of Science
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-34841472012-11-01 A Robust Method of Measuring Other-Race and Other-Ethnicity Effects: The Cambridge Face Memory Test Format McKone, Elinor Stokes, Sacha Liu, Jia Cohan, Sarah Fiorentini, Chiara Pidcock, Madeleine Yovel, Galit Broughton, Mary Pelleg, Michel PLoS One Research Article Other-race and other-ethnicity effects on face memory have remained a topic of consistent research interest over several decades, across fields including face perception, social psychology, and forensic psychology (eyewitness testimony). Here we demonstrate that the Cambridge Face Memory Test format provides a robust method for measuring these effects. Testing the Cambridge Face Memory Test original version (CFMT-original; European-ancestry faces from Boston USA) and a new Cambridge Face Memory Test Chinese (CFMT-Chinese), with European and Asian observers, we report a race-of-face by race-of-observer interaction that was highly significant despite modest sample size and despite observers who had quite high exposure to the other race. We attribute this to high statistical power arising from the very high internal reliability of the tasks. This power also allows us to demonstrate a much smaller within-race other ethnicity effect, based on differences in European physiognomy between Boston faces/observers and Australian faces/observers (using the CFMT-Australian). Public Library of Science 2012-10-30 /pmc/articles/PMC3484147/ /pubmed/23118912 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0047956 Text en © 2012 McKone et al http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are properly credited.
spellingShingle Research Article
McKone, Elinor
Stokes, Sacha
Liu, Jia
Cohan, Sarah
Fiorentini, Chiara
Pidcock, Madeleine
Yovel, Galit
Broughton, Mary
Pelleg, Michel
A Robust Method of Measuring Other-Race and Other-Ethnicity Effects: The Cambridge Face Memory Test Format
title A Robust Method of Measuring Other-Race and Other-Ethnicity Effects: The Cambridge Face Memory Test Format
title_full A Robust Method of Measuring Other-Race and Other-Ethnicity Effects: The Cambridge Face Memory Test Format
title_fullStr A Robust Method of Measuring Other-Race and Other-Ethnicity Effects: The Cambridge Face Memory Test Format
title_full_unstemmed A Robust Method of Measuring Other-Race and Other-Ethnicity Effects: The Cambridge Face Memory Test Format
title_short A Robust Method of Measuring Other-Race and Other-Ethnicity Effects: The Cambridge Face Memory Test Format
title_sort robust method of measuring other-race and other-ethnicity effects: the cambridge face memory test format
topic Research Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3484147/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23118912
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0047956
work_keys_str_mv AT mckoneelinor arobustmethodofmeasuringotherraceandotherethnicityeffectsthecambridgefacememorytestformat
AT stokessacha arobustmethodofmeasuringotherraceandotherethnicityeffectsthecambridgefacememorytestformat
AT liujia arobustmethodofmeasuringotherraceandotherethnicityeffectsthecambridgefacememorytestformat
AT cohansarah arobustmethodofmeasuringotherraceandotherethnicityeffectsthecambridgefacememorytestformat
AT fiorentinichiara arobustmethodofmeasuringotherraceandotherethnicityeffectsthecambridgefacememorytestformat
AT pidcockmadeleine arobustmethodofmeasuringotherraceandotherethnicityeffectsthecambridgefacememorytestformat
AT yovelgalit arobustmethodofmeasuringotherraceandotherethnicityeffectsthecambridgefacememorytestformat
AT broughtonmary arobustmethodofmeasuringotherraceandotherethnicityeffectsthecambridgefacememorytestformat
AT pellegmichel arobustmethodofmeasuringotherraceandotherethnicityeffectsthecambridgefacememorytestformat
AT mckoneelinor robustmethodofmeasuringotherraceandotherethnicityeffectsthecambridgefacememorytestformat
AT stokessacha robustmethodofmeasuringotherraceandotherethnicityeffectsthecambridgefacememorytestformat
AT liujia robustmethodofmeasuringotherraceandotherethnicityeffectsthecambridgefacememorytestformat
AT cohansarah robustmethodofmeasuringotherraceandotherethnicityeffectsthecambridgefacememorytestformat
AT fiorentinichiara robustmethodofmeasuringotherraceandotherethnicityeffectsthecambridgefacememorytestformat
AT pidcockmadeleine robustmethodofmeasuringotherraceandotherethnicityeffectsthecambridgefacememorytestformat
AT yovelgalit robustmethodofmeasuringotherraceandotherethnicityeffectsthecambridgefacememorytestformat
AT broughtonmary robustmethodofmeasuringotherraceandotherethnicityeffectsthecambridgefacememorytestformat
AT pellegmichel robustmethodofmeasuringotherraceandotherethnicityeffectsthecambridgefacememorytestformat