Association of 3-Dimensional Cartilage and Bone Structure with Articular Cartilage Properties in and Adjacent to Autologous Osteochondral Grafts after 6 and 12 Months in a Goat Model

OBJECTIVE: The articular cartilage of autologous osteochondral grafts is typically different in structure and function from local host cartilage and thereby presents a remodeling challenge. The hypothesis of this study was that properties of the articular cartilage of trochlear autografts and adjacent femoral condyle are associated with the 3-dimensional (3-D) geometrical match between grafted and contralateral joints at 6 and 12 months after surgery. DESIGN: Autografts were transferred unilaterally from the lateral trochlea (LT) to the medial femoral condyle (MFC) in adult Spanish goats. Operated and contralateral nonoperated joints were harvested at 6 and 12 months and analyzed by indentation testing, micro–computed tomography, and histology to compare 1) histological indices of repair, 2) 3-D structure (articular surface deviation, bone-cartilage interface deviation, cartilage thickness), 3) indentation stiffness, and 4) correlations between stiffness and 3-D structure. RESULTS: Cartilage deterioration was present in grafts at 6 months and more severe at 12 months. Cartilage thickness and normalized stiffness of the operated MFC were lower than the nonoperated MFC within the graft and proximal adjacent host regions. Operated MFC articular surfaces were recessed relative to the nonoperated MFC and exhibited lower cartilage stiffness with increasing recession. Sites with large bone-cartilage interface deviations, both proud and recessed, were associated with recessed articular surfaces and low cartilage stiffness. CONCLUSION: The effectiveness of cartilage repair by osteochondral grafting is associated with the match of 3-D cartilage and bone geometry to the native osteochondral structure.