Cargando…

A Circle-Monitor for Computerised Assessment of Visual Neglect in Peripersonal Space

Current assessment of visual neglect involves paper-and-pencil tests or computer-based tasks. Both have been criticised because of their lack of ecological validity as target stimuli can only be presented in a restricted visual range. This study examined the user-friendliness and diagnostic strength...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Ulm, Lena, Wohlrapp, Dorota, Meinzer, Marcus, Steinicke, Robert, Schatz, Alexej, Denzler, Petra, Klehmet, Juliane, Dohle, Christian, Niedeggen, Michael, Meisel, Andreas, Winter, York
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Public Library of Science 2013
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3861461/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24349387
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0082892
_version_ 1782295641483902976
author Ulm, Lena
Wohlrapp, Dorota
Meinzer, Marcus
Steinicke, Robert
Schatz, Alexej
Denzler, Petra
Klehmet, Juliane
Dohle, Christian
Niedeggen, Michael
Meisel, Andreas
Winter, York
author_facet Ulm, Lena
Wohlrapp, Dorota
Meinzer, Marcus
Steinicke, Robert
Schatz, Alexej
Denzler, Petra
Klehmet, Juliane
Dohle, Christian
Niedeggen, Michael
Meisel, Andreas
Winter, York
author_sort Ulm, Lena
collection PubMed
description Current assessment of visual neglect involves paper-and-pencil tests or computer-based tasks. Both have been criticised because of their lack of ecological validity as target stimuli can only be presented in a restricted visual range. This study examined the user-friendliness and diagnostic strength of a new “Circle-Monitor” (CM), which enlarges the range of the peripersonal space, in comparison to a standard paper-and-pencil test (Neglect-Test, NET). METHODS: Ten stroke patients with neglect and ten age-matched healthy controls were examined by the NET and the CM test comprising of four subtests (Star Cancellation, Line Bisection, Dice Task, and Puzzle Test). RESULTS: The acceptance of the CM in elderly controls and neglect patients was high. Participants rated the examination by CM as clear, safe and more enjoyable than NET. Healthy controls performed at ceiling on all subtests, without any systematic differences between the visual fields. Both NET and CM revealed significant differences between controls and patients in Line Bisection, Star Cancellation and visuo-constructive tasks (NET: Figure Copying, CM: Puzzle Test). Discriminant analyses revealed cross-validated assignment of patients and controls to groups was more precise when based on the CM (hit rate 90%) as compared to the NET (hit rate 70%). CONCLUSION: The CM proved to be a sensitive novel tool to diagnose visual neglect symptoms quickly and accurately with superior diagnostic validity compared to a standard neglect test while being well accepted by patients. Due to its upgradable functions the system may also be a valuable tool not only to test for non-visual neglect symptoms, but also to provide treatment and assess its outcome.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-3861461
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2013
publisher Public Library of Science
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-38614612013-12-17 A Circle-Monitor for Computerised Assessment of Visual Neglect in Peripersonal Space Ulm, Lena Wohlrapp, Dorota Meinzer, Marcus Steinicke, Robert Schatz, Alexej Denzler, Petra Klehmet, Juliane Dohle, Christian Niedeggen, Michael Meisel, Andreas Winter, York PLoS One Research Article Current assessment of visual neglect involves paper-and-pencil tests or computer-based tasks. Both have been criticised because of their lack of ecological validity as target stimuli can only be presented in a restricted visual range. This study examined the user-friendliness and diagnostic strength of a new “Circle-Monitor” (CM), which enlarges the range of the peripersonal space, in comparison to a standard paper-and-pencil test (Neglect-Test, NET). METHODS: Ten stroke patients with neglect and ten age-matched healthy controls were examined by the NET and the CM test comprising of four subtests (Star Cancellation, Line Bisection, Dice Task, and Puzzle Test). RESULTS: The acceptance of the CM in elderly controls and neglect patients was high. Participants rated the examination by CM as clear, safe and more enjoyable than NET. Healthy controls performed at ceiling on all subtests, without any systematic differences between the visual fields. Both NET and CM revealed significant differences between controls and patients in Line Bisection, Star Cancellation and visuo-constructive tasks (NET: Figure Copying, CM: Puzzle Test). Discriminant analyses revealed cross-validated assignment of patients and controls to groups was more precise when based on the CM (hit rate 90%) as compared to the NET (hit rate 70%). CONCLUSION: The CM proved to be a sensitive novel tool to diagnose visual neglect symptoms quickly and accurately with superior diagnostic validity compared to a standard neglect test while being well accepted by patients. Due to its upgradable functions the system may also be a valuable tool not only to test for non-visual neglect symptoms, but also to provide treatment and assess its outcome. Public Library of Science 2013-12-12 /pmc/articles/PMC3861461/ /pubmed/24349387 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0082892 Text en © 2013 Ulm et al http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are properly credited.
spellingShingle Research Article
Ulm, Lena
Wohlrapp, Dorota
Meinzer, Marcus
Steinicke, Robert
Schatz, Alexej
Denzler, Petra
Klehmet, Juliane
Dohle, Christian
Niedeggen, Michael
Meisel, Andreas
Winter, York
A Circle-Monitor for Computerised Assessment of Visual Neglect in Peripersonal Space
title A Circle-Monitor for Computerised Assessment of Visual Neglect in Peripersonal Space
title_full A Circle-Monitor for Computerised Assessment of Visual Neglect in Peripersonal Space
title_fullStr A Circle-Monitor for Computerised Assessment of Visual Neglect in Peripersonal Space
title_full_unstemmed A Circle-Monitor for Computerised Assessment of Visual Neglect in Peripersonal Space
title_short A Circle-Monitor for Computerised Assessment of Visual Neglect in Peripersonal Space
title_sort circle-monitor for computerised assessment of visual neglect in peripersonal space
topic Research Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3861461/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24349387
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0082892
work_keys_str_mv AT ulmlena acirclemonitorforcomputerisedassessmentofvisualneglectinperipersonalspace
AT wohlrappdorota acirclemonitorforcomputerisedassessmentofvisualneglectinperipersonalspace
AT meinzermarcus acirclemonitorforcomputerisedassessmentofvisualneglectinperipersonalspace
AT steinickerobert acirclemonitorforcomputerisedassessmentofvisualneglectinperipersonalspace
AT schatzalexej acirclemonitorforcomputerisedassessmentofvisualneglectinperipersonalspace
AT denzlerpetra acirclemonitorforcomputerisedassessmentofvisualneglectinperipersonalspace
AT klehmetjuliane acirclemonitorforcomputerisedassessmentofvisualneglectinperipersonalspace
AT dohlechristian acirclemonitorforcomputerisedassessmentofvisualneglectinperipersonalspace
AT niedeggenmichael acirclemonitorforcomputerisedassessmentofvisualneglectinperipersonalspace
AT meiselandreas acirclemonitorforcomputerisedassessmentofvisualneglectinperipersonalspace
AT winteryork acirclemonitorforcomputerisedassessmentofvisualneglectinperipersonalspace
AT ulmlena circlemonitorforcomputerisedassessmentofvisualneglectinperipersonalspace
AT wohlrappdorota circlemonitorforcomputerisedassessmentofvisualneglectinperipersonalspace
AT meinzermarcus circlemonitorforcomputerisedassessmentofvisualneglectinperipersonalspace
AT steinickerobert circlemonitorforcomputerisedassessmentofvisualneglectinperipersonalspace
AT schatzalexej circlemonitorforcomputerisedassessmentofvisualneglectinperipersonalspace
AT denzlerpetra circlemonitorforcomputerisedassessmentofvisualneglectinperipersonalspace
AT klehmetjuliane circlemonitorforcomputerisedassessmentofvisualneglectinperipersonalspace
AT dohlechristian circlemonitorforcomputerisedassessmentofvisualneglectinperipersonalspace
AT niedeggenmichael circlemonitorforcomputerisedassessmentofvisualneglectinperipersonalspace
AT meiselandreas circlemonitorforcomputerisedassessmentofvisualneglectinperipersonalspace
AT winteryork circlemonitorforcomputerisedassessmentofvisualneglectinperipersonalspace