Relative biological effectiveness of therapeutic proton beams for HSG cells at Japanese proton therapy facilities

We investigated the relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of therapeutic proton beams at six proton facilities in Japan with respect to cell lethality of HSG cells. The RBE of treatments could be determined from experimental data. For this purpose, we used a cell survival assay to compare the cell-killing efficiency of proton beams. Among the five linear accelerator (LINAC) X-ray machines at 4 or 6 MeV that were used as reference beams, there was only a small variation (coefficient of variation CV = 3.1% at D(10)) in biological effectiveness. The averaged value of D(10) for the proton beams at the middle position of the spread-out Bragg peak (SOBP) was 4.98. These values showed good agreement, with a CV of 4.3% among the facilities. Thus, the average RBE(10) (RBE at the D(10) level) at the middle position of the SOBP beam for six facilities in Japan was 1.05 with a CV of 2.8%.