Cargando…

Alternative ways of representing Zapotec and Cuicatec folk classification of birds: a multidimensional model and its implications for culturally-informed conservation in Oaxaca, México

BACKGROUND: We report on a comparative ethno-ornithological study of Zapotec and Cuicatec communities in Northern Oaxaca, Mexico that provided a challenge to some existing descriptions of folk classification. Our default model was the taxonomic system of ranks developed by Brent Berlin. METHODS: Fie...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Alcántara-Salinas, Graciela, Ellen, Roy F, Valiñas-Coalla, Leopoldo, Caballero, Javier, Argueta-Villamar, Arturo
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: BioMed Central 2013
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4120933/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24321280
http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/1746-4269-9-81
_version_ 1782329154858909696
author Alcántara-Salinas, Graciela
Ellen, Roy F
Valiñas-Coalla, Leopoldo
Caballero, Javier
Argueta-Villamar, Arturo
author_facet Alcántara-Salinas, Graciela
Ellen, Roy F
Valiñas-Coalla, Leopoldo
Caballero, Javier
Argueta-Villamar, Arturo
author_sort Alcántara-Salinas, Graciela
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: We report on a comparative ethno-ornithological study of Zapotec and Cuicatec communities in Northern Oaxaca, Mexico that provided a challenge to some existing descriptions of folk classification. Our default model was the taxonomic system of ranks developed by Brent Berlin. METHODS: Fieldwork was conducted in the Zapotec village of San Miguel Tiltepec and in the Cuicatec village of San Juan Teponaxtla, using a combination of ethnographic interviews and pile-sorting tests. Post-fieldwork, Principal Component Analysis using NTSYSpc V. 2.11f was applied to obtain pattern variation for the answers from different participants. RESULTS AND CONCLUSION: Using language and pile-sorting data analysed through Principal Component Analysis, we show how both Zapotec and Cuicatec subjects place a particular emphasis on an intermediate level of classification. These categories group birds with non-birds using ecological and behavioral criteria, and violate a strict distinction between symbolic and mundane (or ‘natural’), and between ‘general-purpose’ and ‘single-purpose’ schemes. We suggest that shared classificatory knowledge embodying everyday schemes for apprehending the world of birds might be better reflected in a multidimensional model that would also provide a more realistic basis for developing culturally-informed conservation strategies.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-4120933
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2013
publisher BioMed Central
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-41209332014-08-05 Alternative ways of representing Zapotec and Cuicatec folk classification of birds: a multidimensional model and its implications for culturally-informed conservation in Oaxaca, México Alcántara-Salinas, Graciela Ellen, Roy F Valiñas-Coalla, Leopoldo Caballero, Javier Argueta-Villamar, Arturo J Ethnobiol Ethnomed Research BACKGROUND: We report on a comparative ethno-ornithological study of Zapotec and Cuicatec communities in Northern Oaxaca, Mexico that provided a challenge to some existing descriptions of folk classification. Our default model was the taxonomic system of ranks developed by Brent Berlin. METHODS: Fieldwork was conducted in the Zapotec village of San Miguel Tiltepec and in the Cuicatec village of San Juan Teponaxtla, using a combination of ethnographic interviews and pile-sorting tests. Post-fieldwork, Principal Component Analysis using NTSYSpc V. 2.11f was applied to obtain pattern variation for the answers from different participants. RESULTS AND CONCLUSION: Using language and pile-sorting data analysed through Principal Component Analysis, we show how both Zapotec and Cuicatec subjects place a particular emphasis on an intermediate level of classification. These categories group birds with non-birds using ecological and behavioral criteria, and violate a strict distinction between symbolic and mundane (or ‘natural’), and between ‘general-purpose’ and ‘single-purpose’ schemes. We suggest that shared classificatory knowledge embodying everyday schemes for apprehending the world of birds might be better reflected in a multidimensional model that would also provide a more realistic basis for developing culturally-informed conservation strategies. BioMed Central 2013-12-09 /pmc/articles/PMC4120933/ /pubmed/24321280 http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/1746-4269-9-81 Text en Copyright © 2013 Alcántara-Salinas et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0 This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
spellingShingle Research
Alcántara-Salinas, Graciela
Ellen, Roy F
Valiñas-Coalla, Leopoldo
Caballero, Javier
Argueta-Villamar, Arturo
Alternative ways of representing Zapotec and Cuicatec folk classification of birds: a multidimensional model and its implications for culturally-informed conservation in Oaxaca, México
title Alternative ways of representing Zapotec and Cuicatec folk classification of birds: a multidimensional model and its implications for culturally-informed conservation in Oaxaca, México
title_full Alternative ways of representing Zapotec and Cuicatec folk classification of birds: a multidimensional model and its implications for culturally-informed conservation in Oaxaca, México
title_fullStr Alternative ways of representing Zapotec and Cuicatec folk classification of birds: a multidimensional model and its implications for culturally-informed conservation in Oaxaca, México
title_full_unstemmed Alternative ways of representing Zapotec and Cuicatec folk classification of birds: a multidimensional model and its implications for culturally-informed conservation in Oaxaca, México
title_short Alternative ways of representing Zapotec and Cuicatec folk classification of birds: a multidimensional model and its implications for culturally-informed conservation in Oaxaca, México
title_sort alternative ways of representing zapotec and cuicatec folk classification of birds: a multidimensional model and its implications for culturally-informed conservation in oaxaca, méxico
topic Research
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4120933/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24321280
http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/1746-4269-9-81
work_keys_str_mv AT alcantarasalinasgraciela alternativewaysofrepresentingzapotecandcuicatecfolkclassificationofbirdsamultidimensionalmodelanditsimplicationsforculturallyinformedconservationinoaxacamexico
AT ellenroyf alternativewaysofrepresentingzapotecandcuicatecfolkclassificationofbirdsamultidimensionalmodelanditsimplicationsforculturallyinformedconservationinoaxacamexico
AT valinascoallaleopoldo alternativewaysofrepresentingzapotecandcuicatecfolkclassificationofbirdsamultidimensionalmodelanditsimplicationsforculturallyinformedconservationinoaxacamexico
AT caballerojavier alternativewaysofrepresentingzapotecandcuicatecfolkclassificationofbirdsamultidimensionalmodelanditsimplicationsforculturallyinformedconservationinoaxacamexico
AT arguetavillamararturo alternativewaysofrepresentingzapotecandcuicatecfolkclassificationofbirdsamultidimensionalmodelanditsimplicationsforculturallyinformedconservationinoaxacamexico