Cargando…

A Randomized Prospective Study of Bowel Preparation for Colonoscopy with Low-Dose Sodium Phosphate Tablets versus Polyethylene Glycol Electrolyte Solution

Optimal bowel preparation is essential for the safety and outcome of colonoscopy. A solution containing polyethylene glycol (PEG) is often used as a bowel cleansing agent, but some patients are intolerant of PEG, and this may lead to discontinuation of colonoscopy. Sodium phosphates (NaP) tablets ar...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Kumagai, Erina, Shibuya, Tomoyoshi, Makino, Masae, Murakami, Takashi, Takashima, Shiori, Ritsuno, Hideaki, Ueyama, Hiroya, Kodani, Tomohiro, Sasaki, Hitoshi, Matsumoto, Kenshi, Sakamoto, Naoto, Osada, Taro, Nagahara, Akihito, Ogihara, Tatsuo, Watanabe, Sumio
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Hindawi Publishing Corporation 2014
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4181789/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25309588
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2014/879749
_version_ 1782337421430489088
author Kumagai, Erina
Shibuya, Tomoyoshi
Makino, Masae
Murakami, Takashi
Takashima, Shiori
Ritsuno, Hideaki
Ueyama, Hiroya
Kodani, Tomohiro
Sasaki, Hitoshi
Matsumoto, Kenshi
Sakamoto, Naoto
Osada, Taro
Nagahara, Akihito
Ogihara, Tatsuo
Watanabe, Sumio
author_facet Kumagai, Erina
Shibuya, Tomoyoshi
Makino, Masae
Murakami, Takashi
Takashima, Shiori
Ritsuno, Hideaki
Ueyama, Hiroya
Kodani, Tomohiro
Sasaki, Hitoshi
Matsumoto, Kenshi
Sakamoto, Naoto
Osada, Taro
Nagahara, Akihito
Ogihara, Tatsuo
Watanabe, Sumio
author_sort Kumagai, Erina
collection PubMed
description Optimal bowel preparation is essential for the safety and outcome of colonoscopy. A solution containing polyethylene glycol (PEG) is often used as a bowel cleansing agent, but some patients are intolerant of PEG, and this may lead to discontinuation of colonoscopy. Sodium phosphates (NaP) tablets are designed to improve patient acceptance and compliance. The objective of this study was to compare bowel preparation efficiency and patient acceptance of a 30 NaP tablet preparation (L-NaP) and a 2 L PEG preparation. Patients were randomized into either the L-NaP or PEG group. The primary endpoint was the efficiency of colon cleansing as assessed by a validated four-point scale according to the Aronchick scale by endoscopists and was verified by blinded investigators. The secondary endpoints were patients' tolerability and acceptance. Colon-cleansing efficiency was not significantly different between the two preparations. However, patients' overall judgment was significantly in favor of L-NaP, reflecting better acceptance of L-NaP than PEG. Additionally, more patients favored L-NaP over PEG in a hypothetical future occasion requiring colonoscopy.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-4181789
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2014
publisher Hindawi Publishing Corporation
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-41817892014-10-12 A Randomized Prospective Study of Bowel Preparation for Colonoscopy with Low-Dose Sodium Phosphate Tablets versus Polyethylene Glycol Electrolyte Solution Kumagai, Erina Shibuya, Tomoyoshi Makino, Masae Murakami, Takashi Takashima, Shiori Ritsuno, Hideaki Ueyama, Hiroya Kodani, Tomohiro Sasaki, Hitoshi Matsumoto, Kenshi Sakamoto, Naoto Osada, Taro Nagahara, Akihito Ogihara, Tatsuo Watanabe, Sumio Gastroenterol Res Pract Clinical Study Optimal bowel preparation is essential for the safety and outcome of colonoscopy. A solution containing polyethylene glycol (PEG) is often used as a bowel cleansing agent, but some patients are intolerant of PEG, and this may lead to discontinuation of colonoscopy. Sodium phosphates (NaP) tablets are designed to improve patient acceptance and compliance. The objective of this study was to compare bowel preparation efficiency and patient acceptance of a 30 NaP tablet preparation (L-NaP) and a 2 L PEG preparation. Patients were randomized into either the L-NaP or PEG group. The primary endpoint was the efficiency of colon cleansing as assessed by a validated four-point scale according to the Aronchick scale by endoscopists and was verified by blinded investigators. The secondary endpoints were patients' tolerability and acceptance. Colon-cleansing efficiency was not significantly different between the two preparations. However, patients' overall judgment was significantly in favor of L-NaP, reflecting better acceptance of L-NaP than PEG. Additionally, more patients favored L-NaP over PEG in a hypothetical future occasion requiring colonoscopy. Hindawi Publishing Corporation 2014 2014-09-15 /pmc/articles/PMC4181789/ /pubmed/25309588 http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2014/879749 Text en Copyright © 2014 Erina Kumagai et al. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
spellingShingle Clinical Study
Kumagai, Erina
Shibuya, Tomoyoshi
Makino, Masae
Murakami, Takashi
Takashima, Shiori
Ritsuno, Hideaki
Ueyama, Hiroya
Kodani, Tomohiro
Sasaki, Hitoshi
Matsumoto, Kenshi
Sakamoto, Naoto
Osada, Taro
Nagahara, Akihito
Ogihara, Tatsuo
Watanabe, Sumio
A Randomized Prospective Study of Bowel Preparation for Colonoscopy with Low-Dose Sodium Phosphate Tablets versus Polyethylene Glycol Electrolyte Solution
title A Randomized Prospective Study of Bowel Preparation for Colonoscopy with Low-Dose Sodium Phosphate Tablets versus Polyethylene Glycol Electrolyte Solution
title_full A Randomized Prospective Study of Bowel Preparation for Colonoscopy with Low-Dose Sodium Phosphate Tablets versus Polyethylene Glycol Electrolyte Solution
title_fullStr A Randomized Prospective Study of Bowel Preparation for Colonoscopy with Low-Dose Sodium Phosphate Tablets versus Polyethylene Glycol Electrolyte Solution
title_full_unstemmed A Randomized Prospective Study of Bowel Preparation for Colonoscopy with Low-Dose Sodium Phosphate Tablets versus Polyethylene Glycol Electrolyte Solution
title_short A Randomized Prospective Study of Bowel Preparation for Colonoscopy with Low-Dose Sodium Phosphate Tablets versus Polyethylene Glycol Electrolyte Solution
title_sort randomized prospective study of bowel preparation for colonoscopy with low-dose sodium phosphate tablets versus polyethylene glycol electrolyte solution
topic Clinical Study
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4181789/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25309588
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2014/879749
work_keys_str_mv AT kumagaierina arandomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT shibuyatomoyoshi arandomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT makinomasae arandomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT murakamitakashi arandomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT takashimashiori arandomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT ritsunohideaki arandomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT ueyamahiroya arandomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT kodanitomohiro arandomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT sasakihitoshi arandomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT matsumotokenshi arandomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT sakamotonaoto arandomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT osadataro arandomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT nagaharaakihito arandomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT ogiharatatsuo arandomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT watanabesumio arandomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT kumagaierina randomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT shibuyatomoyoshi randomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT makinomasae randomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT murakamitakashi randomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT takashimashiori randomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT ritsunohideaki randomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT ueyamahiroya randomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT kodanitomohiro randomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT sasakihitoshi randomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT matsumotokenshi randomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT sakamotonaoto randomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT osadataro randomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT nagaharaakihito randomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT ogiharatatsuo randomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution
AT watanabesumio randomizedprospectivestudyofbowelpreparationforcolonoscopywithlowdosesodiumphosphatetabletsversuspolyethyleneglycolelectrolytesolution