Cargando…

Comparison of colistin monotherapy and non-colistin combinations in the treatment of multi-drug resistant Acinetobacter spp. bloodstream infections: A Multicenter retrospective analysis

OBJECTIVES: To compare the efficacy of colistin (COL) monotherapy versus non-COL based combinations in the treatment of bloodstream infections (BSIs) due to multidrug resistant Acinetobacter spp.(MDR-A). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Retrospective data of 107 MDR-A BSI cases from 27 tertiary centers in Tur...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Balkan, Ilker Inanc, Batirel, Ayse, Karabay, Oguz, Agalar, Canan, Akalin, Serife, Alici, Ozlem, Alp, Emine, Altay, Fatma Aybala, Altin, Nilgun, Arslan, Ferhat, Aslan, Turan, Bekiroglu, Nural, Cesur, Salih, Celik, Aygul Dogan, Dogan, Mustafa, Durdu, Bulent, Duygu, Fazilet, Engin, Aynur, Engin, Derya Ozturk, Gonen, Ibak, Guclu, Ertugrul, Guven, Tumer, Hatipoglu, Cigdem Ataman, Hosoglu, Salih, Karahocagil, Mustafa Kasim, Kilic, Aysegul Ulu, Ormen, Bahar, Ozdemir, Davut, Ozer, Serdar, Oztoprak, Nefise, Sezak, Nurbanu, Turhan, Vedat, Turker, Nesrin, Yilmaz, Hava
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Medknow Publications & Media Pvt Ltd 2015
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4375827/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25821319
http://dx.doi.org/10.4103/0253-7613.150383
_version_ 1782363640993677312
author Balkan, Ilker Inanc
Batirel, Ayse
Karabay, Oguz
Agalar, Canan
Akalin, Serife
Alici, Ozlem
Alp, Emine
Altay, Fatma Aybala
Altin, Nilgun
Arslan, Ferhat
Aslan, Turan
Bekiroglu, Nural
Cesur, Salih
Celik, Aygul Dogan
Dogan, Mustafa
Durdu, Bulent
Duygu, Fazilet
Engin, Aynur
Engin, Derya Ozturk
Gonen, Ibak
Guclu, Ertugrul
Guven, Tumer
Hatipoglu, Cigdem Ataman
Hosoglu, Salih
Karahocagil, Mustafa Kasim
Kilic, Aysegul Ulu
Ormen, Bahar
Ozdemir, Davut
Ozer, Serdar
Oztoprak, Nefise
Sezak, Nurbanu
Turhan, Vedat
Turker, Nesrin
Yilmaz, Hava
author_facet Balkan, Ilker Inanc
Batirel, Ayse
Karabay, Oguz
Agalar, Canan
Akalin, Serife
Alici, Ozlem
Alp, Emine
Altay, Fatma Aybala
Altin, Nilgun
Arslan, Ferhat
Aslan, Turan
Bekiroglu, Nural
Cesur, Salih
Celik, Aygul Dogan
Dogan, Mustafa
Durdu, Bulent
Duygu, Fazilet
Engin, Aynur
Engin, Derya Ozturk
Gonen, Ibak
Guclu, Ertugrul
Guven, Tumer
Hatipoglu, Cigdem Ataman
Hosoglu, Salih
Karahocagil, Mustafa Kasim
Kilic, Aysegul Ulu
Ormen, Bahar
Ozdemir, Davut
Ozer, Serdar
Oztoprak, Nefise
Sezak, Nurbanu
Turhan, Vedat
Turker, Nesrin
Yilmaz, Hava
author_sort Balkan, Ilker Inanc
collection PubMed
description OBJECTIVES: To compare the efficacy of colistin (COL) monotherapy versus non-COL based combinations in the treatment of bloodstream infections (BSIs) due to multidrug resistant Acinetobacter spp.(MDR-A). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Retrospective data of 107 MDR-A BSI cases from 27 tertiary centers in Turkey were included. PRIMARY END-POINT: 14-day mortality. SECONDARY END-POINTS: Microbial eradication and clinical improvement. RESULTS: Thirty-six patients in the COL monotherapy (CM) group and 71 in the non-COL based combinations (NCC) group were included in the study. Mean age was 59.98 ± 20 years (range: 18–89) and 50.5% were male. Median duration of follow-up was 40 days (range: 9–297). The 14-day survival rates were 52.8% in CM and 47.23% in NCC group (P = 0.36). Microbiological eradication was achieved in 69% of CM and 83% of NCC group (P = 0.13). Treatment failure was detected in 22.9% of cases in both CM and NCC groups. Univariate analysis revealed that mean age (P = 0.001), Charlson comorbidity index (P = 0.03), duration of hospital stay before MDR-A BSI (P = 0.04), Pitt bacteremia score (P = 0.043) and Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation II score (P = 0.05) were significant in terms of 14-day mortality. Advanced age (P = 0.01) and duration of hospital stay before MDR-A BSI (P = 0.04) were independently associated with 14-day mortality in multivariate analysis. CONCLUSION: No significant difference was detected between CM and non-COL based combinations in the treatment of MDR-A BSIs in terms of efficacy and 14-day mortality.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-4375827
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2015
publisher Medknow Publications & Media Pvt Ltd
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-43758272015-03-27 Comparison of colistin monotherapy and non-colistin combinations in the treatment of multi-drug resistant Acinetobacter spp. bloodstream infections: A Multicenter retrospective analysis Balkan, Ilker Inanc Batirel, Ayse Karabay, Oguz Agalar, Canan Akalin, Serife Alici, Ozlem Alp, Emine Altay, Fatma Aybala Altin, Nilgun Arslan, Ferhat Aslan, Turan Bekiroglu, Nural Cesur, Salih Celik, Aygul Dogan Dogan, Mustafa Durdu, Bulent Duygu, Fazilet Engin, Aynur Engin, Derya Ozturk Gonen, Ibak Guclu, Ertugrul Guven, Tumer Hatipoglu, Cigdem Ataman Hosoglu, Salih Karahocagil, Mustafa Kasim Kilic, Aysegul Ulu Ormen, Bahar Ozdemir, Davut Ozer, Serdar Oztoprak, Nefise Sezak, Nurbanu Turhan, Vedat Turker, Nesrin Yilmaz, Hava Indian J Pharmacol Research Article OBJECTIVES: To compare the efficacy of colistin (COL) monotherapy versus non-COL based combinations in the treatment of bloodstream infections (BSIs) due to multidrug resistant Acinetobacter spp.(MDR-A). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Retrospective data of 107 MDR-A BSI cases from 27 tertiary centers in Turkey were included. PRIMARY END-POINT: 14-day mortality. SECONDARY END-POINTS: Microbial eradication and clinical improvement. RESULTS: Thirty-six patients in the COL monotherapy (CM) group and 71 in the non-COL based combinations (NCC) group were included in the study. Mean age was 59.98 ± 20 years (range: 18–89) and 50.5% were male. Median duration of follow-up was 40 days (range: 9–297). The 14-day survival rates were 52.8% in CM and 47.23% in NCC group (P = 0.36). Microbiological eradication was achieved in 69% of CM and 83% of NCC group (P = 0.13). Treatment failure was detected in 22.9% of cases in both CM and NCC groups. Univariate analysis revealed that mean age (P = 0.001), Charlson comorbidity index (P = 0.03), duration of hospital stay before MDR-A BSI (P = 0.04), Pitt bacteremia score (P = 0.043) and Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation II score (P = 0.05) were significant in terms of 14-day mortality. Advanced age (P = 0.01) and duration of hospital stay before MDR-A BSI (P = 0.04) were independently associated with 14-day mortality in multivariate analysis. CONCLUSION: No significant difference was detected between CM and non-COL based combinations in the treatment of MDR-A BSIs in terms of efficacy and 14-day mortality. Medknow Publications & Media Pvt Ltd 2015 /pmc/articles/PMC4375827/ /pubmed/25821319 http://dx.doi.org/10.4103/0253-7613.150383 Text en Copyright: © Indian Journal of Pharmacology http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0 This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 Unported, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
spellingShingle Research Article
Balkan, Ilker Inanc
Batirel, Ayse
Karabay, Oguz
Agalar, Canan
Akalin, Serife
Alici, Ozlem
Alp, Emine
Altay, Fatma Aybala
Altin, Nilgun
Arslan, Ferhat
Aslan, Turan
Bekiroglu, Nural
Cesur, Salih
Celik, Aygul Dogan
Dogan, Mustafa
Durdu, Bulent
Duygu, Fazilet
Engin, Aynur
Engin, Derya Ozturk
Gonen, Ibak
Guclu, Ertugrul
Guven, Tumer
Hatipoglu, Cigdem Ataman
Hosoglu, Salih
Karahocagil, Mustafa Kasim
Kilic, Aysegul Ulu
Ormen, Bahar
Ozdemir, Davut
Ozer, Serdar
Oztoprak, Nefise
Sezak, Nurbanu
Turhan, Vedat
Turker, Nesrin
Yilmaz, Hava
Comparison of colistin monotherapy and non-colistin combinations in the treatment of multi-drug resistant Acinetobacter spp. bloodstream infections: A Multicenter retrospective analysis
title Comparison of colistin monotherapy and non-colistin combinations in the treatment of multi-drug resistant Acinetobacter spp. bloodstream infections: A Multicenter retrospective analysis
title_full Comparison of colistin monotherapy and non-colistin combinations in the treatment of multi-drug resistant Acinetobacter spp. bloodstream infections: A Multicenter retrospective analysis
title_fullStr Comparison of colistin monotherapy and non-colistin combinations in the treatment of multi-drug resistant Acinetobacter spp. bloodstream infections: A Multicenter retrospective analysis
title_full_unstemmed Comparison of colistin monotherapy and non-colistin combinations in the treatment of multi-drug resistant Acinetobacter spp. bloodstream infections: A Multicenter retrospective analysis
title_short Comparison of colistin monotherapy and non-colistin combinations in the treatment of multi-drug resistant Acinetobacter spp. bloodstream infections: A Multicenter retrospective analysis
title_sort comparison of colistin monotherapy and non-colistin combinations in the treatment of multi-drug resistant acinetobacter spp. bloodstream infections: a multicenter retrospective analysis
topic Research Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4375827/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25821319
http://dx.doi.org/10.4103/0253-7613.150383
work_keys_str_mv AT balkanilkerinanc comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT batirelayse comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT karabayoguz comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT agalarcanan comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT akalinserife comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT aliciozlem comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT alpemine comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT altayfatmaaybala comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT altinnilgun comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT arslanferhat comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT aslanturan comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT bekiroglunural comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT cesursalih comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT celikayguldogan comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT doganmustafa comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT durdubulent comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT duygufazilet comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT enginaynur comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT enginderyaozturk comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT gonenibak comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT gucluertugrul comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT guventumer comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT hatipoglucigdemataman comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT hosoglusalih comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT karahocagilmustafakasim comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT kilicaysegululu comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT ormenbahar comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT ozdemirdavut comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT ozerserdar comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT oztopraknefise comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT sezaknurbanu comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT turhanvedat comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT turkernesrin comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis
AT yilmazhava comparisonofcolistinmonotherapyandnoncolistincombinationsinthetreatmentofmultidrugresistantacinetobactersppbloodstreaminfectionsamulticenterretrospectiveanalysis