Cargando…
An international data set for CMML validates prognostic scoring systems and demonstrates a need for novel prognostication strategies
Since its reclassification as a distinct disease entity, clinical research efforts have attempted to establish baseline characteristics and prognostic scoring systems for chronic myelomonocytic leukemia (CMML). Although existing data for baseline characteristics and CMML prognostication have been ro...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Nature Publishing Group
2015
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4526779/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26230957 http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/bcj.2015.53 |
_version_ | 1782384466284511232 |
---|---|
author | Padron, E Garcia-Manero, G Patnaik, M M Itzykson, R Lasho, T Nazha, A Rampal, R K Sanchez, M E Jabbour, E Al Ali, N H Thompson, Z Colla, S Fenaux, P Kantarjian, H M Killick, S Sekeres, M A List, A F Onida, F Komrokji, R S Tefferi, A Solary, E |
author_facet | Padron, E Garcia-Manero, G Patnaik, M M Itzykson, R Lasho, T Nazha, A Rampal, R K Sanchez, M E Jabbour, E Al Ali, N H Thompson, Z Colla, S Fenaux, P Kantarjian, H M Killick, S Sekeres, M A List, A F Onida, F Komrokji, R S Tefferi, A Solary, E |
author_sort | Padron, E |
collection | PubMed |
description | Since its reclassification as a distinct disease entity, clinical research efforts have attempted to establish baseline characteristics and prognostic scoring systems for chronic myelomonocytic leukemia (CMML). Although existing data for baseline characteristics and CMML prognostication have been robustly developed and externally validated, these results have been limited by the small size of single-institution cohorts. We developed an international CMML data set that included 1832 cases across eight centers to establish the frequency of key clinical characteristics. Of note, we found that the majority of CMML patients were classified as World Health Organization CMML-1 and that a 7.5% bone marrow blast cut-point may discriminate prognosis with higher resolution in comparison with the existing 10%. We additionally interrogated existing CMML prognostic models and found that they are all valid and have comparable performance but are vulnerable to upstaging. Using random forest survival analysis for variable discovery, we demonstrated that the prognostic power of clinical variables alone is limited. Last, we confirmed the independent prognostic relevance of ASXL1 gene mutations and identified the novel adverse prognostic impact imparted by CBL mutations. Our data suggest that combinations of clinical and molecular information may be required to improve the accuracy of current CMML prognostication. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-4526779 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2015 |
publisher | Nature Publishing Group |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-45267792015-08-06 An international data set for CMML validates prognostic scoring systems and demonstrates a need for novel prognostication strategies Padron, E Garcia-Manero, G Patnaik, M M Itzykson, R Lasho, T Nazha, A Rampal, R K Sanchez, M E Jabbour, E Al Ali, N H Thompson, Z Colla, S Fenaux, P Kantarjian, H M Killick, S Sekeres, M A List, A F Onida, F Komrokji, R S Tefferi, A Solary, E Blood Cancer J Original Article Since its reclassification as a distinct disease entity, clinical research efforts have attempted to establish baseline characteristics and prognostic scoring systems for chronic myelomonocytic leukemia (CMML). Although existing data for baseline characteristics and CMML prognostication have been robustly developed and externally validated, these results have been limited by the small size of single-institution cohorts. We developed an international CMML data set that included 1832 cases across eight centers to establish the frequency of key clinical characteristics. Of note, we found that the majority of CMML patients were classified as World Health Organization CMML-1 and that a 7.5% bone marrow blast cut-point may discriminate prognosis with higher resolution in comparison with the existing 10%. We additionally interrogated existing CMML prognostic models and found that they are all valid and have comparable performance but are vulnerable to upstaging. Using random forest survival analysis for variable discovery, we demonstrated that the prognostic power of clinical variables alone is limited. Last, we confirmed the independent prognostic relevance of ASXL1 gene mutations and identified the novel adverse prognostic impact imparted by CBL mutations. Our data suggest that combinations of clinical and molecular information may be required to improve the accuracy of current CMML prognostication. Nature Publishing Group 2015-07 2015-07-31 /pmc/articles/PMC4526779/ /pubmed/26230957 http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/bcj.2015.53 Text en Copyright © 2015 Macmillan Publishers Limited http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in the credit line; if the material is not included under the Creative Commons license, users will need to obtain permission from the license holder to reproduce the material. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
spellingShingle | Original Article Padron, E Garcia-Manero, G Patnaik, M M Itzykson, R Lasho, T Nazha, A Rampal, R K Sanchez, M E Jabbour, E Al Ali, N H Thompson, Z Colla, S Fenaux, P Kantarjian, H M Killick, S Sekeres, M A List, A F Onida, F Komrokji, R S Tefferi, A Solary, E An international data set for CMML validates prognostic scoring systems and demonstrates a need for novel prognostication strategies |
title | An international data set for CMML validates prognostic scoring systems and demonstrates a need for novel prognostication strategies |
title_full | An international data set for CMML validates prognostic scoring systems and demonstrates a need for novel prognostication strategies |
title_fullStr | An international data set for CMML validates prognostic scoring systems and demonstrates a need for novel prognostication strategies |
title_full_unstemmed | An international data set for CMML validates prognostic scoring systems and demonstrates a need for novel prognostication strategies |
title_short | An international data set for CMML validates prognostic scoring systems and demonstrates a need for novel prognostication strategies |
title_sort | international data set for cmml validates prognostic scoring systems and demonstrates a need for novel prognostication strategies |
topic | Original Article |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4526779/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26230957 http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/bcj.2015.53 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT padrone aninternationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT garciamanerog aninternationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT patnaikmm aninternationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT itzyksonr aninternationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT lashot aninternationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT nazhaa aninternationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT rampalrk aninternationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT sanchezme aninternationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT jabboure aninternationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT alalinh aninternationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT thompsonz aninternationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT collas aninternationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT fenauxp aninternationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT kantarjianhm aninternationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT killicks aninternationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT sekeresma aninternationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT listaf aninternationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT onidaf aninternationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT komrokjirs aninternationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT tefferia aninternationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT solarye aninternationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT padrone internationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT garciamanerog internationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT patnaikmm internationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT itzyksonr internationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT lashot internationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT nazhaa internationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT rampalrk internationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT sanchezme internationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT jabboure internationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT alalinh internationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT thompsonz internationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT collas internationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT fenauxp internationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT kantarjianhm internationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT killicks internationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT sekeresma internationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT listaf internationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT onidaf internationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT komrokjirs internationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT tefferia internationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies AT solarye internationaldatasetforcmmlvalidatesprognosticscoringsystemsanddemonstratesaneedfornovelprognosticationstrategies |