Intact parathyroid hormone and whole parathyroid hormone assay results disagree in hemodialysis patients under cinacalcet hydrochloride therapy

BACKGROUND: The parathyroid gland secretes 1-84 and 7-84 parathyroid hormone (PTH) fragments, and its regulation is dependent on stimulation of the extracellular calcium-sensing receptor. While the intact PTH system detects both PTH fragments, the whole PTH system detects the 1-84PTH but not the 7-84PTH. Cinacalcet hydrochloride (CH) binds to calcium-sensing receptor as a calcimimetic. Here we investigated the role of CH treatment in the assessment of parathyroid gland function. METHODS: Stable adult dialysis patients for whom CH therapy was planned were included. Patients for whom CH therapy was not planned were simultaneously included as the control group. RESULTS: The CH group (n = 44) showed significantly higher circulating levels of Ca, intact PTH, and whole PTH, before the CH treatment than the control group (n = 112). The Ca, intact PTH, and whole PTH levels decreased along with the CH therapy, and the Ca levels became comparable in the 8th week of treatment and thereafter. The CH group in the 8th week and thereafter showed significantly lower whole/intact PTH ratios than the control group, while the whole/intact PTH ratio was not significantly different between before and during the CH therapy. A multiple regression analysis revealed that the whole/intact PTH ratio was almost constant, but both the serum Ca level and a CH therapy could potentially modify the fixed number. When the whole PTH levels were estimated by intact PTH levels using the relationship between them in the control group, the levels were clearly overestimated in the CH group. CONCLUSIONS: Although the direct effect of CH on the whole/intact PTH ratio is masked by its hypocalcemic action, we could successfully demonstrate that the ratio in CH users is lower than that in the non-users with comparable levels of serum Ca. Evaluating parathyroid function with intact PTH according to the clinical practice guidelines in patients being treated with CH may lead to significant overestimation and subsequent overtreatment.