Cargando…
An updated h-index measures both the primary and total scientific output of a researcher
The growing interest in scientometry stems from ethical concerns related to the proper evaluation of scientific contributions of an author working in a hard science. In the absence of a consensus, institutions may use arbitrary methods for evaluating scientists for employment and promotion. There ar...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Applied Systems srl
2015
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4617786/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26504901 http://dx.doi.org/10.15190/d.2015.42 |
_version_ | 1782396836601921536 |
---|---|
author | Bucur, Octavian Almasan, Alexandru Zubarev, Roman A. Friedman, Mark T. Nicolson, Garth L. Sumazin, Pavel Leabu, Mircea Nikolajczyk, Barbara S. Avram, Dorina Kunej, Tanja Calin, George A. Godwin, Andrew K. Adami, Hans-Olov Zaphiropoulos, Peter G. Richardson, Des R. Schmitt-Ulms, Gerold Westerblad, Håkan Keniry, Megan Grau, Georges E. R. Carbonetto, Salvatore Stan, Radu V. Popa-Wagner, Aurel Takhar, Kasumov Baron, Beverly W. Galardy, Paul J. Yang, Feng Datta, Dipak Fadare, Oluwole Yeo, KT Jerry Gabreanu, Georgiana Roxana Andrei, Stefan Soare, Georgiana R. Nelson, Mark A. Liehn, Elisa A. |
author_facet | Bucur, Octavian Almasan, Alexandru Zubarev, Roman A. Friedman, Mark T. Nicolson, Garth L. Sumazin, Pavel Leabu, Mircea Nikolajczyk, Barbara S. Avram, Dorina Kunej, Tanja Calin, George A. Godwin, Andrew K. Adami, Hans-Olov Zaphiropoulos, Peter G. Richardson, Des R. Schmitt-Ulms, Gerold Westerblad, Håkan Keniry, Megan Grau, Georges E. R. Carbonetto, Salvatore Stan, Radu V. Popa-Wagner, Aurel Takhar, Kasumov Baron, Beverly W. Galardy, Paul J. Yang, Feng Datta, Dipak Fadare, Oluwole Yeo, KT Jerry Gabreanu, Georgiana Roxana Andrei, Stefan Soare, Georgiana R. Nelson, Mark A. Liehn, Elisa A. |
author_sort | Bucur, Octavian |
collection | PubMed |
description | The growing interest in scientometry stems from ethical concerns related to the proper evaluation of scientific contributions of an author working in a hard science. In the absence of a consensus, institutions may use arbitrary methods for evaluating scientists for employment and promotion. There are several indices in use that attempt to establish the most appropriate and suggestive position of any scientist in the field he/she works in. A scientist’s Hirsch-index (h-index) quantifies their total effective published output, but h-index summarizes the total value of their published work without regard to their contribution to each publication. Consequently, articles where the author was a primary contributor carry the same weight as articles where the author played a minor role. Thus, we propose an updated h-index named Hirsch(p,t)-index that informs about both total scientific output and output where the author played a primary role. Our measure, h(p,t) = h(p),h(t), is composed of the h-index h(t) and the h-index calculated for articles where the author was a key contributor; i.e. first/shared first or senior or corresponding author. Thus, a h(p,t) = 5,10 would mean that the author has 5 articles as first, shared first, senior or corresponding author with at least 5 citations each, and 10 total articles with at least 10 citations each. This index can be applied in biomedical disciplines and in all areas where the first and last position on an article are the most important. Although other indexes, such as r- and w-indexes, were proposed for measuring the authors’ output based on the position of researchers within the published articles, our simpler strategy uses the already established algorithms for h-index calculation and may be more practical to implement. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-4617786 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2015 |
publisher | Applied Systems srl |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-46177862015-10-24 An updated h-index measures both the primary and total scientific output of a researcher Bucur, Octavian Almasan, Alexandru Zubarev, Roman A. Friedman, Mark T. Nicolson, Garth L. Sumazin, Pavel Leabu, Mircea Nikolajczyk, Barbara S. Avram, Dorina Kunej, Tanja Calin, George A. Godwin, Andrew K. Adami, Hans-Olov Zaphiropoulos, Peter G. Richardson, Des R. Schmitt-Ulms, Gerold Westerblad, Håkan Keniry, Megan Grau, Georges E. R. Carbonetto, Salvatore Stan, Radu V. Popa-Wagner, Aurel Takhar, Kasumov Baron, Beverly W. Galardy, Paul J. Yang, Feng Datta, Dipak Fadare, Oluwole Yeo, KT Jerry Gabreanu, Georgiana Roxana Andrei, Stefan Soare, Georgiana R. Nelson, Mark A. Liehn, Elisa A. Discoveries (Craiova) Editorial The growing interest in scientometry stems from ethical concerns related to the proper evaluation of scientific contributions of an author working in a hard science. In the absence of a consensus, institutions may use arbitrary methods for evaluating scientists for employment and promotion. There are several indices in use that attempt to establish the most appropriate and suggestive position of any scientist in the field he/she works in. A scientist’s Hirsch-index (h-index) quantifies their total effective published output, but h-index summarizes the total value of their published work without regard to their contribution to each publication. Consequently, articles where the author was a primary contributor carry the same weight as articles where the author played a minor role. Thus, we propose an updated h-index named Hirsch(p,t)-index that informs about both total scientific output and output where the author played a primary role. Our measure, h(p,t) = h(p),h(t), is composed of the h-index h(t) and the h-index calculated for articles where the author was a key contributor; i.e. first/shared first or senior or corresponding author. Thus, a h(p,t) = 5,10 would mean that the author has 5 articles as first, shared first, senior or corresponding author with at least 5 citations each, and 10 total articles with at least 10 citations each. This index can be applied in biomedical disciplines and in all areas where the first and last position on an article are the most important. Although other indexes, such as r- and w-indexes, were proposed for measuring the authors’ output based on the position of researchers within the published articles, our simpler strategy uses the already established algorithms for h-index calculation and may be more practical to implement. Applied Systems srl 2015-09-30 /pmc/articles/PMC4617786/ /pubmed/26504901 http://dx.doi.org/10.15190/d.2015.42 Text en Copyright: © 2015, Bucur et al. and Applied Systems http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ This article is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited and is not used for commercial purposes. |
spellingShingle | Editorial Bucur, Octavian Almasan, Alexandru Zubarev, Roman A. Friedman, Mark T. Nicolson, Garth L. Sumazin, Pavel Leabu, Mircea Nikolajczyk, Barbara S. Avram, Dorina Kunej, Tanja Calin, George A. Godwin, Andrew K. Adami, Hans-Olov Zaphiropoulos, Peter G. Richardson, Des R. Schmitt-Ulms, Gerold Westerblad, Håkan Keniry, Megan Grau, Georges E. R. Carbonetto, Salvatore Stan, Radu V. Popa-Wagner, Aurel Takhar, Kasumov Baron, Beverly W. Galardy, Paul J. Yang, Feng Datta, Dipak Fadare, Oluwole Yeo, KT Jerry Gabreanu, Georgiana Roxana Andrei, Stefan Soare, Georgiana R. Nelson, Mark A. Liehn, Elisa A. An updated h-index measures both the primary and total scientific output of a researcher |
title | An updated h-index measures both the primary and total scientific output of a researcher |
title_full | An updated h-index measures both the primary and total scientific output of a researcher |
title_fullStr | An updated h-index measures both the primary and total scientific output of a researcher |
title_full_unstemmed | An updated h-index measures both the primary and total scientific output of a researcher |
title_short | An updated h-index measures both the primary and total scientific output of a researcher |
title_sort | updated h-index measures both the primary and total scientific output of a researcher |
topic | Editorial |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4617786/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26504901 http://dx.doi.org/10.15190/d.2015.42 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT bucuroctavian anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT almasanalexandru anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT zubarevromana anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT friedmanmarkt anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT nicolsongarthl anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT sumazinpavel anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT leabumircea anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT nikolajczykbarbaras anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT avramdorina anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT kunejtanja anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT calingeorgea anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT godwinandrewk anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT adamihansolov anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT zaphiropoulospeterg anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT richardsondesr anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT schmittulmsgerold anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT westerbladhakan anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT kenirymegan anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT graugeorgeser anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT carbonettosalvatore anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT stanraduv anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT popawagneraurel anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT takharkasumov anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT baronbeverlyw anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT galardypaulj anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT yangfeng anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT dattadipak anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT fadareoluwole anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT yeoktjerry anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT gabreanugeorgianaroxana anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT andreistefan anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT soaregeorgianar anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT nelsonmarka anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT liehnelisaa anupdatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT bucuroctavian updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT almasanalexandru updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT zubarevromana updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT friedmanmarkt updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT nicolsongarthl updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT sumazinpavel updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT leabumircea updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT nikolajczykbarbaras updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT avramdorina updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT kunejtanja updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT calingeorgea updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT godwinandrewk updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT adamihansolov updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT zaphiropoulospeterg updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT richardsondesr updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT schmittulmsgerold updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT westerbladhakan updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT kenirymegan updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT graugeorgeser updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT carbonettosalvatore updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT stanraduv updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT popawagneraurel updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT takharkasumov updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT baronbeverlyw updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT galardypaulj updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT yangfeng updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT dattadipak updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT fadareoluwole updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT yeoktjerry updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT gabreanugeorgianaroxana updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT andreistefan updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT soaregeorgianar updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT nelsonmarka updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher AT liehnelisaa updatedhindexmeasuresboththeprimaryandtotalscientificoutputofaresearcher |