Cargando…
The Performance of the Four Anaerobic Blood Culture Bottles BacT/ALERT-FN, -FN Plus, BACTEC-Plus and -Lytic in Detection of Anaerobic Bacteria and Identification by Direct MALDI-TOF MS
Detection and identification of anaerobic bacteria in blood cultures (BC) is a well-recognized challenge in clinical microbiology. We studied 100 clinical anaerobic BC isolates to evaluate the performance of BacT/ALERT-FN, -FN Plus (BioMérieux), BACTEC-Plus and -Lytic (Becton Dickinson BioSciences)...
Autores principales: | , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Public Library of Science
2015
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4640713/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26554930 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0142398 |
_version_ | 1782400117781823488 |
---|---|
author | Almuhayawi, Mohammed Altun, Osman Abdulmajeed, Adam Dilshad Ullberg, Måns Özenci, Volkan |
author_facet | Almuhayawi, Mohammed Altun, Osman Abdulmajeed, Adam Dilshad Ullberg, Måns Özenci, Volkan |
author_sort | Almuhayawi, Mohammed |
collection | PubMed |
description | Detection and identification of anaerobic bacteria in blood cultures (BC) is a well-recognized challenge in clinical microbiology. We studied 100 clinical anaerobic BC isolates to evaluate the performance of BacT/ALERT-FN, -FN Plus (BioMérieux), BACTEC-Plus and -Lytic (Becton Dickinson BioSciences) BC bottles in detection and time to detection (TTD) of anaerobic bacteria. BACTEC Lytic had higher detection rate (94/100, 94%) than BacT/ALERT FN Plus (80/100, 80%) (p<0.01) in the studied material. There was no significant difference in detection of anaerobic bacteria among the remaining bottle types. The 67 anaerobic bacteria that signalled positive in all four bottle types were analyzed to compare the time to detection (TTD) and isolates were directly identified by MALDI-TOF MS. There was a significant difference in TTD among the four bottle types (p<0.0001). The shortest median TTD was 18 h in BACTEC Lytic followed by BacT/ALERT FN (23.5 h), BACTEC Plus (27 h) and finally BacT/ALERT FN Plus (38 h) bottles. In contrast, MALDI-TOF MS performed similarly in all bottle types with accurate identification in 51/67 (76%) BacT/ALERT FN, 51/67 (76%) BacT/ALERT FN Plus, 53/67 (79%) BACTEC Plus and 50/67 (75%) BACTEC Lytic bottles. In conclusion, BACTEC Lytic bottles have significantly better detection rates and shorter TTD compared to the three other bottle types. The anaerobic BC bottles are equally suitable for direct MALDI-TOF MS for rapid and reliable identification of common anaerobic bacteria. Further clinical studies are warranted to investigate the performance of anaerobic BC bottles in detection of anaerobic bacteria and identification by direct MALDI-TOF MS. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-4640713 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2015 |
publisher | Public Library of Science |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-46407132015-11-13 The Performance of the Four Anaerobic Blood Culture Bottles BacT/ALERT-FN, -FN Plus, BACTEC-Plus and -Lytic in Detection of Anaerobic Bacteria and Identification by Direct MALDI-TOF MS Almuhayawi, Mohammed Altun, Osman Abdulmajeed, Adam Dilshad Ullberg, Måns Özenci, Volkan PLoS One Research Article Detection and identification of anaerobic bacteria in blood cultures (BC) is a well-recognized challenge in clinical microbiology. We studied 100 clinical anaerobic BC isolates to evaluate the performance of BacT/ALERT-FN, -FN Plus (BioMérieux), BACTEC-Plus and -Lytic (Becton Dickinson BioSciences) BC bottles in detection and time to detection (TTD) of anaerobic bacteria. BACTEC Lytic had higher detection rate (94/100, 94%) than BacT/ALERT FN Plus (80/100, 80%) (p<0.01) in the studied material. There was no significant difference in detection of anaerobic bacteria among the remaining bottle types. The 67 anaerobic bacteria that signalled positive in all four bottle types were analyzed to compare the time to detection (TTD) and isolates were directly identified by MALDI-TOF MS. There was a significant difference in TTD among the four bottle types (p<0.0001). The shortest median TTD was 18 h in BACTEC Lytic followed by BacT/ALERT FN (23.5 h), BACTEC Plus (27 h) and finally BacT/ALERT FN Plus (38 h) bottles. In contrast, MALDI-TOF MS performed similarly in all bottle types with accurate identification in 51/67 (76%) BacT/ALERT FN, 51/67 (76%) BacT/ALERT FN Plus, 53/67 (79%) BACTEC Plus and 50/67 (75%) BACTEC Lytic bottles. In conclusion, BACTEC Lytic bottles have significantly better detection rates and shorter TTD compared to the three other bottle types. The anaerobic BC bottles are equally suitable for direct MALDI-TOF MS for rapid and reliable identification of common anaerobic bacteria. Further clinical studies are warranted to investigate the performance of anaerobic BC bottles in detection of anaerobic bacteria and identification by direct MALDI-TOF MS. Public Library of Science 2015-11-10 /pmc/articles/PMC4640713/ /pubmed/26554930 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0142398 Text en © 2015 Almuhayawi et al http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are properly credited. |
spellingShingle | Research Article Almuhayawi, Mohammed Altun, Osman Abdulmajeed, Adam Dilshad Ullberg, Måns Özenci, Volkan The Performance of the Four Anaerobic Blood Culture Bottles BacT/ALERT-FN, -FN Plus, BACTEC-Plus and -Lytic in Detection of Anaerobic Bacteria and Identification by Direct MALDI-TOF MS |
title | The Performance of the Four Anaerobic Blood Culture Bottles BacT/ALERT-FN, -FN Plus, BACTEC-Plus and -Lytic in Detection of Anaerobic Bacteria and Identification by Direct MALDI-TOF MS |
title_full | The Performance of the Four Anaerobic Blood Culture Bottles BacT/ALERT-FN, -FN Plus, BACTEC-Plus and -Lytic in Detection of Anaerobic Bacteria and Identification by Direct MALDI-TOF MS |
title_fullStr | The Performance of the Four Anaerobic Blood Culture Bottles BacT/ALERT-FN, -FN Plus, BACTEC-Plus and -Lytic in Detection of Anaerobic Bacteria and Identification by Direct MALDI-TOF MS |
title_full_unstemmed | The Performance of the Four Anaerobic Blood Culture Bottles BacT/ALERT-FN, -FN Plus, BACTEC-Plus and -Lytic in Detection of Anaerobic Bacteria and Identification by Direct MALDI-TOF MS |
title_short | The Performance of the Four Anaerobic Blood Culture Bottles BacT/ALERT-FN, -FN Plus, BACTEC-Plus and -Lytic in Detection of Anaerobic Bacteria and Identification by Direct MALDI-TOF MS |
title_sort | performance of the four anaerobic blood culture bottles bact/alert-fn, -fn plus, bactec-plus and -lytic in detection of anaerobic bacteria and identification by direct maldi-tof ms |
topic | Research Article |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4640713/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26554930 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0142398 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT almuhayawimohammed theperformanceofthefouranaerobicbloodculturebottlesbactalertfnfnplusbactecplusandlyticindetectionofanaerobicbacteriaandidentificationbydirectmalditofms AT altunosman theperformanceofthefouranaerobicbloodculturebottlesbactalertfnfnplusbactecplusandlyticindetectionofanaerobicbacteriaandidentificationbydirectmalditofms AT abdulmajeedadamdilshad theperformanceofthefouranaerobicbloodculturebottlesbactalertfnfnplusbactecplusandlyticindetectionofanaerobicbacteriaandidentificationbydirectmalditofms AT ullbergmans theperformanceofthefouranaerobicbloodculturebottlesbactalertfnfnplusbactecplusandlyticindetectionofanaerobicbacteriaandidentificationbydirectmalditofms AT ozencivolkan theperformanceofthefouranaerobicbloodculturebottlesbactalertfnfnplusbactecplusandlyticindetectionofanaerobicbacteriaandidentificationbydirectmalditofms AT almuhayawimohammed performanceofthefouranaerobicbloodculturebottlesbactalertfnfnplusbactecplusandlyticindetectionofanaerobicbacteriaandidentificationbydirectmalditofms AT altunosman performanceofthefouranaerobicbloodculturebottlesbactalertfnfnplusbactecplusandlyticindetectionofanaerobicbacteriaandidentificationbydirectmalditofms AT abdulmajeedadamdilshad performanceofthefouranaerobicbloodculturebottlesbactalertfnfnplusbactecplusandlyticindetectionofanaerobicbacteriaandidentificationbydirectmalditofms AT ullbergmans performanceofthefouranaerobicbloodculturebottlesbactalertfnfnplusbactecplusandlyticindetectionofanaerobicbacteriaandidentificationbydirectmalditofms AT ozencivolkan performanceofthefouranaerobicbloodculturebottlesbactalertfnfnplusbactecplusandlyticindetectionofanaerobicbacteriaandidentificationbydirectmalditofms |