Cargando…

Nationwide study of headache pain in Italy shows that pain assessment is still inadequate in paediatric emergency care

AIM: Italian national guidelines on pain management were published in 2010, but there is little information on how effective pain management is in paediatric emergency care, with other countries reporting poor levels. Using headache as an indicator, we described pain assessment in Italian emergency...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Benini, Franca, Piga, Simone, Zangardi, Tiziana, Messi, Gianni, Tomasello, Caterina, Pirozzi, Nicola, Cuttini, Marina, ocerino, A, Crichiutti, G, Barbi, E, Biban, P, Ghizzi, C, Benedetti, M, rrighini, A, Podestà, A F, Scalfaro, C, Stringhi, C, Rotta, S, Salvo, I R Di, Fossali, E, rbino, A, Taglietto, M, Marciano, C, Piccotti, E, Manfredini, L, Mannelli, F, Messeri, A, Cardoni, G, Piattellini, G M, Midulla, F, Chiaretti, A, Campa, A, Borrometi, F, Maremonti, P, Grandolfo, Rita, Fucà, F, Parrino, R
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2016
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4825404/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26792256
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/apa.13335
_version_ 1782426214462390272
author Benini, Franca
Piga, Simone
Zangardi, Tiziana
Messi, Gianni
Tomasello, Caterina
Pirozzi, Nicola
Cuttini, Marina
ocerino, A
Crichiutti, G
Barbi, E
Biban, P
Ghizzi, C
Benedetti, M
rrighini, A
Podestà, A F
Scalfaro, C
Stringhi, C
Rotta, S
Salvo, I R Di
Fossali, E
rbino, A
Taglietto, M
Marciano, C
Piccotti, E
Manfredini, L
Mannelli, F
Messeri, A
Cardoni, G
Piattellini, G M
Midulla, F
Chiaretti, A
Campa, A
Borrometi, F
Maremonti, P
Grandolfo, Rita
Fucà, F
Parrino, R
author_facet Benini, Franca
Piga, Simone
Zangardi, Tiziana
Messi, Gianni
Tomasello, Caterina
Pirozzi, Nicola
Cuttini, Marina
ocerino, A
Crichiutti, G
Barbi, E
Biban, P
Ghizzi, C
Benedetti, M
rrighini, A
Podestà, A F
Scalfaro, C
Stringhi, C
Rotta, S
Salvo, I R Di
Fossali, E
rbino, A
Taglietto, M
Marciano, C
Piccotti, E
Manfredini, L
Mannelli, F
Messeri, A
Cardoni, G
Piattellini, G M
Midulla, F
Chiaretti, A
Campa, A
Borrometi, F
Maremonti, P
Grandolfo, Rita
Fucà, F
Parrino, R
author_sort Benini, Franca
collection PubMed
description AIM: Italian national guidelines on pain management were published in 2010, but there is little information on how effective pain management is in paediatric emergency care, with other countries reporting poor levels. Using headache as an indicator, we described pain assessment in Italian emergency departments and identified predictors of algometric scale use. METHODS: All Italian paediatric and maternal and child hospitals participated, plus four general hospitals. Data on all children aged 4–14 years admitted during a one‐month period with headache as their chief complaint were abstracted from clinical records. Multivariable analyses identified predictors of algometric assessment, taking into account the cluster study design. RESULTS: We studied 470 admissions. During triage, pain was assessed using a standardised scale (41.5%), informally (15.5%) or was not recorded (42.9%). Only 32.1% of the children received analgesia in the emergency department. The odds ratios for predictors of algometric assessment were non‐Italian nationality (3.6), prehospital medication (1.8), admission to a research hospital (7.3) and a more favourable nurses‐to‐admissions ratio of 10.8 for the highest versus lowest tertile. CONCLUSION: Despite national guidelines, paediatric pain assessment in Italian emergency care was suboptimal. Hospital variables appeared to be stronger predictors of adequate assessment than patient characteristics.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-4825404
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2016
publisher John Wiley and Sons Inc.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-48254042016-04-18 Nationwide study of headache pain in Italy shows that pain assessment is still inadequate in paediatric emergency care Benini, Franca Piga, Simone Zangardi, Tiziana Messi, Gianni Tomasello, Caterina Pirozzi, Nicola Cuttini, Marina ocerino, A Crichiutti, G Barbi, E Biban, P Ghizzi, C Benedetti, M rrighini, A Podestà, A F Scalfaro, C Stringhi, C Rotta, S Salvo, I R Di Fossali, E rbino, A Taglietto, M Marciano, C Piccotti, E Manfredini, L Mannelli, F Messeri, A Cardoni, G Piattellini, G M Midulla, F Chiaretti, A Campa, A Borrometi, F Maremonti, P Grandolfo, Rita Fucà, F Parrino, R Acta Paediatr Online Only Articles AIM: Italian national guidelines on pain management were published in 2010, but there is little information on how effective pain management is in paediatric emergency care, with other countries reporting poor levels. Using headache as an indicator, we described pain assessment in Italian emergency departments and identified predictors of algometric scale use. METHODS: All Italian paediatric and maternal and child hospitals participated, plus four general hospitals. Data on all children aged 4–14 years admitted during a one‐month period with headache as their chief complaint were abstracted from clinical records. Multivariable analyses identified predictors of algometric assessment, taking into account the cluster study design. RESULTS: We studied 470 admissions. During triage, pain was assessed using a standardised scale (41.5%), informally (15.5%) or was not recorded (42.9%). Only 32.1% of the children received analgesia in the emergency department. The odds ratios for predictors of algometric assessment were non‐Italian nationality (3.6), prehospital medication (1.8), admission to a research hospital (7.3) and a more favourable nurses‐to‐admissions ratio of 10.8 for the highest versus lowest tertile. CONCLUSION: Despite national guidelines, paediatric pain assessment in Italian emergency care was suboptimal. Hospital variables appeared to be stronger predictors of adequate assessment than patient characteristics. John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2016-02-12 2016-05 /pmc/articles/PMC4825404/ /pubmed/26792256 http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/apa.13335 Text en ©2016 The Authors. Acta Pædiatrica published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of Foundation Acta Pædiatrica This is an open access article under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution‐NonCommercial (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited and is not used for commercial purposes.
spellingShingle Online Only Articles
Benini, Franca
Piga, Simone
Zangardi, Tiziana
Messi, Gianni
Tomasello, Caterina
Pirozzi, Nicola
Cuttini, Marina
ocerino, A
Crichiutti, G
Barbi, E
Biban, P
Ghizzi, C
Benedetti, M
rrighini, A
Podestà, A F
Scalfaro, C
Stringhi, C
Rotta, S
Salvo, I R Di
Fossali, E
rbino, A
Taglietto, M
Marciano, C
Piccotti, E
Manfredini, L
Mannelli, F
Messeri, A
Cardoni, G
Piattellini, G M
Midulla, F
Chiaretti, A
Campa, A
Borrometi, F
Maremonti, P
Grandolfo, Rita
Fucà, F
Parrino, R
Nationwide study of headache pain in Italy shows that pain assessment is still inadequate in paediatric emergency care
title Nationwide study of headache pain in Italy shows that pain assessment is still inadequate in paediatric emergency care
title_full Nationwide study of headache pain in Italy shows that pain assessment is still inadequate in paediatric emergency care
title_fullStr Nationwide study of headache pain in Italy shows that pain assessment is still inadequate in paediatric emergency care
title_full_unstemmed Nationwide study of headache pain in Italy shows that pain assessment is still inadequate in paediatric emergency care
title_short Nationwide study of headache pain in Italy shows that pain assessment is still inadequate in paediatric emergency care
title_sort nationwide study of headache pain in italy shows that pain assessment is still inadequate in paediatric emergency care
topic Online Only Articles
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4825404/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26792256
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/apa.13335
work_keys_str_mv AT beninifranca nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT pigasimone nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT zangarditiziana nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT messigianni nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT tomasellocaterina nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT pirozzinicola nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT cuttinimarina nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT ocerinoa nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT crichiuttig nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT barbie nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT bibanp nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT ghizzic nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT benedettim nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT rrighinia nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT podestaaf nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT scalfaroc nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT stringhic nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT rottas nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT salvoirdi nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT fossalie nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT rbinoa nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT tagliettom nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT marcianoc nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT piccottie nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT manfredinil nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT mannellif nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT messeria nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT cardonig nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT piattellinigm nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT midullaf nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT chiarettia nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT campaa nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT borrometif nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT maremontip nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT grandolforita nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT fucaf nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare
AT parrinor nationwidestudyofheadachepaininitalyshowsthatpainassessmentisstillinadequateinpaediatricemergencycare