Cargando…
Impact of Center Experience on Patient Radiation Exposure During Transradial Coronary Angiography and Percutaneous Intervention: A Patient‐Level, International, Collaborative, Multi‐Center Analysis
BACKGROUND: The adoption of the transradial (TR) approach over the traditional transfemoral (TF) approach has been hampered by concerns of increased radiation exposure—a subject of considerable debate within the field. We performed a patient‐level, multi‐center analysis to definitively address the i...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
John Wiley and Sons Inc.
2016
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4937274/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27247332 http://dx.doi.org/10.1161/JAHA.116.003333 |
_version_ | 1782441680311418880 |
---|---|
author | Simard, Trevor Hibbert, Benjamin Natarajan, Madhu K. Mercuri, Mathew Hetherington, Simon L. Wright, Robert Delewi, Ronak Piek, Jan J. Lehmann, Ralf Ruzsa, Zoltán Lange, Helmut W. Geijer, Håkan Sandborg, Michael Kansal, Vinay Bernick, Jordan Di Santo, Pietro Pourdjabbar, Ali Ramirez, F. Daniel Chow, Benjamin J. W. Chong, Aun Yeong Labinaz, Marino Le May, Michel R. O'Brien, Edward R. Wells, George A. So, Derek |
author_facet | Simard, Trevor Hibbert, Benjamin Natarajan, Madhu K. Mercuri, Mathew Hetherington, Simon L. Wright, Robert Delewi, Ronak Piek, Jan J. Lehmann, Ralf Ruzsa, Zoltán Lange, Helmut W. Geijer, Håkan Sandborg, Michael Kansal, Vinay Bernick, Jordan Di Santo, Pietro Pourdjabbar, Ali Ramirez, F. Daniel Chow, Benjamin J. W. Chong, Aun Yeong Labinaz, Marino Le May, Michel R. O'Brien, Edward R. Wells, George A. So, Derek |
author_sort | Simard, Trevor |
collection | PubMed |
description | BACKGROUND: The adoption of the transradial (TR) approach over the traditional transfemoral (TF) approach has been hampered by concerns of increased radiation exposure—a subject of considerable debate within the field. We performed a patient‐level, multi‐center analysis to definitively address the impact of TR access on radiation exposure. METHODS AND RESULTS: Overall, 10 centers were included from 6 countries—Canada (2 centers), United Kingdom (2), Germany (2), Sweden (2), Hungary (1), and The Netherlands (1). We compared the radiation exposure of TR versus TF access using measured dose‐area product (DAP). To account for local variations in equipment and exposure, standardized TR:TF DAP ratios were constructed per center with procedures separated by coronary angiography (CA) and percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI). Among 57 326 procedures, we demonstrated increased radiation exposure with the TR versus TF approach, particularly in the CA cohort across all centers (weighted‐average ratios: CA, 1.15; PCI, 1.05). However, this was mitigated by increasing TR experience in the PCI cohort across all centers (r=−0.8; P=0.005). Over time, as a center transitioned to increasing TR experience (r=0.9; P=0.001), a concomitant decrease in radiation exposure occurred (r=−0.8; P=0.006). Ultimately, when a center's balance of TR to TF procedures approaches 50%, the resultant radiation exposure was equivalent. CONCLUSIONS: The TR approach is associated with a modest increase in patient radiation exposure. However, this increase is eliminated when the TR and TF approaches are used with equal frequency—a guiding principle for centers adopting the TR approach. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-4937274 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2016 |
publisher | John Wiley and Sons Inc. |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-49372742016-07-18 Impact of Center Experience on Patient Radiation Exposure During Transradial Coronary Angiography and Percutaneous Intervention: A Patient‐Level, International, Collaborative, Multi‐Center Analysis Simard, Trevor Hibbert, Benjamin Natarajan, Madhu K. Mercuri, Mathew Hetherington, Simon L. Wright, Robert Delewi, Ronak Piek, Jan J. Lehmann, Ralf Ruzsa, Zoltán Lange, Helmut W. Geijer, Håkan Sandborg, Michael Kansal, Vinay Bernick, Jordan Di Santo, Pietro Pourdjabbar, Ali Ramirez, F. Daniel Chow, Benjamin J. W. Chong, Aun Yeong Labinaz, Marino Le May, Michel R. O'Brien, Edward R. Wells, George A. So, Derek J Am Heart Assoc Original Research BACKGROUND: The adoption of the transradial (TR) approach over the traditional transfemoral (TF) approach has been hampered by concerns of increased radiation exposure—a subject of considerable debate within the field. We performed a patient‐level, multi‐center analysis to definitively address the impact of TR access on radiation exposure. METHODS AND RESULTS: Overall, 10 centers were included from 6 countries—Canada (2 centers), United Kingdom (2), Germany (2), Sweden (2), Hungary (1), and The Netherlands (1). We compared the radiation exposure of TR versus TF access using measured dose‐area product (DAP). To account for local variations in equipment and exposure, standardized TR:TF DAP ratios were constructed per center with procedures separated by coronary angiography (CA) and percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI). Among 57 326 procedures, we demonstrated increased radiation exposure with the TR versus TF approach, particularly in the CA cohort across all centers (weighted‐average ratios: CA, 1.15; PCI, 1.05). However, this was mitigated by increasing TR experience in the PCI cohort across all centers (r=−0.8; P=0.005). Over time, as a center transitioned to increasing TR experience (r=0.9; P=0.001), a concomitant decrease in radiation exposure occurred (r=−0.8; P=0.006). Ultimately, when a center's balance of TR to TF procedures approaches 50%, the resultant radiation exposure was equivalent. CONCLUSIONS: The TR approach is associated with a modest increase in patient radiation exposure. However, this increase is eliminated when the TR and TF approaches are used with equal frequency—a guiding principle for centers adopting the TR approach. John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2016-05-31 /pmc/articles/PMC4937274/ /pubmed/27247332 http://dx.doi.org/10.1161/JAHA.116.003333 Text en © 2016 The Authors. Published on behalf of the American Heart Association, Inc., by Wiley Blackwell. This is an open access article under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution‐NonCommercial‐NoDerivs (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/) License, which permits use and distribution in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited, the use is non‐commercial and no modifications or adaptations are made. |
spellingShingle | Original Research Simard, Trevor Hibbert, Benjamin Natarajan, Madhu K. Mercuri, Mathew Hetherington, Simon L. Wright, Robert Delewi, Ronak Piek, Jan J. Lehmann, Ralf Ruzsa, Zoltán Lange, Helmut W. Geijer, Håkan Sandborg, Michael Kansal, Vinay Bernick, Jordan Di Santo, Pietro Pourdjabbar, Ali Ramirez, F. Daniel Chow, Benjamin J. W. Chong, Aun Yeong Labinaz, Marino Le May, Michel R. O'Brien, Edward R. Wells, George A. So, Derek Impact of Center Experience on Patient Radiation Exposure During Transradial Coronary Angiography and Percutaneous Intervention: A Patient‐Level, International, Collaborative, Multi‐Center Analysis |
title | Impact of Center Experience on Patient Radiation Exposure During Transradial Coronary Angiography and Percutaneous Intervention: A Patient‐Level, International, Collaborative, Multi‐Center Analysis |
title_full | Impact of Center Experience on Patient Radiation Exposure During Transradial Coronary Angiography and Percutaneous Intervention: A Patient‐Level, International, Collaborative, Multi‐Center Analysis |
title_fullStr | Impact of Center Experience on Patient Radiation Exposure During Transradial Coronary Angiography and Percutaneous Intervention: A Patient‐Level, International, Collaborative, Multi‐Center Analysis |
title_full_unstemmed | Impact of Center Experience on Patient Radiation Exposure During Transradial Coronary Angiography and Percutaneous Intervention: A Patient‐Level, International, Collaborative, Multi‐Center Analysis |
title_short | Impact of Center Experience on Patient Radiation Exposure During Transradial Coronary Angiography and Percutaneous Intervention: A Patient‐Level, International, Collaborative, Multi‐Center Analysis |
title_sort | impact of center experience on patient radiation exposure during transradial coronary angiography and percutaneous intervention: a patient‐level, international, collaborative, multi‐center analysis |
topic | Original Research |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4937274/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27247332 http://dx.doi.org/10.1161/JAHA.116.003333 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT simardtrevor impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT hibbertbenjamin impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT natarajanmadhuk impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT mercurimathew impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT hetheringtonsimonl impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT wrightrobert impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT delewironak impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT piekjanj impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT lehmannralf impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT ruzsazoltan impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT langehelmutw impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT geijerhakan impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT sandborgmichael impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT kansalvinay impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT bernickjordan impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT disantopietro impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT pourdjabbarali impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT ramirezfdaniel impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT chowbenjaminjw impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT chongaunyeong impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT labinazmarino impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT lemaymichelr impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT obrienedwardr impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT wellsgeorgea impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis AT soderek impactofcenterexperienceonpatientradiationexposureduringtransradialcoronaryangiographyandpercutaneousinterventionapatientlevelinternationalcollaborativemulticenteranalysis |