Cargando…

Pitfalls in genetic testing: the story of missed SCN1A mutations

BACKGROUND: Sanger sequencing, still the standard technique for genetic testing in most diagnostic laboratories and until recently widely used in research, is gradually being complemented by next‐generation sequencing (NGS). No single mutation detection technique is however perfect in identifying al...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Djémié, Tania, Weckhuysen, Sarah, von Spiczak, Sarah, Carvill, Gemma L., Jaehn, Johanna, Anttonen, Anna‐Kaisa, Brilstra, Eva, Caglayan, Hande S., de Kovel, Carolien G., Depienne, Christel, Gaily, Eija, Gennaro, Elena, Giraldez, Beatriz G., Gormley, Padhraig, Guerrero‐López, Rosa, Guerrini, Renzo, Hämäläinen, Eija, Hartmann, Corinna, Hernandez‐Hernandez, Laura, Hjalgrim, Helle, Koeleman, Bobby P. C., Leguern, Eric, Lehesjoki, Anna‐Elina, Lemke, Johannes R., Leu, Costin, Marini, Carla, McMahon, Jacinta M., Mei, Davide, Møller, Rikke S., Muhle, Hiltrud, Myers, Candace T., Nava, Caroline, Serratosa, Jose M., Sisodiya, Sanjay M., Stephani, Ulrich, Striano, Pasquale, van Kempen, Marjan J. A., Verbeek, Nienke E., Usluer, Sunay, Zara, Federico, Palotie, Aarno, Mefford, Heather C., Scheffer, Ingrid E., De Jonghe, Peter, Helbig, Ingo, Suls, Arvid
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2016
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4947864/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27465585
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/mgg3.217
_version_ 1782443245564854272
author Djémié, Tania
Weckhuysen, Sarah
von Spiczak, Sarah
Carvill, Gemma L.
Jaehn, Johanna
Anttonen, Anna‐Kaisa
Brilstra, Eva
Caglayan, Hande S.
de Kovel, Carolien G.
Depienne, Christel
Gaily, Eija
Gennaro, Elena
Giraldez, Beatriz G.
Gormley, Padhraig
Guerrero‐López, Rosa
Guerrini, Renzo
Hämäläinen, Eija
Hartmann, Corinna
Hernandez‐Hernandez, Laura
Hjalgrim, Helle
Koeleman, Bobby P. C.
Leguern, Eric
Lehesjoki, Anna‐Elina
Lemke, Johannes R.
Leu, Costin
Marini, Carla
McMahon, Jacinta M.
Mei, Davide
Møller, Rikke S.
Muhle, Hiltrud
Myers, Candace T.
Nava, Caroline
Serratosa, Jose M.
Sisodiya, Sanjay M.
Stephani, Ulrich
Striano, Pasquale
van Kempen, Marjan J. A.
Verbeek, Nienke E.
Usluer, Sunay
Zara, Federico
Palotie, Aarno
Mefford, Heather C.
Scheffer, Ingrid E.
De Jonghe, Peter
Helbig, Ingo
Suls, Arvid
author_facet Djémié, Tania
Weckhuysen, Sarah
von Spiczak, Sarah
Carvill, Gemma L.
Jaehn, Johanna
Anttonen, Anna‐Kaisa
Brilstra, Eva
Caglayan, Hande S.
de Kovel, Carolien G.
Depienne, Christel
Gaily, Eija
Gennaro, Elena
Giraldez, Beatriz G.
Gormley, Padhraig
Guerrero‐López, Rosa
Guerrini, Renzo
Hämäläinen, Eija
Hartmann, Corinna
Hernandez‐Hernandez, Laura
Hjalgrim, Helle
Koeleman, Bobby P. C.
Leguern, Eric
Lehesjoki, Anna‐Elina
Lemke, Johannes R.
Leu, Costin
Marini, Carla
McMahon, Jacinta M.
Mei, Davide
Møller, Rikke S.
Muhle, Hiltrud
Myers, Candace T.
Nava, Caroline
Serratosa, Jose M.
Sisodiya, Sanjay M.
Stephani, Ulrich
Striano, Pasquale
van Kempen, Marjan J. A.
Verbeek, Nienke E.
Usluer, Sunay
Zara, Federico
Palotie, Aarno
Mefford, Heather C.
Scheffer, Ingrid E.
De Jonghe, Peter
Helbig, Ingo
Suls, Arvid
author_sort Djémié, Tania
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Sanger sequencing, still the standard technique for genetic testing in most diagnostic laboratories and until recently widely used in research, is gradually being complemented by next‐generation sequencing (NGS). No single mutation detection technique is however perfect in identifying all mutations. Therefore, we wondered to what extent inconsistencies between Sanger sequencing and NGS affect the molecular diagnosis of patients. Since mutations in SCN1A, the major gene implicated in epilepsy, are found in the majority of Dravet syndrome (DS) patients, we focused on missed SCN1A mutations. METHODS: We sent out a survey to 16 genetic centers performing SCN1A testing. RESULTS: We collected data on 28 mutations initially missed using Sanger sequencing. All patients were falsely reported as SCN1A mutation‐negative, both due to technical limitations and human errors. CONCLUSION: We illustrate the pitfalls of Sanger sequencing and most importantly provide evidence that SCN1A mutations are an even more frequent cause of DS than already anticipated.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-4947864
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2016
publisher John Wiley and Sons Inc.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-49478642016-07-27 Pitfalls in genetic testing: the story of missed SCN1A mutations Djémié, Tania Weckhuysen, Sarah von Spiczak, Sarah Carvill, Gemma L. Jaehn, Johanna Anttonen, Anna‐Kaisa Brilstra, Eva Caglayan, Hande S. de Kovel, Carolien G. Depienne, Christel Gaily, Eija Gennaro, Elena Giraldez, Beatriz G. Gormley, Padhraig Guerrero‐López, Rosa Guerrini, Renzo Hämäläinen, Eija Hartmann, Corinna Hernandez‐Hernandez, Laura Hjalgrim, Helle Koeleman, Bobby P. C. Leguern, Eric Lehesjoki, Anna‐Elina Lemke, Johannes R. Leu, Costin Marini, Carla McMahon, Jacinta M. Mei, Davide Møller, Rikke S. Muhle, Hiltrud Myers, Candace T. Nava, Caroline Serratosa, Jose M. Sisodiya, Sanjay M. Stephani, Ulrich Striano, Pasquale van Kempen, Marjan J. A. Verbeek, Nienke E. Usluer, Sunay Zara, Federico Palotie, Aarno Mefford, Heather C. Scheffer, Ingrid E. De Jonghe, Peter Helbig, Ingo Suls, Arvid Mol Genet Genomic Med Original Articles BACKGROUND: Sanger sequencing, still the standard technique for genetic testing in most diagnostic laboratories and until recently widely used in research, is gradually being complemented by next‐generation sequencing (NGS). No single mutation detection technique is however perfect in identifying all mutations. Therefore, we wondered to what extent inconsistencies between Sanger sequencing and NGS affect the molecular diagnosis of patients. Since mutations in SCN1A, the major gene implicated in epilepsy, are found in the majority of Dravet syndrome (DS) patients, we focused on missed SCN1A mutations. METHODS: We sent out a survey to 16 genetic centers performing SCN1A testing. RESULTS: We collected data on 28 mutations initially missed using Sanger sequencing. All patients were falsely reported as SCN1A mutation‐negative, both due to technical limitations and human errors. CONCLUSION: We illustrate the pitfalls of Sanger sequencing and most importantly provide evidence that SCN1A mutations are an even more frequent cause of DS than already anticipated. John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2016-04-14 /pmc/articles/PMC4947864/ /pubmed/27465585 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/mgg3.217 Text en © 2016 The Authors. Molecular Genetics & Genomic Medicine published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc. This is an open access article under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
spellingShingle Original Articles
Djémié, Tania
Weckhuysen, Sarah
von Spiczak, Sarah
Carvill, Gemma L.
Jaehn, Johanna
Anttonen, Anna‐Kaisa
Brilstra, Eva
Caglayan, Hande S.
de Kovel, Carolien G.
Depienne, Christel
Gaily, Eija
Gennaro, Elena
Giraldez, Beatriz G.
Gormley, Padhraig
Guerrero‐López, Rosa
Guerrini, Renzo
Hämäläinen, Eija
Hartmann, Corinna
Hernandez‐Hernandez, Laura
Hjalgrim, Helle
Koeleman, Bobby P. C.
Leguern, Eric
Lehesjoki, Anna‐Elina
Lemke, Johannes R.
Leu, Costin
Marini, Carla
McMahon, Jacinta M.
Mei, Davide
Møller, Rikke S.
Muhle, Hiltrud
Myers, Candace T.
Nava, Caroline
Serratosa, Jose M.
Sisodiya, Sanjay M.
Stephani, Ulrich
Striano, Pasquale
van Kempen, Marjan J. A.
Verbeek, Nienke E.
Usluer, Sunay
Zara, Federico
Palotie, Aarno
Mefford, Heather C.
Scheffer, Ingrid E.
De Jonghe, Peter
Helbig, Ingo
Suls, Arvid
Pitfalls in genetic testing: the story of missed SCN1A mutations
title Pitfalls in genetic testing: the story of missed SCN1A mutations
title_full Pitfalls in genetic testing: the story of missed SCN1A mutations
title_fullStr Pitfalls in genetic testing: the story of missed SCN1A mutations
title_full_unstemmed Pitfalls in genetic testing: the story of missed SCN1A mutations
title_short Pitfalls in genetic testing: the story of missed SCN1A mutations
title_sort pitfalls in genetic testing: the story of missed scn1a mutations
topic Original Articles
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4947864/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27465585
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/mgg3.217
work_keys_str_mv AT djemietania pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT weckhuysensarah pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT vonspiczaksarah pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT carvillgemmal pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT jaehnjohanna pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT anttonenannakaisa pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT brilstraeva pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT caglayanhandes pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT dekovelcarolieng pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT depiennechristel pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT gailyeija pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT gennaroelena pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT giraldezbeatrizg pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT gormleypadhraig pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT guerrerolopezrosa pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT guerrinirenzo pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT hamalaineneija pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT hartmanncorinna pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT hernandezhernandezlaura pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT hjalgrimhelle pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT koelemanbobbypc pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT leguerneric pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT lehesjokiannaelina pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT lemkejohannesr pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT leucostin pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT marinicarla pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT mcmahonjacintam pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT meidavide pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT møllerrikkes pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT muhlehiltrud pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT myerscandacet pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT navacaroline pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT serratosajosem pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT sisodiyasanjaym pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT stephaniulrich pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT strianopasquale pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT vankempenmarjanja pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT verbeeknienkee pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT usluersunay pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT zarafederico pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT palotieaarno pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT meffordheatherc pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT schefferingride pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT dejonghepeter pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT helbigingo pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT sulsarvid pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations
AT pitfallsingenetictestingthestoryofmissedscn1amutations