Cargando…

The use of mosquito repellents at three sites in India with declining malaria transmission: surveys in the community and clinic

BACKGROUND: Repellents such as coils, vaporizers, mats and creams can be used to reduce the risk of malaria and other infectious diseases. Although evidence for their effectiveness is limited, they are advertised as providing an additional approach to mosquito control in combination with other strat...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: van Eijk, Anna Maria, Ramanathapuram, Lalitha, Sutton, Patrick L., Peddy, Nandini, Choubey, Sandhya, Mohanty, Stuti, Asokan, Aswin, Ravishankaran, Sangamithra, Priya, G Sri Lakshmi, Johnson, Justin Amala, Velayutham, Sangeetha, Kanagaraj, Deena, Patel, Ankita, Desai, Nisha, Tandel, Nikunj, Sullivan, Steven A., Wassmer, Samuel C., Singh, Ranveer, Pradhan, K, Carlton, Jane M., Srivasatava, H. C., Eapen, Alex, Sharma, S. K.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: BioMed Central 2016
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4963934/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27465199
http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s13071-016-1709-9
_version_ 1782445011194871808
author van Eijk, Anna Maria
Ramanathapuram, Lalitha
Sutton, Patrick L.
Peddy, Nandini
Choubey, Sandhya
Mohanty, Stuti
Asokan, Aswin
Ravishankaran, Sangamithra
Priya, G Sri Lakshmi
Johnson, Justin Amala
Velayutham, Sangeetha
Kanagaraj, Deena
Patel, Ankita
Desai, Nisha
Tandel, Nikunj
Sullivan, Steven A.
Wassmer, Samuel C.
Singh, Ranveer
Pradhan, K
Carlton, Jane M.
Srivasatava, H. C.
Eapen, Alex
Sharma, S. K.
author_facet van Eijk, Anna Maria
Ramanathapuram, Lalitha
Sutton, Patrick L.
Peddy, Nandini
Choubey, Sandhya
Mohanty, Stuti
Asokan, Aswin
Ravishankaran, Sangamithra
Priya, G Sri Lakshmi
Johnson, Justin Amala
Velayutham, Sangeetha
Kanagaraj, Deena
Patel, Ankita
Desai, Nisha
Tandel, Nikunj
Sullivan, Steven A.
Wassmer, Samuel C.
Singh, Ranveer
Pradhan, K
Carlton, Jane M.
Srivasatava, H. C.
Eapen, Alex
Sharma, S. K.
author_sort van Eijk, Anna Maria
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Repellents such as coils, vaporizers, mats and creams can be used to reduce the risk of malaria and other infectious diseases. Although evidence for their effectiveness is limited, they are advertised as providing an additional approach to mosquito control in combination with other strategies, e.g. insecticide-treated nets. We examined the use of repellents in India in an urban setting in Chennai (mainly Plasmodium vivax malaria), a peri-urban setting in Nadiad (both P. vivax and P. falciparum malaria), and a more rural setting in Raurkela (mainly P. falciparum malaria). METHODS: The use of repellents was examined at the household level during a census, and at the individual level in cross-sectional surveys and among patients visiting a clinic with fever or other symptoms. Factors associated with their use were examined in a multivariate analysis, and the association between malaria and the use of repellents was assessed among survey- and clinic participants. RESULTS: Characteristics of participants differed by region, with more people of higher education present in Chennai. Use of repellents varied between 56–77 % at the household level and between 32–78 % at the individual level. Vaporizers were the main repellents used in Chennai, whereas coils were more common in Nadiad and Raurkela. In Chennai and Nadiad, vaporizers were more likely to be used in households with young male children. Vaporizer use was associated with higher socio-economic status (SES) in households in Chennai and Nadiad, whereas use of coils was greater in the lower SES strata. In Raurkela, there was a higher use of coils among the higher SES strata. Education was associated with the use of a repellent among survey participants in Chennai and clinic study participants in Chennai and Nadiad. Repellent use was associated with less malaria in the clinic study in Chennai and Raurkela, but not in the surveys, with the exception of the use of coils in Nadiad. CONCLUSIONS: Repellents are widely used in India. Their use is influenced by the level of education and SES. Information on effectiveness and guidance on choices may improve rational use. ELECTRONIC SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL: The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s13071-016-1709-9) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-4963934
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2016
publisher BioMed Central
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-49639342016-07-29 The use of mosquito repellents at three sites in India with declining malaria transmission: surveys in the community and clinic van Eijk, Anna Maria Ramanathapuram, Lalitha Sutton, Patrick L. Peddy, Nandini Choubey, Sandhya Mohanty, Stuti Asokan, Aswin Ravishankaran, Sangamithra Priya, G Sri Lakshmi Johnson, Justin Amala Velayutham, Sangeetha Kanagaraj, Deena Patel, Ankita Desai, Nisha Tandel, Nikunj Sullivan, Steven A. Wassmer, Samuel C. Singh, Ranveer Pradhan, K Carlton, Jane M. Srivasatava, H. C. Eapen, Alex Sharma, S. K. Parasit Vectors Research BACKGROUND: Repellents such as coils, vaporizers, mats and creams can be used to reduce the risk of malaria and other infectious diseases. Although evidence for their effectiveness is limited, they are advertised as providing an additional approach to mosquito control in combination with other strategies, e.g. insecticide-treated nets. We examined the use of repellents in India in an urban setting in Chennai (mainly Plasmodium vivax malaria), a peri-urban setting in Nadiad (both P. vivax and P. falciparum malaria), and a more rural setting in Raurkela (mainly P. falciparum malaria). METHODS: The use of repellents was examined at the household level during a census, and at the individual level in cross-sectional surveys and among patients visiting a clinic with fever or other symptoms. Factors associated with their use were examined in a multivariate analysis, and the association between malaria and the use of repellents was assessed among survey- and clinic participants. RESULTS: Characteristics of participants differed by region, with more people of higher education present in Chennai. Use of repellents varied between 56–77 % at the household level and between 32–78 % at the individual level. Vaporizers were the main repellents used in Chennai, whereas coils were more common in Nadiad and Raurkela. In Chennai and Nadiad, vaporizers were more likely to be used in households with young male children. Vaporizer use was associated with higher socio-economic status (SES) in households in Chennai and Nadiad, whereas use of coils was greater in the lower SES strata. In Raurkela, there was a higher use of coils among the higher SES strata. Education was associated with the use of a repellent among survey participants in Chennai and clinic study participants in Chennai and Nadiad. Repellent use was associated with less malaria in the clinic study in Chennai and Raurkela, but not in the surveys, with the exception of the use of coils in Nadiad. CONCLUSIONS: Repellents are widely used in India. Their use is influenced by the level of education and SES. Information on effectiveness and guidance on choices may improve rational use. ELECTRONIC SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL: The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s13071-016-1709-9) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users. BioMed Central 2016-07-27 /pmc/articles/PMC4963934/ /pubmed/27465199 http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s13071-016-1709-9 Text en © The Author(s). 2016 Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.
spellingShingle Research
van Eijk, Anna Maria
Ramanathapuram, Lalitha
Sutton, Patrick L.
Peddy, Nandini
Choubey, Sandhya
Mohanty, Stuti
Asokan, Aswin
Ravishankaran, Sangamithra
Priya, G Sri Lakshmi
Johnson, Justin Amala
Velayutham, Sangeetha
Kanagaraj, Deena
Patel, Ankita
Desai, Nisha
Tandel, Nikunj
Sullivan, Steven A.
Wassmer, Samuel C.
Singh, Ranveer
Pradhan, K
Carlton, Jane M.
Srivasatava, H. C.
Eapen, Alex
Sharma, S. K.
The use of mosquito repellents at three sites in India with declining malaria transmission: surveys in the community and clinic
title The use of mosquito repellents at three sites in India with declining malaria transmission: surveys in the community and clinic
title_full The use of mosquito repellents at three sites in India with declining malaria transmission: surveys in the community and clinic
title_fullStr The use of mosquito repellents at three sites in India with declining malaria transmission: surveys in the community and clinic
title_full_unstemmed The use of mosquito repellents at three sites in India with declining malaria transmission: surveys in the community and clinic
title_short The use of mosquito repellents at three sites in India with declining malaria transmission: surveys in the community and clinic
title_sort use of mosquito repellents at three sites in india with declining malaria transmission: surveys in the community and clinic
topic Research
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4963934/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27465199
http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s13071-016-1709-9
work_keys_str_mv AT vaneijkannamaria theuseofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT ramanathapuramlalitha theuseofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT suttonpatrickl theuseofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT peddynandini theuseofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT choubeysandhya theuseofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT mohantystuti theuseofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT asokanaswin theuseofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT ravishankaransangamithra theuseofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT priyagsrilakshmi theuseofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT johnsonjustinamala theuseofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT velayuthamsangeetha theuseofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT kanagarajdeena theuseofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT patelankita theuseofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT desainisha theuseofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT tandelnikunj theuseofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT sullivanstevena theuseofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT wassmersamuelc theuseofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT singhranveer theuseofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT pradhank theuseofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT carltonjanem theuseofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT srivasatavahc theuseofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT eapenalex theuseofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT sharmask theuseofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT vaneijkannamaria useofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT ramanathapuramlalitha useofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT suttonpatrickl useofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT peddynandini useofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT choubeysandhya useofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT mohantystuti useofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT asokanaswin useofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT ravishankaransangamithra useofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT priyagsrilakshmi useofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT johnsonjustinamala useofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT velayuthamsangeetha useofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT kanagarajdeena useofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT patelankita useofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT desainisha useofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT tandelnikunj useofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT sullivanstevena useofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT wassmersamuelc useofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT singhranveer useofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT pradhank useofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT carltonjanem useofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT srivasatavahc useofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT eapenalex useofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic
AT sharmask useofmosquitorepellentsatthreesitesinindiawithdecliningmalariatransmissionsurveysinthecommunityandclinic