Cargando…

Correspondence in Stakeholder Assessment of Health, Work Capacity and Sick Leave in Workers with Comorbid Subjective Health Complaints? A Video Vignette Study

Purpose The purpose of this study is to test if there is correspondence in stakeholders’ assessments of health, work capacity and sickness certification in four workers with comorbid subjective health complaints based on video vignettes. Methods A cross sectional survey among stakeholders (N = 514)...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Maeland, Silje, Magnussen, Liv Heide, Eriksen, Hege R., Werner, Erik L., Helle-Valle, Anna, Hensing, Gunnel
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Springer US 2015
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4967420/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26615412
http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10926-015-9618-x
_version_ 1782445509991989248
author Maeland, Silje
Magnussen, Liv Heide
Eriksen, Hege R.
Werner, Erik L.
Helle-Valle, Anna
Hensing, Gunnel
author_facet Maeland, Silje
Magnussen, Liv Heide
Eriksen, Hege R.
Werner, Erik L.
Helle-Valle, Anna
Hensing, Gunnel
author_sort Maeland, Silje
collection PubMed
description Purpose The purpose of this study is to test if there is correspondence in stakeholders’ assessments of health, work capacity and sickness certification in four workers with comorbid subjective health complaints based on video vignettes. Methods A cross sectional survey among stakeholders (N = 514) in Norway in 2009/2010. Logistic regression and multinomial logistic regression was used to obtain the estimated probability of stakeholders choosing 100 % sick leave, partial sick leave or work and the estimation of odds ratio of stakeholder assessment compared to the other stakeholders for the individual worker. Results The supervisors were less likely to assess poor health and reduced work capacity, and more likely to suggest partial sick leave and full time work compared to the GPs for worker 1. The public was less likely to assess comorbidity and reduced work capacity, and 6 and 12 times more likely to suggest partial sick leave and full time work compared to the GPs for worker 1. Stakeholders generally agreed in their assessments of workers 2 and 3. The public was more likely to assess poor health, comorbidity and reduced work capacity, and the supervisors more likely to assess comorbidity and reduced work capacity, compared to the GPs for worker 4. Compared to the GPs, all other stakeholders were less likely to suggest full time work for this worker. Conclusions Our results seem to suggest that stakeholders have divergent assessments of complaints, health, work capacity, and sickness certification in workers with comorbid subjective health complaints.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-4967420
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2015
publisher Springer US
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-49674202016-08-12 Correspondence in Stakeholder Assessment of Health, Work Capacity and Sick Leave in Workers with Comorbid Subjective Health Complaints? A Video Vignette Study Maeland, Silje Magnussen, Liv Heide Eriksen, Hege R. Werner, Erik L. Helle-Valle, Anna Hensing, Gunnel J Occup Rehabil Article Purpose The purpose of this study is to test if there is correspondence in stakeholders’ assessments of health, work capacity and sickness certification in four workers with comorbid subjective health complaints based on video vignettes. Methods A cross sectional survey among stakeholders (N = 514) in Norway in 2009/2010. Logistic regression and multinomial logistic regression was used to obtain the estimated probability of stakeholders choosing 100 % sick leave, partial sick leave or work and the estimation of odds ratio of stakeholder assessment compared to the other stakeholders for the individual worker. Results The supervisors were less likely to assess poor health and reduced work capacity, and more likely to suggest partial sick leave and full time work compared to the GPs for worker 1. The public was less likely to assess comorbidity and reduced work capacity, and 6 and 12 times more likely to suggest partial sick leave and full time work compared to the GPs for worker 1. Stakeholders generally agreed in their assessments of workers 2 and 3. The public was more likely to assess poor health, comorbidity and reduced work capacity, and the supervisors more likely to assess comorbidity and reduced work capacity, compared to the GPs for worker 4. Compared to the GPs, all other stakeholders were less likely to suggest full time work for this worker. Conclusions Our results seem to suggest that stakeholders have divergent assessments of complaints, health, work capacity, and sickness certification in workers with comorbid subjective health complaints. Springer US 2015-11-28 2016 /pmc/articles/PMC4967420/ /pubmed/26615412 http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10926-015-9618-x Text en © Springer Science+Business Media New York 2015
spellingShingle Article
Maeland, Silje
Magnussen, Liv Heide
Eriksen, Hege R.
Werner, Erik L.
Helle-Valle, Anna
Hensing, Gunnel
Correspondence in Stakeholder Assessment of Health, Work Capacity and Sick Leave in Workers with Comorbid Subjective Health Complaints? A Video Vignette Study
title Correspondence in Stakeholder Assessment of Health, Work Capacity and Sick Leave in Workers with Comorbid Subjective Health Complaints? A Video Vignette Study
title_full Correspondence in Stakeholder Assessment of Health, Work Capacity and Sick Leave in Workers with Comorbid Subjective Health Complaints? A Video Vignette Study
title_fullStr Correspondence in Stakeholder Assessment of Health, Work Capacity and Sick Leave in Workers with Comorbid Subjective Health Complaints? A Video Vignette Study
title_full_unstemmed Correspondence in Stakeholder Assessment of Health, Work Capacity and Sick Leave in Workers with Comorbid Subjective Health Complaints? A Video Vignette Study
title_short Correspondence in Stakeholder Assessment of Health, Work Capacity and Sick Leave in Workers with Comorbid Subjective Health Complaints? A Video Vignette Study
title_sort correspondence in stakeholder assessment of health, work capacity and sick leave in workers with comorbid subjective health complaints? a video vignette study
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4967420/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26615412
http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10926-015-9618-x
work_keys_str_mv AT maelandsilje correspondenceinstakeholderassessmentofhealthworkcapacityandsickleaveinworkerswithcomorbidsubjectivehealthcomplaintsavideovignettestudy
AT magnussenlivheide correspondenceinstakeholderassessmentofhealthworkcapacityandsickleaveinworkerswithcomorbidsubjectivehealthcomplaintsavideovignettestudy
AT eriksenheger correspondenceinstakeholderassessmentofhealthworkcapacityandsickleaveinworkerswithcomorbidsubjectivehealthcomplaintsavideovignettestudy
AT wernererikl correspondenceinstakeholderassessmentofhealthworkcapacityandsickleaveinworkerswithcomorbidsubjectivehealthcomplaintsavideovignettestudy
AT hellevalleanna correspondenceinstakeholderassessmentofhealthworkcapacityandsickleaveinworkerswithcomorbidsubjectivehealthcomplaintsavideovignettestudy
AT hensinggunnel correspondenceinstakeholderassessmentofhealthworkcapacityandsickleaveinworkerswithcomorbidsubjectivehealthcomplaintsavideovignettestudy