Cargando…
Estimation of daily interfractional larynx residual setup error after isocentric alignment for head and neck radiotherapy: quality assurance implications for target volume and organs‐at‐risk margination using daily CT on‐rails imaging
Larynx may alternatively serve as a target or organs at risk (OAR) in head and neck cancer (HNC) image‐guided radiotherapy (IGRT). The objective of this study was to estimate IGRT parameters required for larynx positional error independent of isocentric alignment and suggest population‐based compens...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
John Wiley and Sons Inc.
2014
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5016194/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25679151 http://dx.doi.org/10.1120/jacmp.v16i1.5108 |
_version_ | 1782452542274273280 |
---|---|
author | Baron, Charles A. Awan, Musaddiq J. Mohamed, Abdallah S.R. Akel, Imad Rosenthal, David I. Gunn, G. Brandon Garden, Adam S. Dyer, Brandon A. Court, Laurence Sevak, Parag R. Kocak‐Uzel, Esengul Fuller, Clifton D. |
author_facet | Baron, Charles A. Awan, Musaddiq J. Mohamed, Abdallah S.R. Akel, Imad Rosenthal, David I. Gunn, G. Brandon Garden, Adam S. Dyer, Brandon A. Court, Laurence Sevak, Parag R. Kocak‐Uzel, Esengul Fuller, Clifton D. |
author_sort | Baron, Charles A. |
collection | PubMed |
description | Larynx may alternatively serve as a target or organs at risk (OAR) in head and neck cancer (HNC) image‐guided radiotherapy (IGRT). The objective of this study was to estimate IGRT parameters required for larynx positional error independent of isocentric alignment and suggest population‐based compensatory margins. Ten HNC patients receiving radiotherapy (RT) with daily CT on‐rails imaging were assessed. Seven landmark points were placed on each daily scan. Taking the most superior‐anterior point of the C5 vertebra as a reference isocenter for each scan, residual displacement vectors to the other six points were calculated postisocentric alignment. Subsequently, using the first scan as a reference, the magnitude of vector differences for all six points for all scans over the course of treatment was calculated. Residual systematic and random error and the necessary compensatory CTV‐to‐PTV and OAR‐to‐PRV margins were calculated, using both observational cohort data and a bootstrap‐resampled population estimator. The grand mean displacements for all anatomical points was 5.07 mm, with mean systematic error of 1.1 mm and mean random setup error of 2.63 mm, while bootstrapped POIs grand mean displacement was 5.09 mm, with mean systematic error of 1.23 mm and mean random setup error of 2.61 mm. Required margin for CTV‐PTV expansion was 4.6 mm for all cohort points, while the bootstrap estimator of the equivalent margin was 4.9 mm. The calculated OAR‐to‐PRV expansion for the observed residual setup error was 2.7 mm and bootstrap estimated expansion of 2.9 mm. We conclude that the interfractional larynx setup error is a significant source of RT setup/delivery error in HNC, both when the larynx is considered as a CTV or OAR. We estimate the need for a uniform expansion of 5 mm to compensate for setup error if the larynx is a target, or 3 mm if the larynx is an OAR, when using a nonlaryngeal bony isocenter. PACS numbers: 87.55.D‐, 87.55.Qr |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-5016194 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2014 |
publisher | John Wiley and Sons Inc. |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-50161942018-04-02 Estimation of daily interfractional larynx residual setup error after isocentric alignment for head and neck radiotherapy: quality assurance implications for target volume and organs‐at‐risk margination using daily CT on‐rails imaging Baron, Charles A. Awan, Musaddiq J. Mohamed, Abdallah S.R. Akel, Imad Rosenthal, David I. Gunn, G. Brandon Garden, Adam S. Dyer, Brandon A. Court, Laurence Sevak, Parag R. Kocak‐Uzel, Esengul Fuller, Clifton D. J Appl Clin Med Phys Radiation Oncology Physics Larynx may alternatively serve as a target or organs at risk (OAR) in head and neck cancer (HNC) image‐guided radiotherapy (IGRT). The objective of this study was to estimate IGRT parameters required for larynx positional error independent of isocentric alignment and suggest population‐based compensatory margins. Ten HNC patients receiving radiotherapy (RT) with daily CT on‐rails imaging were assessed. Seven landmark points were placed on each daily scan. Taking the most superior‐anterior point of the C5 vertebra as a reference isocenter for each scan, residual displacement vectors to the other six points were calculated postisocentric alignment. Subsequently, using the first scan as a reference, the magnitude of vector differences for all six points for all scans over the course of treatment was calculated. Residual systematic and random error and the necessary compensatory CTV‐to‐PTV and OAR‐to‐PRV margins were calculated, using both observational cohort data and a bootstrap‐resampled population estimator. The grand mean displacements for all anatomical points was 5.07 mm, with mean systematic error of 1.1 mm and mean random setup error of 2.63 mm, while bootstrapped POIs grand mean displacement was 5.09 mm, with mean systematic error of 1.23 mm and mean random setup error of 2.61 mm. Required margin for CTV‐PTV expansion was 4.6 mm for all cohort points, while the bootstrap estimator of the equivalent margin was 4.9 mm. The calculated OAR‐to‐PRV expansion for the observed residual setup error was 2.7 mm and bootstrap estimated expansion of 2.9 mm. We conclude that the interfractional larynx setup error is a significant source of RT setup/delivery error in HNC, both when the larynx is considered as a CTV or OAR. We estimate the need for a uniform expansion of 5 mm to compensate for setup error if the larynx is a target, or 3 mm if the larynx is an OAR, when using a nonlaryngeal bony isocenter. PACS numbers: 87.55.D‐, 87.55.Qr John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2014-01-08 /pmc/articles/PMC5016194/ /pubmed/25679151 http://dx.doi.org/10.1120/jacmp.v16i1.5108 Text en © 2015 The Authors. This is an open access article under the terms of the http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. |
spellingShingle | Radiation Oncology Physics Baron, Charles A. Awan, Musaddiq J. Mohamed, Abdallah S.R. Akel, Imad Rosenthal, David I. Gunn, G. Brandon Garden, Adam S. Dyer, Brandon A. Court, Laurence Sevak, Parag R. Kocak‐Uzel, Esengul Fuller, Clifton D. Estimation of daily interfractional larynx residual setup error after isocentric alignment for head and neck radiotherapy: quality assurance implications for target volume and organs‐at‐risk margination using daily CT on‐rails imaging |
title | Estimation of daily interfractional larynx residual setup error after isocentric alignment for head and neck radiotherapy: quality assurance implications for target volume and organs‐at‐risk margination using daily CT on‐rails imaging |
title_full | Estimation of daily interfractional larynx residual setup error after isocentric alignment for head and neck radiotherapy: quality assurance implications for target volume and organs‐at‐risk margination using daily CT on‐rails imaging |
title_fullStr | Estimation of daily interfractional larynx residual setup error after isocentric alignment for head and neck radiotherapy: quality assurance implications for target volume and organs‐at‐risk margination using daily CT on‐rails imaging |
title_full_unstemmed | Estimation of daily interfractional larynx residual setup error after isocentric alignment for head and neck radiotherapy: quality assurance implications for target volume and organs‐at‐risk margination using daily CT on‐rails imaging |
title_short | Estimation of daily interfractional larynx residual setup error after isocentric alignment for head and neck radiotherapy: quality assurance implications for target volume and organs‐at‐risk margination using daily CT on‐rails imaging |
title_sort | estimation of daily interfractional larynx residual setup error after isocentric alignment for head and neck radiotherapy: quality assurance implications for target volume and organs‐at‐risk margination using daily ct on‐rails imaging |
topic | Radiation Oncology Physics |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5016194/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25679151 http://dx.doi.org/10.1120/jacmp.v16i1.5108 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT baroncharlesa estimationofdailyinterfractionallarynxresidualsetuperrorafterisocentricalignmentforheadandneckradiotherapyqualityassuranceimplicationsfortargetvolumeandorgansatriskmarginationusingdailyctonrailsimaging AT awanmusaddiqj estimationofdailyinterfractionallarynxresidualsetuperrorafterisocentricalignmentforheadandneckradiotherapyqualityassuranceimplicationsfortargetvolumeandorgansatriskmarginationusingdailyctonrailsimaging AT mohamedabdallahsr estimationofdailyinterfractionallarynxresidualsetuperrorafterisocentricalignmentforheadandneckradiotherapyqualityassuranceimplicationsfortargetvolumeandorgansatriskmarginationusingdailyctonrailsimaging AT akelimad estimationofdailyinterfractionallarynxresidualsetuperrorafterisocentricalignmentforheadandneckradiotherapyqualityassuranceimplicationsfortargetvolumeandorgansatriskmarginationusingdailyctonrailsimaging AT rosenthaldavidi estimationofdailyinterfractionallarynxresidualsetuperrorafterisocentricalignmentforheadandneckradiotherapyqualityassuranceimplicationsfortargetvolumeandorgansatriskmarginationusingdailyctonrailsimaging AT gunngbrandon estimationofdailyinterfractionallarynxresidualsetuperrorafterisocentricalignmentforheadandneckradiotherapyqualityassuranceimplicationsfortargetvolumeandorgansatriskmarginationusingdailyctonrailsimaging AT gardenadams estimationofdailyinterfractionallarynxresidualsetuperrorafterisocentricalignmentforheadandneckradiotherapyqualityassuranceimplicationsfortargetvolumeandorgansatriskmarginationusingdailyctonrailsimaging AT dyerbrandona estimationofdailyinterfractionallarynxresidualsetuperrorafterisocentricalignmentforheadandneckradiotherapyqualityassuranceimplicationsfortargetvolumeandorgansatriskmarginationusingdailyctonrailsimaging AT courtlaurence estimationofdailyinterfractionallarynxresidualsetuperrorafterisocentricalignmentforheadandneckradiotherapyqualityassuranceimplicationsfortargetvolumeandorgansatriskmarginationusingdailyctonrailsimaging AT sevakparagr estimationofdailyinterfractionallarynxresidualsetuperrorafterisocentricalignmentforheadandneckradiotherapyqualityassuranceimplicationsfortargetvolumeandorgansatriskmarginationusingdailyctonrailsimaging AT kocakuzelesengul estimationofdailyinterfractionallarynxresidualsetuperrorafterisocentricalignmentforheadandneckradiotherapyqualityassuranceimplicationsfortargetvolumeandorgansatriskmarginationusingdailyctonrailsimaging AT fullercliftond estimationofdailyinterfractionallarynxresidualsetuperrorafterisocentricalignmentforheadandneckradiotherapyqualityassuranceimplicationsfortargetvolumeandorgansatriskmarginationusingdailyctonrailsimaging |