Cargando…

A standardized, evidence-based protocol to assess clinical actionability of genetic disorders associated with genomic variation

PURPOSE: Genome and exome sequencing can identify variants unrelated to the primary goal of sequencing. Detecting pathogenic variants associated with an increased risk of a medical disorder enables clinical interventions to improve future health outcomes in patients and their at-risk relatives. The...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Hunter, Jessica Ezzell, Irving, Stephanie A., Biesecker, Leslie G., Buchanan, Adam, Jensen, Brian, Lee, Kristy, Martin, Christa Lese, Milko, Laura, Muessig, Kristin, Niehaus, Annie D., O'Daniel, Julianne, Piper, Margaret A., Ramos, Erin M., Schully, Sheri D., Scott, Alan F., Slavotinek, Anne, Sobreira, Nara, Strande, Natasha, Weaver, Meredith, Webber, Elizabeth M., Williams, Marc S., Berg, Jonathan S., Evans, James P., Goddard, Katrina A.B.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Nature Publishing Group 2016
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5085884/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27124788
http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/gim.2016.40
_version_ 1782463655183384576
author Hunter, Jessica Ezzell
Irving, Stephanie A.
Biesecker, Leslie G.
Buchanan, Adam
Jensen, Brian
Lee, Kristy
Martin, Christa Lese
Milko, Laura
Muessig, Kristin
Niehaus, Annie D.
O'Daniel, Julianne
Piper, Margaret A.
Ramos, Erin M.
Schully, Sheri D.
Scott, Alan F.
Slavotinek, Anne
Sobreira, Nara
Strande, Natasha
Weaver, Meredith
Webber, Elizabeth M.
Williams, Marc S.
Berg, Jonathan S.
Evans, James P.
Goddard, Katrina A.B.
author_facet Hunter, Jessica Ezzell
Irving, Stephanie A.
Biesecker, Leslie G.
Buchanan, Adam
Jensen, Brian
Lee, Kristy
Martin, Christa Lese
Milko, Laura
Muessig, Kristin
Niehaus, Annie D.
O'Daniel, Julianne
Piper, Margaret A.
Ramos, Erin M.
Schully, Sheri D.
Scott, Alan F.
Slavotinek, Anne
Sobreira, Nara
Strande, Natasha
Weaver, Meredith
Webber, Elizabeth M.
Williams, Marc S.
Berg, Jonathan S.
Evans, James P.
Goddard, Katrina A.B.
author_sort Hunter, Jessica Ezzell
collection PubMed
description PURPOSE: Genome and exome sequencing can identify variants unrelated to the primary goal of sequencing. Detecting pathogenic variants associated with an increased risk of a medical disorder enables clinical interventions to improve future health outcomes in patients and their at-risk relatives. The Clinical Genome Resource, or ClinGen, aims to assess clinical actionability of genes and associated disorders as part of a larger effort to build a central resource of information regarding the clinical relevance of genomic variation for use in precision medicine and research. METHODS: We developed a practical, standardized protocol to identify available evidence and generate qualitative summary reports of actionability for disorders and associated genes. We applied a semiquantitative metric to score actionability. RESULTS: We generated summary reports and actionability scores for the 56 genes and associated disorders recommended by the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics for return as secondary findings from clinical genome-scale sequencing. We also describe the challenges that arose during the development of the protocol that highlight important issues in characterizing actionability across a range of disorders. CONCLUSION: The ClinGen framework for actionability assessment will assist research and clinical communities in making clear, efficient, and consistent determinations of actionability based on transparent criteria to guide analysis and reporting of findings from clinical genome-scale sequencing. Genet Med 18 12, 1258–1268.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-5085884
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2016
publisher Nature Publishing Group
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-50858842016-12-02 A standardized, evidence-based protocol to assess clinical actionability of genetic disorders associated with genomic variation Hunter, Jessica Ezzell Irving, Stephanie A. Biesecker, Leslie G. Buchanan, Adam Jensen, Brian Lee, Kristy Martin, Christa Lese Milko, Laura Muessig, Kristin Niehaus, Annie D. O'Daniel, Julianne Piper, Margaret A. Ramos, Erin M. Schully, Sheri D. Scott, Alan F. Slavotinek, Anne Sobreira, Nara Strande, Natasha Weaver, Meredith Webber, Elizabeth M. Williams, Marc S. Berg, Jonathan S. Evans, James P. Goddard, Katrina A.B. Genet Med Original Research Article PURPOSE: Genome and exome sequencing can identify variants unrelated to the primary goal of sequencing. Detecting pathogenic variants associated with an increased risk of a medical disorder enables clinical interventions to improve future health outcomes in patients and their at-risk relatives. The Clinical Genome Resource, or ClinGen, aims to assess clinical actionability of genes and associated disorders as part of a larger effort to build a central resource of information regarding the clinical relevance of genomic variation for use in precision medicine and research. METHODS: We developed a practical, standardized protocol to identify available evidence and generate qualitative summary reports of actionability for disorders and associated genes. We applied a semiquantitative metric to score actionability. RESULTS: We generated summary reports and actionability scores for the 56 genes and associated disorders recommended by the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics for return as secondary findings from clinical genome-scale sequencing. We also describe the challenges that arose during the development of the protocol that highlight important issues in characterizing actionability across a range of disorders. CONCLUSION: The ClinGen framework for actionability assessment will assist research and clinical communities in making clear, efficient, and consistent determinations of actionability based on transparent criteria to guide analysis and reporting of findings from clinical genome-scale sequencing. Genet Med 18 12, 1258–1268. Nature Publishing Group 2016-12 2016-04-28 /pmc/articles/PMC5085884/ /pubmed/27124788 http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/gim.2016.40 Text en Copyright © 2016 Official journal of the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 4.0 International License. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in the credit line; if the material is not included under the Creative Commons license, users will need to obtain permission from the license holder to reproduce the material. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
spellingShingle Original Research Article
Hunter, Jessica Ezzell
Irving, Stephanie A.
Biesecker, Leslie G.
Buchanan, Adam
Jensen, Brian
Lee, Kristy
Martin, Christa Lese
Milko, Laura
Muessig, Kristin
Niehaus, Annie D.
O'Daniel, Julianne
Piper, Margaret A.
Ramos, Erin M.
Schully, Sheri D.
Scott, Alan F.
Slavotinek, Anne
Sobreira, Nara
Strande, Natasha
Weaver, Meredith
Webber, Elizabeth M.
Williams, Marc S.
Berg, Jonathan S.
Evans, James P.
Goddard, Katrina A.B.
A standardized, evidence-based protocol to assess clinical actionability of genetic disorders associated with genomic variation
title A standardized, evidence-based protocol to assess clinical actionability of genetic disorders associated with genomic variation
title_full A standardized, evidence-based protocol to assess clinical actionability of genetic disorders associated with genomic variation
title_fullStr A standardized, evidence-based protocol to assess clinical actionability of genetic disorders associated with genomic variation
title_full_unstemmed A standardized, evidence-based protocol to assess clinical actionability of genetic disorders associated with genomic variation
title_short A standardized, evidence-based protocol to assess clinical actionability of genetic disorders associated with genomic variation
title_sort standardized, evidence-based protocol to assess clinical actionability of genetic disorders associated with genomic variation
topic Original Research Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5085884/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27124788
http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/gim.2016.40
work_keys_str_mv AT hunterjessicaezzell astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT irvingstephaniea astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT bieseckerleslieg astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT buchananadam astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT jensenbrian astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT leekristy astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT martinchristalese astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT milkolaura astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT muessigkristin astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT niehausannied astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT odanieljulianne astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT pipermargareta astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT ramoserinm astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT schullysherid astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT scottalanf astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT slavotinekanne astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT sobreiranara astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT strandenatasha astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT weavermeredith astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT webberelizabethm astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT williamsmarcs astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT bergjonathans astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT evansjamesp astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT goddardkatrinaab astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT astandardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT hunterjessicaezzell standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT irvingstephaniea standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT bieseckerleslieg standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT buchananadam standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT jensenbrian standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT leekristy standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT martinchristalese standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT milkolaura standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT muessigkristin standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT niehausannied standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT odanieljulianne standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT pipermargareta standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT ramoserinm standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT schullysherid standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT scottalanf standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT slavotinekanne standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT sobreiranara standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT strandenatasha standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT weavermeredith standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT webberelizabethm standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT williamsmarcs standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT bergjonathans standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT evansjamesp standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT goddardkatrinaab standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation
AT standardizedevidencebasedprotocoltoassessclinicalactionabilityofgeneticdisordersassociatedwithgenomicvariation