Cargando…

A massive experiment on choice blindness in political decisions: Confidence, confabulation, and unconscious detection of self-deception

We implemented a Choice Blindness Paradigm containing political statements in Argentina to reveal the existence of categorical ranges of introspective reports, identified by confidence and agreement levels, separating easy from very hard to manipulate decisions. CBP was implemented in both live and...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Rieznik, Andrés, Moscovich, Lorena, Frieiro, Alan, Figini, Julieta, Catalano, Rodrigo, Garrido, Juan Manuel, Álvarez Heduan, Facundo, Sigman, Mariano, Gonzalez, Pablo A.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Public Library of Science 2017
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5308842/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/28196093
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0171108
_version_ 1782507611217723392
author Rieznik, Andrés
Moscovich, Lorena
Frieiro, Alan
Figini, Julieta
Catalano, Rodrigo
Garrido, Juan Manuel
Álvarez Heduan, Facundo
Sigman, Mariano
Gonzalez, Pablo A.
author_facet Rieznik, Andrés
Moscovich, Lorena
Frieiro, Alan
Figini, Julieta
Catalano, Rodrigo
Garrido, Juan Manuel
Álvarez Heduan, Facundo
Sigman, Mariano
Gonzalez, Pablo A.
author_sort Rieznik, Andrés
collection PubMed
description We implemented a Choice Blindness Paradigm containing political statements in Argentina to reveal the existence of categorical ranges of introspective reports, identified by confidence and agreement levels, separating easy from very hard to manipulate decisions. CBP was implemented in both live and web-based forms. Importantly, and contrary to what was observed in Sweden, we did not observe changes in voting intentions. Also, confidence levels in the manipulated replies where significantly lower than in non-manipulated cases even in undetected manipulations. We name this phenomenon unconscious detection of self-deception. Results also show that females are more difficult to manipulate than men.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-5308842
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2017
publisher Public Library of Science
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-53088422017-02-28 A massive experiment on choice blindness in political decisions: Confidence, confabulation, and unconscious detection of self-deception Rieznik, Andrés Moscovich, Lorena Frieiro, Alan Figini, Julieta Catalano, Rodrigo Garrido, Juan Manuel Álvarez Heduan, Facundo Sigman, Mariano Gonzalez, Pablo A. PLoS One Research Article We implemented a Choice Blindness Paradigm containing political statements in Argentina to reveal the existence of categorical ranges of introspective reports, identified by confidence and agreement levels, separating easy from very hard to manipulate decisions. CBP was implemented in both live and web-based forms. Importantly, and contrary to what was observed in Sweden, we did not observe changes in voting intentions. Also, confidence levels in the manipulated replies where significantly lower than in non-manipulated cases even in undetected manipulations. We name this phenomenon unconscious detection of self-deception. Results also show that females are more difficult to manipulate than men. Public Library of Science 2017-02-14 /pmc/articles/PMC5308842/ /pubmed/28196093 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0171108 Text en © 2017 Rieznik et al http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
spellingShingle Research Article
Rieznik, Andrés
Moscovich, Lorena
Frieiro, Alan
Figini, Julieta
Catalano, Rodrigo
Garrido, Juan Manuel
Álvarez Heduan, Facundo
Sigman, Mariano
Gonzalez, Pablo A.
A massive experiment on choice blindness in political decisions: Confidence, confabulation, and unconscious detection of self-deception
title A massive experiment on choice blindness in political decisions: Confidence, confabulation, and unconscious detection of self-deception
title_full A massive experiment on choice blindness in political decisions: Confidence, confabulation, and unconscious detection of self-deception
title_fullStr A massive experiment on choice blindness in political decisions: Confidence, confabulation, and unconscious detection of self-deception
title_full_unstemmed A massive experiment on choice blindness in political decisions: Confidence, confabulation, and unconscious detection of self-deception
title_short A massive experiment on choice blindness in political decisions: Confidence, confabulation, and unconscious detection of self-deception
title_sort massive experiment on choice blindness in political decisions: confidence, confabulation, and unconscious detection of self-deception
topic Research Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5308842/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/28196093
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0171108
work_keys_str_mv AT rieznikandres amassiveexperimentonchoiceblindnessinpoliticaldecisionsconfidenceconfabulationandunconsciousdetectionofselfdeception
AT moscovichlorena amassiveexperimentonchoiceblindnessinpoliticaldecisionsconfidenceconfabulationandunconsciousdetectionofselfdeception
AT frieiroalan amassiveexperimentonchoiceblindnessinpoliticaldecisionsconfidenceconfabulationandunconsciousdetectionofselfdeception
AT figinijulieta amassiveexperimentonchoiceblindnessinpoliticaldecisionsconfidenceconfabulationandunconsciousdetectionofselfdeception
AT catalanorodrigo amassiveexperimentonchoiceblindnessinpoliticaldecisionsconfidenceconfabulationandunconsciousdetectionofselfdeception
AT garridojuanmanuel amassiveexperimentonchoiceblindnessinpoliticaldecisionsconfidenceconfabulationandunconsciousdetectionofselfdeception
AT alvarezheduanfacundo amassiveexperimentonchoiceblindnessinpoliticaldecisionsconfidenceconfabulationandunconsciousdetectionofselfdeception
AT sigmanmariano amassiveexperimentonchoiceblindnessinpoliticaldecisionsconfidenceconfabulationandunconsciousdetectionofselfdeception
AT gonzalezpabloa amassiveexperimentonchoiceblindnessinpoliticaldecisionsconfidenceconfabulationandunconsciousdetectionofselfdeception
AT rieznikandres massiveexperimentonchoiceblindnessinpoliticaldecisionsconfidenceconfabulationandunconsciousdetectionofselfdeception
AT moscovichlorena massiveexperimentonchoiceblindnessinpoliticaldecisionsconfidenceconfabulationandunconsciousdetectionofselfdeception
AT frieiroalan massiveexperimentonchoiceblindnessinpoliticaldecisionsconfidenceconfabulationandunconsciousdetectionofselfdeception
AT figinijulieta massiveexperimentonchoiceblindnessinpoliticaldecisionsconfidenceconfabulationandunconsciousdetectionofselfdeception
AT catalanorodrigo massiveexperimentonchoiceblindnessinpoliticaldecisionsconfidenceconfabulationandunconsciousdetectionofselfdeception
AT garridojuanmanuel massiveexperimentonchoiceblindnessinpoliticaldecisionsconfidenceconfabulationandunconsciousdetectionofselfdeception
AT alvarezheduanfacundo massiveexperimentonchoiceblindnessinpoliticaldecisionsconfidenceconfabulationandunconsciousdetectionofselfdeception
AT sigmanmariano massiveexperimentonchoiceblindnessinpoliticaldecisionsconfidenceconfabulationandunconsciousdetectionofselfdeception
AT gonzalezpabloa massiveexperimentonchoiceblindnessinpoliticaldecisionsconfidenceconfabulationandunconsciousdetectionofselfdeception