The changing 50% inhibitory concentration (IC(50)) of cisplatin: a pilot study on the artifacts of the MTT assay and the precise measurement of density-dependent chemoresistance in ovarian cancer

Inconsistencies in the half-maximal (50%) inhibitory concentration (IC(50)) data for anticancer chemotherapeutic agents have yielded irreproducible experimental results and thus reciprocally contradictory theories in modern cancer research. The MTT assay is currently the most extensively used method for IC(50) measurements. Here, we dissected the critical reasons behind MTT-dependent IC(50) inconsistencies. We showed that IC(50) errors caused by the technical deficiencies of the MTT assay are large and not adjustable (range: 300–11,000%). To overcome severe MTT artifacts, we developed an unbiased direct IC(50) measurement method, the limiting dilution assay. This detection technique led us to the discovery of the inherent density-dependent chemoresistance variation of cancer cells, which is manifold and unpredictable in its forms. The subsequent intracellular signaling pathway analysis indicated that pAkt and p62 expression levels correlated with alterations in the IC(50) values for cisplatin in ovarian cancer, providing an explainable mechanism for this property. An in situ pAkt-and-p62-based immunohistochemical (IHC(pAkt+p62)) scoring system was thereby established. Both the limiting dilution assay and the IHC(pAkt+p62) scoring system accurately predicted the primary chemoresistance against cisplatin in ovarian cancer patients. Furthermore, two distinct chemoresistant recurrence patterns were uncovered using these novel detection tools, which were linked to two different forms of density-chemoresistance relationships (positively vs. negatively correlated), respectively. An interpretation was given based on the cancer evolution theory. We concluded that the density-related IC(50) uncertainty is a natural property of the cancer cells and that the precise measurement of the density-dependent IC(50) spectrum can benefit both basic and clinical cancer research fields.