Cargando…

Blood‐based detection of RAS mutations to guide anti‐EGFR therapy in colorectal cancer patients: concordance of results from circulating tumor DNA and tissue‐based RAS testing

An accurate blood‐based RAS mutation assay to determine eligibility of metastatic colorectal cancer (mCRC) patients for anti‐EGFR therapy would benefit clinical practice by better informing decisions to administer treatment independent of tissue availability. The objective of this study was to deter...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Schmiegel, Wolff, Scott, Rodney J., Dooley, Susan, Lewis, Wendy, Meldrum, Cliff J., Pockney, Peter, Draganic, Brian, Smith, Steve, Hewitt, Chelsee, Philimore, Hazel, Lucas, Amanda, Shi, Elva, Namdarian, Kateh, Chan, Timmy, Acosta, Danilo, Ping‐Chang, Su, Tannapfel, Andrea, Reinacher‐Schick, Anke, Uhl, Waldemar, Teschendorf, Christian, Wolters, Heiner, Stern, Josef, Viebahn, Richard, Friess, Helmut, Janssen, Klaus‐Peter, Nitsche, Ulrich, Slotta‐Huspenina, Julia, Pohl, Michael, Vangala, Deepak, Baraniskin, Alexander, Dockhorn‐Dworniczak, Barbara, Hegewisch‐Becker, Susanne, Ronga, Philippe, Edelstein, Daniel L., Jones, Frederick S., Hahn, Stephan, Fox, Stephen B.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2017
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5527457/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/28106345
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/1878-0261.12023
_version_ 1783252965067325440
author Schmiegel, Wolff
Scott, Rodney J.
Dooley, Susan
Lewis, Wendy
Meldrum, Cliff J.
Pockney, Peter
Draganic, Brian
Smith, Steve
Hewitt, Chelsee
Philimore, Hazel
Lucas, Amanda
Shi, Elva
Namdarian, Kateh
Chan, Timmy
Acosta, Danilo
Ping‐Chang, Su
Tannapfel, Andrea
Reinacher‐Schick, Anke
Uhl, Waldemar
Teschendorf, Christian
Wolters, Heiner
Stern, Josef
Viebahn, Richard
Friess, Helmut
Janssen, Klaus‐Peter
Nitsche, Ulrich
Slotta‐Huspenina, Julia
Pohl, Michael
Vangala, Deepak
Baraniskin, Alexander
Dockhorn‐Dworniczak, Barbara
Hegewisch‐Becker, Susanne
Ronga, Philippe
Edelstein, Daniel L.
Jones, Frederick S.
Hahn, Stephan
Fox, Stephen B.
author_facet Schmiegel, Wolff
Scott, Rodney J.
Dooley, Susan
Lewis, Wendy
Meldrum, Cliff J.
Pockney, Peter
Draganic, Brian
Smith, Steve
Hewitt, Chelsee
Philimore, Hazel
Lucas, Amanda
Shi, Elva
Namdarian, Kateh
Chan, Timmy
Acosta, Danilo
Ping‐Chang, Su
Tannapfel, Andrea
Reinacher‐Schick, Anke
Uhl, Waldemar
Teschendorf, Christian
Wolters, Heiner
Stern, Josef
Viebahn, Richard
Friess, Helmut
Janssen, Klaus‐Peter
Nitsche, Ulrich
Slotta‐Huspenina, Julia
Pohl, Michael
Vangala, Deepak
Baraniskin, Alexander
Dockhorn‐Dworniczak, Barbara
Hegewisch‐Becker, Susanne
Ronga, Philippe
Edelstein, Daniel L.
Jones, Frederick S.
Hahn, Stephan
Fox, Stephen B.
author_sort Schmiegel, Wolff
collection PubMed
description An accurate blood‐based RAS mutation assay to determine eligibility of metastatic colorectal cancer (mCRC) patients for anti‐EGFR therapy would benefit clinical practice by better informing decisions to administer treatment independent of tissue availability. The objective of this study was to determine the level of concordance between plasma and tissue RAS mutation status in patients with mCRC to gauge whether blood‐based RAS mutation testing is a viable alternative to standard‐of‐care RAS tumor testing. RAS testing was performed on plasma samples from newly diagnosed metastatic patients, or from recurrent mCRC patients using the highly sensitive digital PCR technology, BEAMing (beads, emulsions, amplification, and magnetics), and compared with DNA sequencing data of respective FFPE (formalin‐fixed paraffin‐embedded) tumor samples. Discordant tissue RAS results were re‐examined by BEAMing, if possible. The prevalence of RAS mutations detected in plasma (51%) vs. tumor (53%) was similar, in accord with the known prevalence of RAS mutations observed in mCRC patient populations. The positive agreement between plasma and tumor RAS results was 90.4% (47/52), the negative agreement was 93.5% (43/46), and the overall agreement (concordance) was 91.8% (90/98). The high concordance of plasma and tissue results demonstrates that blood‐based RAS mutation testing is a viable alternative to tissue‐based RAS testing.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-5527457
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2017
publisher John Wiley and Sons Inc.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-55274572017-08-15 Blood‐based detection of RAS mutations to guide anti‐EGFR therapy in colorectal cancer patients: concordance of results from circulating tumor DNA and tissue‐based RAS testing Schmiegel, Wolff Scott, Rodney J. Dooley, Susan Lewis, Wendy Meldrum, Cliff J. Pockney, Peter Draganic, Brian Smith, Steve Hewitt, Chelsee Philimore, Hazel Lucas, Amanda Shi, Elva Namdarian, Kateh Chan, Timmy Acosta, Danilo Ping‐Chang, Su Tannapfel, Andrea Reinacher‐Schick, Anke Uhl, Waldemar Teschendorf, Christian Wolters, Heiner Stern, Josef Viebahn, Richard Friess, Helmut Janssen, Klaus‐Peter Nitsche, Ulrich Slotta‐Huspenina, Julia Pohl, Michael Vangala, Deepak Baraniskin, Alexander Dockhorn‐Dworniczak, Barbara Hegewisch‐Becker, Susanne Ronga, Philippe Edelstein, Daniel L. Jones, Frederick S. Hahn, Stephan Fox, Stephen B. Mol Oncol Research Articles An accurate blood‐based RAS mutation assay to determine eligibility of metastatic colorectal cancer (mCRC) patients for anti‐EGFR therapy would benefit clinical practice by better informing decisions to administer treatment independent of tissue availability. The objective of this study was to determine the level of concordance between plasma and tissue RAS mutation status in patients with mCRC to gauge whether blood‐based RAS mutation testing is a viable alternative to standard‐of‐care RAS tumor testing. RAS testing was performed on plasma samples from newly diagnosed metastatic patients, or from recurrent mCRC patients using the highly sensitive digital PCR technology, BEAMing (beads, emulsions, amplification, and magnetics), and compared with DNA sequencing data of respective FFPE (formalin‐fixed paraffin‐embedded) tumor samples. Discordant tissue RAS results were re‐examined by BEAMing, if possible. The prevalence of RAS mutations detected in plasma (51%) vs. tumor (53%) was similar, in accord with the known prevalence of RAS mutations observed in mCRC patient populations. The positive agreement between plasma and tumor RAS results was 90.4% (47/52), the negative agreement was 93.5% (43/46), and the overall agreement (concordance) was 91.8% (90/98). The high concordance of plasma and tissue results demonstrates that blood‐based RAS mutation testing is a viable alternative to tissue‐based RAS testing. John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2017-01-20 2017-02 /pmc/articles/PMC5527457/ /pubmed/28106345 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/1878-0261.12023 Text en © 2016 The Authors. Published by FEBS Press and John Wiley & Sons Ltd. This is an open access article under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
spellingShingle Research Articles
Schmiegel, Wolff
Scott, Rodney J.
Dooley, Susan
Lewis, Wendy
Meldrum, Cliff J.
Pockney, Peter
Draganic, Brian
Smith, Steve
Hewitt, Chelsee
Philimore, Hazel
Lucas, Amanda
Shi, Elva
Namdarian, Kateh
Chan, Timmy
Acosta, Danilo
Ping‐Chang, Su
Tannapfel, Andrea
Reinacher‐Schick, Anke
Uhl, Waldemar
Teschendorf, Christian
Wolters, Heiner
Stern, Josef
Viebahn, Richard
Friess, Helmut
Janssen, Klaus‐Peter
Nitsche, Ulrich
Slotta‐Huspenina, Julia
Pohl, Michael
Vangala, Deepak
Baraniskin, Alexander
Dockhorn‐Dworniczak, Barbara
Hegewisch‐Becker, Susanne
Ronga, Philippe
Edelstein, Daniel L.
Jones, Frederick S.
Hahn, Stephan
Fox, Stephen B.
Blood‐based detection of RAS mutations to guide anti‐EGFR therapy in colorectal cancer patients: concordance of results from circulating tumor DNA and tissue‐based RAS testing
title Blood‐based detection of RAS mutations to guide anti‐EGFR therapy in colorectal cancer patients: concordance of results from circulating tumor DNA and tissue‐based RAS testing
title_full Blood‐based detection of RAS mutations to guide anti‐EGFR therapy in colorectal cancer patients: concordance of results from circulating tumor DNA and tissue‐based RAS testing
title_fullStr Blood‐based detection of RAS mutations to guide anti‐EGFR therapy in colorectal cancer patients: concordance of results from circulating tumor DNA and tissue‐based RAS testing
title_full_unstemmed Blood‐based detection of RAS mutations to guide anti‐EGFR therapy in colorectal cancer patients: concordance of results from circulating tumor DNA and tissue‐based RAS testing
title_short Blood‐based detection of RAS mutations to guide anti‐EGFR therapy in colorectal cancer patients: concordance of results from circulating tumor DNA and tissue‐based RAS testing
title_sort blood‐based detection of ras mutations to guide anti‐egfr therapy in colorectal cancer patients: concordance of results from circulating tumor dna and tissue‐based ras testing
topic Research Articles
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5527457/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/28106345
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/1878-0261.12023
work_keys_str_mv AT schmiegelwolff bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT scottrodneyj bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT dooleysusan bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT lewiswendy bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT meldrumcliffj bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT pockneypeter bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT draganicbrian bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT smithsteve bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT hewittchelsee bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT philimorehazel bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT lucasamanda bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT shielva bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT namdariankateh bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT chantimmy bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT acostadanilo bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT pingchangsu bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT tannapfelandrea bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT reinacherschickanke bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT uhlwaldemar bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT teschendorfchristian bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT woltersheiner bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT sternjosef bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT viebahnrichard bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT friesshelmut bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT janssenklauspeter bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT nitscheulrich bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT slottahuspeninajulia bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT pohlmichael bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT vangaladeepak bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT baraniskinalexander bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT dockhorndworniczakbarbara bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT hegewischbeckersusanne bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT rongaphilippe bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT edelsteindaniell bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT jonesfredericks bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT hahnstephan bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting
AT foxstephenb bloodbaseddetectionofrasmutationstoguideantiegfrtherapyincolorectalcancerpatientsconcordanceofresultsfromcirculatingtumordnaandtissuebasedrastesting