Cargando…

A Novel Host-protein Assay Accurately Distinguishes Bacterial From Viral Upper Respiratory Tract Infections

BACKGROUND: Bacterial and viral infections are often clinically indistinguishable, particularly in upper respiratory tract infections (URTI), which leads to antibiotic misuse. A novel assay (ImmunoXpert™) that integrates measurements of three host-response proteins (TRAIL, IP-10, CRP) was recently d...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Oved, Kfir, Eden, Eran, Van Houten, Chantal, Gottlieb, Tanya, Navon, Roy, Cohen, Asi, Boico, Olga, Paz, Meital, Etshtein, Liat, Kronenfeld, Gali, Friedman, Tom, Bamberger, Ellen, Chistyakov, Irina, Potasman, Israel, Stein, Michal, Klein, Adi, Gervaix, Alain, Srugo, Isaac, Bont, Louis
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Oxford University Press 2017
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5631523/
http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/ofid/ofx163.847
_version_ 1783269494125232128
author Oved, Kfir
Eden, Eran
Van Houten, Chantal
Gottlieb, Tanya
Navon, Roy
Cohen, Asi
Boico, Olga
Paz, Meital
Etshtein, Liat
Kronenfeld, Gali
Friedman, Tom
Bamberger, Ellen
Chistyakov, Irina
Potasman, Israel
Stein, Michal
Klein, Adi
Gervaix, Alain
Srugo, Isaac
Bont, Louis
author_facet Oved, Kfir
Eden, Eran
Van Houten, Chantal
Gottlieb, Tanya
Navon, Roy
Cohen, Asi
Boico, Olga
Paz, Meital
Etshtein, Liat
Kronenfeld, Gali
Friedman, Tom
Bamberger, Ellen
Chistyakov, Irina
Potasman, Israel
Stein, Michal
Klein, Adi
Gervaix, Alain
Srugo, Isaac
Bont, Louis
author_sort Oved, Kfir
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Bacterial and viral infections are often clinically indistinguishable, particularly in upper respiratory tract infections (URTI), which leads to antibiotic misuse. A novel assay (ImmunoXpert™) that integrates measurements of three host-response proteins (TRAIL, IP-10, CRP) was recently developed to assist in differentiation between bacterial and viral etiologies. We evaluated the assay performance in URTI patients and compared it with standard laboratory measures. METHODS: We performed a sub-analysis of 464 patients with clinical suspicion of URTI enrolled in three previously conducted multi-center clinical studies that evaluated the assay performance in patients with acute infections: ‘Curiosity’ study (NCT01917461), ‘Opportunity’ study (NCT01931254), and ‘Pathfinder’ study (NCT01911143). Comparator method was predetermined criteria combined with expert panel adjudication, which was blinded to the test results. Diagnostic performance was evaluated by comparing test and comparator method outcomes. RESULTS: A unanimous panel adjudication was attained for 61 bacterial (13%) and 241 viral (52%) patients (162 patients (35%) had an indeterminate diagnosis). The assay distinguished between bacterial and viral infected patients with a sensitivity of 92% (95% CI: 82%- 98%) and specificity of 93% (88%-96%) with 11% equivocal test results. Overall the assay outperformed other routine laboratory tests (FIG 1), including: white blood cell count (WBC; cutoff 15,000 cells/µL, sensitivity 48% (35%-60%), P < 10(-−6); specificity 85% (80%-90%), P < 0.05); CRP (cutoff 40 mg/L, sensitivity 82% (72%–92%), P = 0.16, specificity 79% (74%–84%), P < 10(-4)); Procalcitonin (PCT; cutoff 0.5 ng/mL, sensitivity 22% (11%–32%), P < 10(–14), specificity 80% (74%–85%), P < 0.001); absolute neutrophil count (ANC; cutoff 10,000 cells/µL, sensitivity 58% (45%–71%), P < 10(-−4), specificity 94% (91%–97%), P = 0.7). CONCLUSION: The novel assay demonstrated superior performance compared with routine laboratory tests (WBC, ANC) and biomarkers (CRP, PCT), in distinguishing bacterial from viral etiologies in patients with URTI. It has the potential to help clinicians avoid missing bacterial infections or prescribing unwarranted antibiotics for viral URTIs. DISCLOSURES: K. Oved, MeMed Diagnostics: Board Member, Employee and Shareholder, Salary E. Eden, MeMed Diagnostics: Board Member, Employee and Shareholder, Salary T. Gottlieb, MeMed Diagnostics: Employee, Salary R. Navon, MeMed Diagnostics: Employee, Salary A. Cohen, MeMed Diagnostics: Employee, Salary O. Boico, MeMed Diagnostics: Employee, Salary M. Paz, MeMed Diagnostics: Employee, Salary L. Etshtein, MeMed Diagnostics: Employee, Salary G. Kronenfeld, MeMed Diagnostics: Employee, Salary T. Friedman, MeMed Diagnostics: Employee, Salary E. Bamberger, MeMed Diagnostics: Employee, Salary I. Chistyakov, MeMed Diagnostics: Consultant, Consulting fee I. Potasman, MeMed Diagnostics: Holding stock options, stock options
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-5631523
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2017
publisher Oxford University Press
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-56315232017-11-07 A Novel Host-protein Assay Accurately Distinguishes Bacterial From Viral Upper Respiratory Tract Infections Oved, Kfir Eden, Eran Van Houten, Chantal Gottlieb, Tanya Navon, Roy Cohen, Asi Boico, Olga Paz, Meital Etshtein, Liat Kronenfeld, Gali Friedman, Tom Bamberger, Ellen Chistyakov, Irina Potasman, Israel Stein, Michal Klein, Adi Gervaix, Alain Srugo, Isaac Bont, Louis Open Forum Infect Dis Abstracts BACKGROUND: Bacterial and viral infections are often clinically indistinguishable, particularly in upper respiratory tract infections (URTI), which leads to antibiotic misuse. A novel assay (ImmunoXpert™) that integrates measurements of three host-response proteins (TRAIL, IP-10, CRP) was recently developed to assist in differentiation between bacterial and viral etiologies. We evaluated the assay performance in URTI patients and compared it with standard laboratory measures. METHODS: We performed a sub-analysis of 464 patients with clinical suspicion of URTI enrolled in three previously conducted multi-center clinical studies that evaluated the assay performance in patients with acute infections: ‘Curiosity’ study (NCT01917461), ‘Opportunity’ study (NCT01931254), and ‘Pathfinder’ study (NCT01911143). Comparator method was predetermined criteria combined with expert panel adjudication, which was blinded to the test results. Diagnostic performance was evaluated by comparing test and comparator method outcomes. RESULTS: A unanimous panel adjudication was attained for 61 bacterial (13%) and 241 viral (52%) patients (162 patients (35%) had an indeterminate diagnosis). The assay distinguished between bacterial and viral infected patients with a sensitivity of 92% (95% CI: 82%- 98%) and specificity of 93% (88%-96%) with 11% equivocal test results. Overall the assay outperformed other routine laboratory tests (FIG 1), including: white blood cell count (WBC; cutoff 15,000 cells/µL, sensitivity 48% (35%-60%), P < 10(-−6); specificity 85% (80%-90%), P < 0.05); CRP (cutoff 40 mg/L, sensitivity 82% (72%–92%), P = 0.16, specificity 79% (74%–84%), P < 10(-4)); Procalcitonin (PCT; cutoff 0.5 ng/mL, sensitivity 22% (11%–32%), P < 10(–14), specificity 80% (74%–85%), P < 0.001); absolute neutrophil count (ANC; cutoff 10,000 cells/µL, sensitivity 58% (45%–71%), P < 10(-−4), specificity 94% (91%–97%), P = 0.7). CONCLUSION: The novel assay demonstrated superior performance compared with routine laboratory tests (WBC, ANC) and biomarkers (CRP, PCT), in distinguishing bacterial from viral etiologies in patients with URTI. It has the potential to help clinicians avoid missing bacterial infections or prescribing unwarranted antibiotics for viral URTIs. DISCLOSURES: K. Oved, MeMed Diagnostics: Board Member, Employee and Shareholder, Salary E. Eden, MeMed Diagnostics: Board Member, Employee and Shareholder, Salary T. Gottlieb, MeMed Diagnostics: Employee, Salary R. Navon, MeMed Diagnostics: Employee, Salary A. Cohen, MeMed Diagnostics: Employee, Salary O. Boico, MeMed Diagnostics: Employee, Salary M. Paz, MeMed Diagnostics: Employee, Salary L. Etshtein, MeMed Diagnostics: Employee, Salary G. Kronenfeld, MeMed Diagnostics: Employee, Salary T. Friedman, MeMed Diagnostics: Employee, Salary E. Bamberger, MeMed Diagnostics: Employee, Salary I. Chistyakov, MeMed Diagnostics: Consultant, Consulting fee I. Potasman, MeMed Diagnostics: Holding stock options, stock options Oxford University Press 2017-10-04 /pmc/articles/PMC5631523/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/ofid/ofx163.847 Text en © The Author 2017. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Infectious Diseases Society of America. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0 This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/), which permits non-commercial reproduction and distribution of the work, in any medium, provided the original work is not altered or transformed in any way, and that the work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact journals.permissions@oup.com
spellingShingle Abstracts
Oved, Kfir
Eden, Eran
Van Houten, Chantal
Gottlieb, Tanya
Navon, Roy
Cohen, Asi
Boico, Olga
Paz, Meital
Etshtein, Liat
Kronenfeld, Gali
Friedman, Tom
Bamberger, Ellen
Chistyakov, Irina
Potasman, Israel
Stein, Michal
Klein, Adi
Gervaix, Alain
Srugo, Isaac
Bont, Louis
A Novel Host-protein Assay Accurately Distinguishes Bacterial From Viral Upper Respiratory Tract Infections
title A Novel Host-protein Assay Accurately Distinguishes Bacterial From Viral Upper Respiratory Tract Infections
title_full A Novel Host-protein Assay Accurately Distinguishes Bacterial From Viral Upper Respiratory Tract Infections
title_fullStr A Novel Host-protein Assay Accurately Distinguishes Bacterial From Viral Upper Respiratory Tract Infections
title_full_unstemmed A Novel Host-protein Assay Accurately Distinguishes Bacterial From Viral Upper Respiratory Tract Infections
title_short A Novel Host-protein Assay Accurately Distinguishes Bacterial From Viral Upper Respiratory Tract Infections
title_sort a novel host-protein assay accurately distinguishes bacterial from viral upper respiratory tract infections
topic Abstracts
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5631523/
http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/ofid/ofx163.847
work_keys_str_mv AT ovedkfir anovelhostproteinassayaccuratelydistinguishesbacterialfromviralupperrespiratorytractinfections
AT edeneran anovelhostproteinassayaccuratelydistinguishesbacterialfromviralupperrespiratorytractinfections
AT vanhoutenchantal anovelhostproteinassayaccuratelydistinguishesbacterialfromviralupperrespiratorytractinfections
AT gottliebtanya anovelhostproteinassayaccuratelydistinguishesbacterialfromviralupperrespiratorytractinfections
AT navonroy anovelhostproteinassayaccuratelydistinguishesbacterialfromviralupperrespiratorytractinfections
AT cohenasi anovelhostproteinassayaccuratelydistinguishesbacterialfromviralupperrespiratorytractinfections
AT boicoolga anovelhostproteinassayaccuratelydistinguishesbacterialfromviralupperrespiratorytractinfections
AT pazmeital anovelhostproteinassayaccuratelydistinguishesbacterialfromviralupperrespiratorytractinfections
AT etshteinliat anovelhostproteinassayaccuratelydistinguishesbacterialfromviralupperrespiratorytractinfections
AT kronenfeldgali anovelhostproteinassayaccuratelydistinguishesbacterialfromviralupperrespiratorytractinfections
AT friedmantom anovelhostproteinassayaccuratelydistinguishesbacterialfromviralupperrespiratorytractinfections
AT bambergerellen anovelhostproteinassayaccuratelydistinguishesbacterialfromviralupperrespiratorytractinfections
AT chistyakovirina anovelhostproteinassayaccuratelydistinguishesbacterialfromviralupperrespiratorytractinfections
AT potasmanisrael anovelhostproteinassayaccuratelydistinguishesbacterialfromviralupperrespiratorytractinfections
AT steinmichal anovelhostproteinassayaccuratelydistinguishesbacterialfromviralupperrespiratorytractinfections
AT kleinadi anovelhostproteinassayaccuratelydistinguishesbacterialfromviralupperrespiratorytractinfections
AT gervaixalain anovelhostproteinassayaccuratelydistinguishesbacterialfromviralupperrespiratorytractinfections
AT srugoisaac anovelhostproteinassayaccuratelydistinguishesbacterialfromviralupperrespiratorytractinfections
AT bontlouis anovelhostproteinassayaccuratelydistinguishesbacterialfromviralupperrespiratorytractinfections