Phenotypic Innovation and Adaptive Constraints in the Evolutionary Radiation of Palaeozoic Crinoids

To better understand the patterns and processes shaping large-scale phenotypic diversification, I integrate palaeobiological and phylogenetic perspectives to investigate a ~200-million-year radiation using a global sample of Palaeozoic crinoid echinoderms. Results indicate the early history of crinoid diversification is characterized by early burst dynamics with decelerating morphologic rates. However, in contrast with expectation for a single “early burst” model, morphospace continued to expand following a slowdown in rates. In addition, I find evidence for an isolated peak in morphologic rates occurring late in the clade’s history. This episode of elevated rates is not associated with increased disparity, morphologic novelty, or the radiation of a single subclade. Instead, this episode of elevated rates involved multiple subclade radiations driven by environmental change toward a pre-existing adaptive optimum. The decoupling of morphologic disparity with rates of change suggests phenotypic rates are primarily shaped by ecologic factors rather than the origination of morphologic novelty alone. These results suggest phenotypic diversification is far more complex than models commonly assumed in comparative biology. Furthermore, palaeontological disparity patterns are not a reliable proxy for rates after an initial diversifying phase. These issues highlight the need for continued synthesis between fossil and phylogenetic approaches to macroevolution.