Cargando…

Very Late Pathological Responses to Cobalt–Chromium Everolimus‐Eluting, Stainless Steel Sirolimus‐Eluting, and Cobalt–Chromium Bare Metal Stents in Humans

BACKGROUND: The “very late” clinical outcomes for durable polymer drug‐eluting stents and bare metal stents (BMSs) have been shown to be dissimilar in clinical studies. Conceptually, the long‐term vascular compatibility of BMSs is still regarded to be superior to drug‐eluting stents; however, no pat...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Mori, Hiroyoshi, Atmakuri, Dheeraj R., Torii, Sho, Braumann, Ryan, Smith, Samantha, Jinnouchi, Hiroyuki, Gupta, Anuj, Harari, Emanuel, Shkullaku, Melsi, Kutys, Robert, Fowler, David, Romero, Maria, Virmani, Renu, Finn, Aloke V.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2017
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5721792/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29150493
http://dx.doi.org/10.1161/JAHA.117.007244
_version_ 1783284882738249728
author Mori, Hiroyoshi
Atmakuri, Dheeraj R.
Torii, Sho
Braumann, Ryan
Smith, Samantha
Jinnouchi, Hiroyuki
Gupta, Anuj
Harari, Emanuel
Shkullaku, Melsi
Kutys, Robert
Fowler, David
Romero, Maria
Virmani, Renu
Finn, Aloke V.
author_facet Mori, Hiroyoshi
Atmakuri, Dheeraj R.
Torii, Sho
Braumann, Ryan
Smith, Samantha
Jinnouchi, Hiroyuki
Gupta, Anuj
Harari, Emanuel
Shkullaku, Melsi
Kutys, Robert
Fowler, David
Romero, Maria
Virmani, Renu
Finn, Aloke V.
author_sort Mori, Hiroyoshi
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: The “very late” clinical outcomes for durable polymer drug‐eluting stents and bare metal stents (BMSs) have been shown to be dissimilar in clinical studies. Conceptually, the long‐term vascular compatibility of BMSs is still regarded to be superior to drug‐eluting stents; however, no pathologic study to date has specifically addressed this issue. We evaluated the very late (≥1 year) pathologic responses to durable polymer drug‐eluting stents (cobalt–chromium [CoCr] everolimus‐eluting stents [EESs] and stainless steel sirolimus‐eluting stents [SS‐SESs]) versus BMSs (CoCr‐BMSs). METHODS AND RESULTS: From the CVPath stent registry, we studied a total of 119 lesions (40 CoCr‐EESs, 44 SS‐SESs, 35 CoCr‐BMSs) from 92 autopsy cases with a duration ranging from 1 to 5 years. Sections of stented coronary segments were pathologically analyzed. Inflammation score and the percentage of struts with giant cells were lowest in CoCr‐EESs (median inflammation score: 0.6; median percentage of struts with giant cells: 3.8%) followed by CoCr‐BMSs (median inflammation score: 1.3 [P<0.01]; median percentage of struts with giant cells: 8.9% [P=0.02]) and SS‐SESs (median inflammation score: 1.7 [P<0.01]; median percentage of struts with giant cells: 15.3% [P<0.01]). Polymer delamination was observed exclusively in SS‐SESs and was associated with increased inflammatory and giant cell reactions. The prevalence of neoatherosclerosis with CoCr‐EESs (50%) was significantly less than with SS‐SESs (77%, P=0.02) but significantly greater than with CoCr‐BMSs (20%, P<0.01). CONCLUSIONS: CoCr‐EESs, SS‐SESs, and BMSs each demonstrated distinct vascular responses. CoCr‐EESs demonstrated the least inflammation, near‐equivalent healing to BMSs, and lower neointimal formation. These results challenge the belief that BMSs have superior biocompatibility compared with some polymeric coated drug‐eluting stents and may have implications for future stent design.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-5721792
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2017
publisher John Wiley and Sons Inc.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-57217922017-12-12 Very Late Pathological Responses to Cobalt–Chromium Everolimus‐Eluting, Stainless Steel Sirolimus‐Eluting, and Cobalt–Chromium Bare Metal Stents in Humans Mori, Hiroyoshi Atmakuri, Dheeraj R. Torii, Sho Braumann, Ryan Smith, Samantha Jinnouchi, Hiroyuki Gupta, Anuj Harari, Emanuel Shkullaku, Melsi Kutys, Robert Fowler, David Romero, Maria Virmani, Renu Finn, Aloke V. J Am Heart Assoc Original Research BACKGROUND: The “very late” clinical outcomes for durable polymer drug‐eluting stents and bare metal stents (BMSs) have been shown to be dissimilar in clinical studies. Conceptually, the long‐term vascular compatibility of BMSs is still regarded to be superior to drug‐eluting stents; however, no pathologic study to date has specifically addressed this issue. We evaluated the very late (≥1 year) pathologic responses to durable polymer drug‐eluting stents (cobalt–chromium [CoCr] everolimus‐eluting stents [EESs] and stainless steel sirolimus‐eluting stents [SS‐SESs]) versus BMSs (CoCr‐BMSs). METHODS AND RESULTS: From the CVPath stent registry, we studied a total of 119 lesions (40 CoCr‐EESs, 44 SS‐SESs, 35 CoCr‐BMSs) from 92 autopsy cases with a duration ranging from 1 to 5 years. Sections of stented coronary segments were pathologically analyzed. Inflammation score and the percentage of struts with giant cells were lowest in CoCr‐EESs (median inflammation score: 0.6; median percentage of struts with giant cells: 3.8%) followed by CoCr‐BMSs (median inflammation score: 1.3 [P<0.01]; median percentage of struts with giant cells: 8.9% [P=0.02]) and SS‐SESs (median inflammation score: 1.7 [P<0.01]; median percentage of struts with giant cells: 15.3% [P<0.01]). Polymer delamination was observed exclusively in SS‐SESs and was associated with increased inflammatory and giant cell reactions. The prevalence of neoatherosclerosis with CoCr‐EESs (50%) was significantly less than with SS‐SESs (77%, P=0.02) but significantly greater than with CoCr‐BMSs (20%, P<0.01). CONCLUSIONS: CoCr‐EESs, SS‐SESs, and BMSs each demonstrated distinct vascular responses. CoCr‐EESs demonstrated the least inflammation, near‐equivalent healing to BMSs, and lower neointimal formation. These results challenge the belief that BMSs have superior biocompatibility compared with some polymeric coated drug‐eluting stents and may have implications for future stent design. John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2017-11-17 /pmc/articles/PMC5721792/ /pubmed/29150493 http://dx.doi.org/10.1161/JAHA.117.007244 Text en © 2017 The Authors. Published on behalf of the American Heart Association, Inc., by Wiley. This is an open access article under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution‐NonCommercial (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited and is not used for commercial purposes.
spellingShingle Original Research
Mori, Hiroyoshi
Atmakuri, Dheeraj R.
Torii, Sho
Braumann, Ryan
Smith, Samantha
Jinnouchi, Hiroyuki
Gupta, Anuj
Harari, Emanuel
Shkullaku, Melsi
Kutys, Robert
Fowler, David
Romero, Maria
Virmani, Renu
Finn, Aloke V.
Very Late Pathological Responses to Cobalt–Chromium Everolimus‐Eluting, Stainless Steel Sirolimus‐Eluting, and Cobalt–Chromium Bare Metal Stents in Humans
title Very Late Pathological Responses to Cobalt–Chromium Everolimus‐Eluting, Stainless Steel Sirolimus‐Eluting, and Cobalt–Chromium Bare Metal Stents in Humans
title_full Very Late Pathological Responses to Cobalt–Chromium Everolimus‐Eluting, Stainless Steel Sirolimus‐Eluting, and Cobalt–Chromium Bare Metal Stents in Humans
title_fullStr Very Late Pathological Responses to Cobalt–Chromium Everolimus‐Eluting, Stainless Steel Sirolimus‐Eluting, and Cobalt–Chromium Bare Metal Stents in Humans
title_full_unstemmed Very Late Pathological Responses to Cobalt–Chromium Everolimus‐Eluting, Stainless Steel Sirolimus‐Eluting, and Cobalt–Chromium Bare Metal Stents in Humans
title_short Very Late Pathological Responses to Cobalt–Chromium Everolimus‐Eluting, Stainless Steel Sirolimus‐Eluting, and Cobalt–Chromium Bare Metal Stents in Humans
title_sort very late pathological responses to cobalt–chromium everolimus‐eluting, stainless steel sirolimus‐eluting, and cobalt–chromium bare metal stents in humans
topic Original Research
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5721792/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29150493
http://dx.doi.org/10.1161/JAHA.117.007244
work_keys_str_mv AT morihiroyoshi verylatepathologicalresponsestocobaltchromiumeverolimuselutingstainlesssteelsirolimuselutingandcobaltchromiumbaremetalstentsinhumans
AT atmakuridheerajr verylatepathologicalresponsestocobaltchromiumeverolimuselutingstainlesssteelsirolimuselutingandcobaltchromiumbaremetalstentsinhumans
AT toriisho verylatepathologicalresponsestocobaltchromiumeverolimuselutingstainlesssteelsirolimuselutingandcobaltchromiumbaremetalstentsinhumans
AT braumannryan verylatepathologicalresponsestocobaltchromiumeverolimuselutingstainlesssteelsirolimuselutingandcobaltchromiumbaremetalstentsinhumans
AT smithsamantha verylatepathologicalresponsestocobaltchromiumeverolimuselutingstainlesssteelsirolimuselutingandcobaltchromiumbaremetalstentsinhumans
AT jinnouchihiroyuki verylatepathologicalresponsestocobaltchromiumeverolimuselutingstainlesssteelsirolimuselutingandcobaltchromiumbaremetalstentsinhumans
AT guptaanuj verylatepathologicalresponsestocobaltchromiumeverolimuselutingstainlesssteelsirolimuselutingandcobaltchromiumbaremetalstentsinhumans
AT harariemanuel verylatepathologicalresponsestocobaltchromiumeverolimuselutingstainlesssteelsirolimuselutingandcobaltchromiumbaremetalstentsinhumans
AT shkullakumelsi verylatepathologicalresponsestocobaltchromiumeverolimuselutingstainlesssteelsirolimuselutingandcobaltchromiumbaremetalstentsinhumans
AT kutysrobert verylatepathologicalresponsestocobaltchromiumeverolimuselutingstainlesssteelsirolimuselutingandcobaltchromiumbaremetalstentsinhumans
AT fowlerdavid verylatepathologicalresponsestocobaltchromiumeverolimuselutingstainlesssteelsirolimuselutingandcobaltchromiumbaremetalstentsinhumans
AT romeromaria verylatepathologicalresponsestocobaltchromiumeverolimuselutingstainlesssteelsirolimuselutingandcobaltchromiumbaremetalstentsinhumans
AT virmanirenu verylatepathologicalresponsestocobaltchromiumeverolimuselutingstainlesssteelsirolimuselutingandcobaltchromiumbaremetalstentsinhumans
AT finnalokev verylatepathologicalresponsestocobaltchromiumeverolimuselutingstainlesssteelsirolimuselutingandcobaltchromiumbaremetalstentsinhumans