Cargando…

An interspecies comparative study of invasive electrophysiological functional connectivity

INTRODUCTION: Resting‐state connectivity patterns have been observed in humans and other mammal species, and can be recorded using a variety of different technologies. Functional connectivity has been previously compared between species using resting‐state fMRI, but not in electrophysiological studi...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Casimo, Kaitlyn, Levinson, Lila H., Zanos, Stavros, Gkogkidis, C. Alexis, Ball, Tonio, Fetz, Eberhard, Weaver, Kurt E., Ojemann, Jeffrey G.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2017
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5745242/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29299382
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/brb3.863
_version_ 1783288882391941120
author Casimo, Kaitlyn
Levinson, Lila H.
Zanos, Stavros
Gkogkidis, C. Alexis
Ball, Tonio
Fetz, Eberhard
Weaver, Kurt E.
Ojemann, Jeffrey G.
author_facet Casimo, Kaitlyn
Levinson, Lila H.
Zanos, Stavros
Gkogkidis, C. Alexis
Ball, Tonio
Fetz, Eberhard
Weaver, Kurt E.
Ojemann, Jeffrey G.
author_sort Casimo, Kaitlyn
collection PubMed
description INTRODUCTION: Resting‐state connectivity patterns have been observed in humans and other mammal species, and can be recorded using a variety of different technologies. Functional connectivity has been previously compared between species using resting‐state fMRI, but not in electrophysiological studies. METHODS: We compared connectivity with implanted electrodes in humans (electrocorticography) to macaques and sheep (microelectrocorticography), which are capable of recording neural data at high frequencies with spatial precision. We specifically examined synchrony, implicated in functional integration between regions. RESULTS: We found that connectivity strength was overwhelmingly similar in humans and monkeys for pairs of two different brain regions (prefrontal, motor, premotor, parietal), but differed more often within single brain regions. The two connectivity measures, correlation and phase locking value, were similar in most comparisons. Connectivity strength agreed more often between the species at higher frequencies. Where the species differed, monkey synchrony was stronger than human in all but one case. In contrast, human and sheep connectivity within somatosensory cortex diverged in almost all frequencies, with human connectivity stronger than sheep. DISCUSSION: Our findings imply greater heterogeneity within regions in humans than in monkeys, but comparable functional interactions between regions in the two species. This suggests that monkeys may be effectively used to probe resting‐state connectivity in humans, and that such findings can then be validated in humans. Although the discrepancy between humans and sheep is larger, we suggest that findings from sheep in highly invasive studies may be used to provide guidance for studies in other species.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-5745242
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2017
publisher John Wiley and Sons Inc.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-57452422018-01-03 An interspecies comparative study of invasive electrophysiological functional connectivity Casimo, Kaitlyn Levinson, Lila H. Zanos, Stavros Gkogkidis, C. Alexis Ball, Tonio Fetz, Eberhard Weaver, Kurt E. Ojemann, Jeffrey G. Brain Behav Original Research INTRODUCTION: Resting‐state connectivity patterns have been observed in humans and other mammal species, and can be recorded using a variety of different technologies. Functional connectivity has been previously compared between species using resting‐state fMRI, but not in electrophysiological studies. METHODS: We compared connectivity with implanted electrodes in humans (electrocorticography) to macaques and sheep (microelectrocorticography), which are capable of recording neural data at high frequencies with spatial precision. We specifically examined synchrony, implicated in functional integration between regions. RESULTS: We found that connectivity strength was overwhelmingly similar in humans and monkeys for pairs of two different brain regions (prefrontal, motor, premotor, parietal), but differed more often within single brain regions. The two connectivity measures, correlation and phase locking value, were similar in most comparisons. Connectivity strength agreed more often between the species at higher frequencies. Where the species differed, monkey synchrony was stronger than human in all but one case. In contrast, human and sheep connectivity within somatosensory cortex diverged in almost all frequencies, with human connectivity stronger than sheep. DISCUSSION: Our findings imply greater heterogeneity within regions in humans than in monkeys, but comparable functional interactions between regions in the two species. This suggests that monkeys may be effectively used to probe resting‐state connectivity in humans, and that such findings can then be validated in humans. Although the discrepancy between humans and sheep is larger, we suggest that findings from sheep in highly invasive studies may be used to provide guidance for studies in other species. John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2017-11-22 /pmc/articles/PMC5745242/ /pubmed/29299382 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/brb3.863 Text en © 2017 The Authors. Brain and Behavior published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc. This is an open access article under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
spellingShingle Original Research
Casimo, Kaitlyn
Levinson, Lila H.
Zanos, Stavros
Gkogkidis, C. Alexis
Ball, Tonio
Fetz, Eberhard
Weaver, Kurt E.
Ojemann, Jeffrey G.
An interspecies comparative study of invasive electrophysiological functional connectivity
title An interspecies comparative study of invasive electrophysiological functional connectivity
title_full An interspecies comparative study of invasive electrophysiological functional connectivity
title_fullStr An interspecies comparative study of invasive electrophysiological functional connectivity
title_full_unstemmed An interspecies comparative study of invasive electrophysiological functional connectivity
title_short An interspecies comparative study of invasive electrophysiological functional connectivity
title_sort interspecies comparative study of invasive electrophysiological functional connectivity
topic Original Research
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5745242/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29299382
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/brb3.863
work_keys_str_mv AT casimokaitlyn aninterspeciescomparativestudyofinvasiveelectrophysiologicalfunctionalconnectivity
AT levinsonlilah aninterspeciescomparativestudyofinvasiveelectrophysiologicalfunctionalconnectivity
AT zanosstavros aninterspeciescomparativestudyofinvasiveelectrophysiologicalfunctionalconnectivity
AT gkogkidiscalexis aninterspeciescomparativestudyofinvasiveelectrophysiologicalfunctionalconnectivity
AT balltonio aninterspeciescomparativestudyofinvasiveelectrophysiologicalfunctionalconnectivity
AT fetzeberhard aninterspeciescomparativestudyofinvasiveelectrophysiologicalfunctionalconnectivity
AT weaverkurte aninterspeciescomparativestudyofinvasiveelectrophysiologicalfunctionalconnectivity
AT ojemannjeffreyg aninterspeciescomparativestudyofinvasiveelectrophysiologicalfunctionalconnectivity
AT casimokaitlyn interspeciescomparativestudyofinvasiveelectrophysiologicalfunctionalconnectivity
AT levinsonlilah interspeciescomparativestudyofinvasiveelectrophysiologicalfunctionalconnectivity
AT zanosstavros interspeciescomparativestudyofinvasiveelectrophysiologicalfunctionalconnectivity
AT gkogkidiscalexis interspeciescomparativestudyofinvasiveelectrophysiologicalfunctionalconnectivity
AT balltonio interspeciescomparativestudyofinvasiveelectrophysiologicalfunctionalconnectivity
AT fetzeberhard interspeciescomparativestudyofinvasiveelectrophysiologicalfunctionalconnectivity
AT weaverkurte interspeciescomparativestudyofinvasiveelectrophysiologicalfunctionalconnectivity
AT ojemannjeffreyg interspeciescomparativestudyofinvasiveelectrophysiologicalfunctionalconnectivity