Enumerating viable phytoplankton using a culture-based Most Probable Number assay following ultraviolet-C treatment

Ballast water management systems (BWMS) must be tested to assess their compliance with standards for the discharge of organisms, for example in the ≥ 10- and < 50-μm size category, which is dominated by phytoplankton. Assessment of BWMS performance with the vital stains fluorescein diacetate + 5-chlorofluorescein diacetate, required by regulations in the USA, is problematic in the case of ultraviolet-C (UVC) radiation. This is because UVC targets nucleotides—and thus reproduction, hence viability—rather than membrane integrity, which is assayed by the stains. The Serial Dilution Culture-Most Probable Number (SDC-MPN) method, long used to enumerate fragile phytoplankton from natural communities, is appropriate for counting viable phytoplankton. We developed QA/QC “best practice” criteria for its application as a robust and repeatable assay of viable cells in cultures of phytoplankton before and after experimental treatment, then constructed dose-response curves for UVC-induced loss of viable cells in 12 species of phytoplankton from seven divisions. Sensitivity to UVC, expressed as the dose required to reduce viability by 99%—the criterion for type approval of treatment systems—varied more than 10-fold and was not correlated with cell size. The form of the dose-response curves varied between taxa, with most having a threshold dose below which there was no reduction in viability. Analysis of the patterns of growth indicates that if recovery from treatment occurred, it was complete in 1 or 2 days in > 80% of cases, long before the assays were terminated. We conclude that the SDC-MPN assay as described is robust and adaptable for use on natural phytoplankton.