Cargando…

The Diagnostic Value of MRI Pattern Recognition in Distal Myopathies

Objective: Distal myopathies are a diagnostically challenging group of diseases. We wanted to understand the value of MRI in the current clinical setting and explore the potential for optimizing its clinical application. Methods: We retrospectively audited the diagnostic workup in a distal myopathy...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Bugiardini, Enrico, Morrow, Jasper M., Shah, Sachit, Wood, Claire L., Lynch, David S., Pitmann, Alan M., Reilly, Mary M., Houlden, Henry, Matthews, Emma, Parton, Matt, Hanna, Michael G., Straub, Volker, Yousry, Tarek A.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Frontiers Media S.A. 2018
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6028608/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29997562
http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fneur.2018.00456
_version_ 1783336801028538368
author Bugiardini, Enrico
Morrow, Jasper M.
Shah, Sachit
Wood, Claire L.
Lynch, David S.
Pitmann, Alan M.
Reilly, Mary M.
Houlden, Henry
Matthews, Emma
Parton, Matt
Hanna, Michael G.
Straub, Volker
Yousry, Tarek A.
author_facet Bugiardini, Enrico
Morrow, Jasper M.
Shah, Sachit
Wood, Claire L.
Lynch, David S.
Pitmann, Alan M.
Reilly, Mary M.
Houlden, Henry
Matthews, Emma
Parton, Matt
Hanna, Michael G.
Straub, Volker
Yousry, Tarek A.
author_sort Bugiardini, Enrico
collection PubMed
description Objective: Distal myopathies are a diagnostically challenging group of diseases. We wanted to understand the value of MRI in the current clinical setting and explore the potential for optimizing its clinical application. Methods: We retrospectively audited the diagnostic workup in a distal myopathy patient cohort, reassessing the diagnosis, whilst documenting the usage of MRI. We established a literature based distal myopathies MRI pattern template and assessed its diagnostic utility in terms of sensitivity, specificity, and potential impact on the diagnostic workup. Results: Fifty-five patients were included; in 38 with a comprehensive set of data the diagnostic work-up was audited. The median time from symptoms onset to diagnosis was 12.1 years. The initial genetic diagnostic rate was 39%; 18% were misdiagnosed as neuropathies and 13% as inclusion body myositis (IBM). Based on 21 publications we established a MRI pattern template. Its overall sensitivity (50%) and specificity (32%) were low. However in some diseases (e.g., MYOT-related myopathy, TTN-HMERF) MRI correctly identified the causative gene. The number of genes suggested by MRI pattern analysis was smaller compared to clinical work up (median 1 vs. 9, p < 0.0001) but fewer genes were correctly predicted (5/10 vs. 7/10). MRI analysis ruled out IBM in all cases. Conclusion: In the diagnostic work-up of distal myopathies, MRI is useful in assisting genetic testing and avoiding misdiagnosis (IBM). The overall low sensitivity and specificity limits its generalized use when traditional single gene test methods are applied. However, in the context of next generation sequencing MRI may represent a valuable tool for interpreting complex genetic results.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-6028608
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2018
publisher Frontiers Media S.A.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-60286082018-07-11 The Diagnostic Value of MRI Pattern Recognition in Distal Myopathies Bugiardini, Enrico Morrow, Jasper M. Shah, Sachit Wood, Claire L. Lynch, David S. Pitmann, Alan M. Reilly, Mary M. Houlden, Henry Matthews, Emma Parton, Matt Hanna, Michael G. Straub, Volker Yousry, Tarek A. Front Neurol Neurology Objective: Distal myopathies are a diagnostically challenging group of diseases. We wanted to understand the value of MRI in the current clinical setting and explore the potential for optimizing its clinical application. Methods: We retrospectively audited the diagnostic workup in a distal myopathy patient cohort, reassessing the diagnosis, whilst documenting the usage of MRI. We established a literature based distal myopathies MRI pattern template and assessed its diagnostic utility in terms of sensitivity, specificity, and potential impact on the diagnostic workup. Results: Fifty-five patients were included; in 38 with a comprehensive set of data the diagnostic work-up was audited. The median time from symptoms onset to diagnosis was 12.1 years. The initial genetic diagnostic rate was 39%; 18% were misdiagnosed as neuropathies and 13% as inclusion body myositis (IBM). Based on 21 publications we established a MRI pattern template. Its overall sensitivity (50%) and specificity (32%) were low. However in some diseases (e.g., MYOT-related myopathy, TTN-HMERF) MRI correctly identified the causative gene. The number of genes suggested by MRI pattern analysis was smaller compared to clinical work up (median 1 vs. 9, p < 0.0001) but fewer genes were correctly predicted (5/10 vs. 7/10). MRI analysis ruled out IBM in all cases. Conclusion: In the diagnostic work-up of distal myopathies, MRI is useful in assisting genetic testing and avoiding misdiagnosis (IBM). The overall low sensitivity and specificity limits its generalized use when traditional single gene test methods are applied. However, in the context of next generation sequencing MRI may represent a valuable tool for interpreting complex genetic results. Frontiers Media S.A. 2018-06-26 /pmc/articles/PMC6028608/ /pubmed/29997562 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fneur.2018.00456 Text en Copyright © 2018 Bugiardini, Morrow, Shah, Wood, Lynch, Pitmann, Reilly, Houlden, Matthews, Parton, Hanna, Straub and Yousry. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
spellingShingle Neurology
Bugiardini, Enrico
Morrow, Jasper M.
Shah, Sachit
Wood, Claire L.
Lynch, David S.
Pitmann, Alan M.
Reilly, Mary M.
Houlden, Henry
Matthews, Emma
Parton, Matt
Hanna, Michael G.
Straub, Volker
Yousry, Tarek A.
The Diagnostic Value of MRI Pattern Recognition in Distal Myopathies
title The Diagnostic Value of MRI Pattern Recognition in Distal Myopathies
title_full The Diagnostic Value of MRI Pattern Recognition in Distal Myopathies
title_fullStr The Diagnostic Value of MRI Pattern Recognition in Distal Myopathies
title_full_unstemmed The Diagnostic Value of MRI Pattern Recognition in Distal Myopathies
title_short The Diagnostic Value of MRI Pattern Recognition in Distal Myopathies
title_sort diagnostic value of mri pattern recognition in distal myopathies
topic Neurology
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6028608/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29997562
http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fneur.2018.00456
work_keys_str_mv AT bugiardinienrico thediagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT morrowjasperm thediagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT shahsachit thediagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT woodclairel thediagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT lynchdavids thediagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT pitmannalanm thediagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT reillymarym thediagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT houldenhenry thediagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT matthewsemma thediagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT partonmatt thediagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT hannamichaelg thediagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT straubvolker thediagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT yousrytareka thediagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT bugiardinienrico diagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT morrowjasperm diagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT shahsachit diagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT woodclairel diagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT lynchdavids diagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT pitmannalanm diagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT reillymarym diagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT houldenhenry diagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT matthewsemma diagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT partonmatt diagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT hannamichaelg diagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT straubvolker diagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies
AT yousrytareka diagnosticvalueofmripatternrecognitionindistalmyopathies