Cargando…

A multi-technique analytical approach to sourcing Scandinavian flint: Provenance of ballast flint from the shipwreck “Leirvigen 1”, Norway

Although Scandinavian flint is one of the most important materials used for prehistoric stone tool production in Northern and Central Europe, a conclusive method for securely differentiating between flint sources, geologically bound to northern European chalk formations, has never been achieved. The...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Brandl, Michael, Martinez, Maria M., Hauzenberger, Christoph, Filzmoser, Peter, Nymoen, Pål, Mehler, Natascha
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Public Library of Science 2018
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6082525/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/30089119
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0200647
_version_ 1783345815172939776
author Brandl, Michael
Martinez, Maria M.
Hauzenberger, Christoph
Filzmoser, Peter
Nymoen, Pål
Mehler, Natascha
author_facet Brandl, Michael
Martinez, Maria M.
Hauzenberger, Christoph
Filzmoser, Peter
Nymoen, Pål
Mehler, Natascha
author_sort Brandl, Michael
collection PubMed
description Although Scandinavian flint is one of the most important materials used for prehistoric stone tool production in Northern and Central Europe, a conclusive method for securely differentiating between flint sources, geologically bound to northern European chalk formations, has never been achieved. The main problems with traditional approaches concern the oftentimes high similarities of SiO(2) raw materials (i.e. chert and flint) on different scales due to similar genetic conditions and higher intra- than inter-source variation. Conventional chert and flint provenance studies chiefly concentrate on visual, petrographic or geochemical investigations. Hence, attempts to generate characteristic fingerprints of particular chert raw materials were in most cases unsatisfying. Here we show that the Multi Layered Chert Sourcing Approach (MLA) achieves a clear differentiation between primary sources of Scandinavian flint. The MLA combines visual comparative studies, stereo-microscopic analyses of microfossil inclusions, geochemical trace element analyses applying LA-ICP-MS (Laser Ablation Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry) and statistical analyses through CODA (Compositional Data Analysis). For archaeologists, provenance studies are the gateway to advance interpretations of economic behavior expressed in resource management strategies entailing the procurement, use and distribution of lithic raw materials. We demonstrate the relevance of our results for archaeological materials in a case study in which we were able to differentiate between Scandinavian flint sources and establish the provenance of historic ballast flint from a shipwreck found near Kristiansand close to the shore of southern Norway from a beach source in Northern Jutland, the Vigsø Bay.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-6082525
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2018
publisher Public Library of Science
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-60825252018-08-28 A multi-technique analytical approach to sourcing Scandinavian flint: Provenance of ballast flint from the shipwreck “Leirvigen 1”, Norway Brandl, Michael Martinez, Maria M. Hauzenberger, Christoph Filzmoser, Peter Nymoen, Pål Mehler, Natascha PLoS One Research Article Although Scandinavian flint is one of the most important materials used for prehistoric stone tool production in Northern and Central Europe, a conclusive method for securely differentiating between flint sources, geologically bound to northern European chalk formations, has never been achieved. The main problems with traditional approaches concern the oftentimes high similarities of SiO(2) raw materials (i.e. chert and flint) on different scales due to similar genetic conditions and higher intra- than inter-source variation. Conventional chert and flint provenance studies chiefly concentrate on visual, petrographic or geochemical investigations. Hence, attempts to generate characteristic fingerprints of particular chert raw materials were in most cases unsatisfying. Here we show that the Multi Layered Chert Sourcing Approach (MLA) achieves a clear differentiation between primary sources of Scandinavian flint. The MLA combines visual comparative studies, stereo-microscopic analyses of microfossil inclusions, geochemical trace element analyses applying LA-ICP-MS (Laser Ablation Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry) and statistical analyses through CODA (Compositional Data Analysis). For archaeologists, provenance studies are the gateway to advance interpretations of economic behavior expressed in resource management strategies entailing the procurement, use and distribution of lithic raw materials. We demonstrate the relevance of our results for archaeological materials in a case study in which we were able to differentiate between Scandinavian flint sources and establish the provenance of historic ballast flint from a shipwreck found near Kristiansand close to the shore of southern Norway from a beach source in Northern Jutland, the Vigsø Bay. Public Library of Science 2018-08-08 /pmc/articles/PMC6082525/ /pubmed/30089119 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0200647 Text en https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/ This is an open access article, free of all copyright, and may be freely reproduced, distributed, transmitted, modified, built upon, or otherwise used by anyone for any lawful purpose. The work is made available under the Creative Commons CC0 (https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) public domain dedication.
spellingShingle Research Article
Brandl, Michael
Martinez, Maria M.
Hauzenberger, Christoph
Filzmoser, Peter
Nymoen, Pål
Mehler, Natascha
A multi-technique analytical approach to sourcing Scandinavian flint: Provenance of ballast flint from the shipwreck “Leirvigen 1”, Norway
title A multi-technique analytical approach to sourcing Scandinavian flint: Provenance of ballast flint from the shipwreck “Leirvigen 1”, Norway
title_full A multi-technique analytical approach to sourcing Scandinavian flint: Provenance of ballast flint from the shipwreck “Leirvigen 1”, Norway
title_fullStr A multi-technique analytical approach to sourcing Scandinavian flint: Provenance of ballast flint from the shipwreck “Leirvigen 1”, Norway
title_full_unstemmed A multi-technique analytical approach to sourcing Scandinavian flint: Provenance of ballast flint from the shipwreck “Leirvigen 1”, Norway
title_short A multi-technique analytical approach to sourcing Scandinavian flint: Provenance of ballast flint from the shipwreck “Leirvigen 1”, Norway
title_sort multi-technique analytical approach to sourcing scandinavian flint: provenance of ballast flint from the shipwreck “leirvigen 1”, norway
topic Research Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6082525/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/30089119
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0200647
work_keys_str_mv AT brandlmichael amultitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway
AT martinezmariam amultitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway
AT hauzenbergerchristoph amultitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway
AT filzmoserpeter amultitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway
AT nymoenpal amultitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway
AT mehlernatascha amultitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway
AT brandlmichael multitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway
AT martinezmariam multitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway
AT hauzenbergerchristoph multitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway
AT filzmoserpeter multitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway
AT nymoenpal multitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway
AT mehlernatascha multitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway