Cargando…
A novel panel of short mononucleotide repeats linked to informative polymorphisms enabling effective high volume low cost discrimination between mismatch repair deficient and proficient tumours
Somatic mutations in mononucleotide repeats are commonly used to assess the mismatch repair status of tumours. Current tests focus on repeats with a length above 15bp, which tend to be somatically more unstable than shorter ones. These longer repeats also have a substantially higher PCR error rate,...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Public Library of Science
2018
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6114912/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/30157243 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0203052 |
_version_ | 1783351285912698880 |
---|---|
author | Redford, Lisa Alhilal, Ghanim Needham, Stephanie O’Brien, Ottie Coaker, Julie Tyson, John Amorim, Leonardo Maldaner Middleton, Iona Izuogu, Osagi Arends, Mark Oniscu, Anca Alonso, Ángel Miguel Laguna, Sira Moreno Gallon, Richard Sheth, Harsh Santibanez-Koref, Mauro Jackson, Michael S. Burn, John |
author_facet | Redford, Lisa Alhilal, Ghanim Needham, Stephanie O’Brien, Ottie Coaker, Julie Tyson, John Amorim, Leonardo Maldaner Middleton, Iona Izuogu, Osagi Arends, Mark Oniscu, Anca Alonso, Ángel Miguel Laguna, Sira Moreno Gallon, Richard Sheth, Harsh Santibanez-Koref, Mauro Jackson, Michael S. Burn, John |
author_sort | Redford, Lisa |
collection | PubMed |
description | Somatic mutations in mononucleotide repeats are commonly used to assess the mismatch repair status of tumours. Current tests focus on repeats with a length above 15bp, which tend to be somatically more unstable than shorter ones. These longer repeats also have a substantially higher PCR error rate, and tests that use capillary electrophoresis for fragment size analysis often require expert interpretation. In this communication, we present a panel of 17 short repeats (length 7–12bp) for sequence-based microsatellite instability (MSI) testing. Using a simple scoring procedure that incorporates the allelic distribution of the mutant repeats, and analysis of two cohort of tumours totalling 209 samples, we show that this panel is able to discriminate between MMR proficient and deficient tumours, even when constitutional DNA is not available. In the training cohort, the method achieved 100% concordance with fragment analysis, while in the testing cohort, 4 discordant samples were observed (corresponding to 97% concordance). Of these, 2 showed discrepancies between fragment analysis and immunohistochemistry and one was reclassified after re-testing using fragment analysis. These results indicate that our approach offers the option of a reliable, scalable routine test for MSI. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-6114912 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2018 |
publisher | Public Library of Science |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-61149122018-09-17 A novel panel of short mononucleotide repeats linked to informative polymorphisms enabling effective high volume low cost discrimination between mismatch repair deficient and proficient tumours Redford, Lisa Alhilal, Ghanim Needham, Stephanie O’Brien, Ottie Coaker, Julie Tyson, John Amorim, Leonardo Maldaner Middleton, Iona Izuogu, Osagi Arends, Mark Oniscu, Anca Alonso, Ángel Miguel Laguna, Sira Moreno Gallon, Richard Sheth, Harsh Santibanez-Koref, Mauro Jackson, Michael S. Burn, John PLoS One Research Article Somatic mutations in mononucleotide repeats are commonly used to assess the mismatch repair status of tumours. Current tests focus on repeats with a length above 15bp, which tend to be somatically more unstable than shorter ones. These longer repeats also have a substantially higher PCR error rate, and tests that use capillary electrophoresis for fragment size analysis often require expert interpretation. In this communication, we present a panel of 17 short repeats (length 7–12bp) for sequence-based microsatellite instability (MSI) testing. Using a simple scoring procedure that incorporates the allelic distribution of the mutant repeats, and analysis of two cohort of tumours totalling 209 samples, we show that this panel is able to discriminate between MMR proficient and deficient tumours, even when constitutional DNA is not available. In the training cohort, the method achieved 100% concordance with fragment analysis, while in the testing cohort, 4 discordant samples were observed (corresponding to 97% concordance). Of these, 2 showed discrepancies between fragment analysis and immunohistochemistry and one was reclassified after re-testing using fragment analysis. These results indicate that our approach offers the option of a reliable, scalable routine test for MSI. Public Library of Science 2018-08-29 /pmc/articles/PMC6114912/ /pubmed/30157243 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0203052 Text en © 2018 Redford et al http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. |
spellingShingle | Research Article Redford, Lisa Alhilal, Ghanim Needham, Stephanie O’Brien, Ottie Coaker, Julie Tyson, John Amorim, Leonardo Maldaner Middleton, Iona Izuogu, Osagi Arends, Mark Oniscu, Anca Alonso, Ángel Miguel Laguna, Sira Moreno Gallon, Richard Sheth, Harsh Santibanez-Koref, Mauro Jackson, Michael S. Burn, John A novel panel of short mononucleotide repeats linked to informative polymorphisms enabling effective high volume low cost discrimination between mismatch repair deficient and proficient tumours |
title | A novel panel of short mononucleotide repeats linked to informative polymorphisms enabling effective high volume low cost discrimination between mismatch repair deficient and proficient tumours |
title_full | A novel panel of short mononucleotide repeats linked to informative polymorphisms enabling effective high volume low cost discrimination between mismatch repair deficient and proficient tumours |
title_fullStr | A novel panel of short mononucleotide repeats linked to informative polymorphisms enabling effective high volume low cost discrimination between mismatch repair deficient and proficient tumours |
title_full_unstemmed | A novel panel of short mononucleotide repeats linked to informative polymorphisms enabling effective high volume low cost discrimination between mismatch repair deficient and proficient tumours |
title_short | A novel panel of short mononucleotide repeats linked to informative polymorphisms enabling effective high volume low cost discrimination between mismatch repair deficient and proficient tumours |
title_sort | novel panel of short mononucleotide repeats linked to informative polymorphisms enabling effective high volume low cost discrimination between mismatch repair deficient and proficient tumours |
topic | Research Article |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6114912/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/30157243 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0203052 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT redfordlisa anovelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT alhilalghanim anovelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT needhamstephanie anovelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT obrienottie anovelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT coakerjulie anovelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT tysonjohn anovelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT amorimleonardomaldaner anovelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT middletoniona anovelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT izuoguosagi anovelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT arendsmark anovelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT oniscuanca anovelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT alonsoangelmiguel anovelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT lagunasiramoreno anovelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT gallonrichard anovelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT shethharsh anovelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT santibanezkorefmauro anovelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT jacksonmichaels anovelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT burnjohn anovelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT redfordlisa novelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT alhilalghanim novelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT needhamstephanie novelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT obrienottie novelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT coakerjulie novelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT tysonjohn novelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT amorimleonardomaldaner novelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT middletoniona novelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT izuoguosagi novelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT arendsmark novelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT oniscuanca novelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT alonsoangelmiguel novelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT lagunasiramoreno novelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT gallonrichard novelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT shethharsh novelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT santibanezkorefmauro novelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT jacksonmichaels novelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours AT burnjohn novelpanelofshortmononucleotiderepeatslinkedtoinformativepolymorphismsenablingeffectivehighvolumelowcostdiscriminationbetweenmismatchrepairdeficientandproficienttumours |