Rhenium-188 Hydroxyethane 1,1-Diphosphonic Acid (HEDP) for Bone Pain Palliation Using BARC-HEDP Kits versus Pars-HEDP Kits: A Comparison on Preparation and Performance Aspects at Hospital Radiopharmacy

PURPOSE OF THE STUDY: Rhenium-188 hydroxyethane 1,1-diphosphonic acid (HEDP) is a clinically established radiopharmaceutical for palliation of bone pain due to osseous metastases. Recently, the Bhabha Atomic Research Centre (BARC) had developed a freeze-dried kit for the preparation of rhenium-188 HEDP. The present study compares the radiochemistry aspects of indigenous BARC-HEDP kits with commercially available HEDP kits from Pars Isotope Company, Iran. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Freeze-dried HEDP kits were obtained from Radiopharmaceuticals Division, BARC, and Pars Isotope Company, Iran. Following recommended procedures, rhenium-188 HEDP was prepared using freeze-dried kits from both sources using freshly eluted rhenium-188 sodium perrhenate obtained from a commercial tungsten-188/rhenium-188 generator. RESULTS: Both kits could be used for the preparation of rhenium-188 HEDP in >95% radiochemical purity (RCP). Rhenium-188 HEDP prepared from both kits showed comparable in vitro stability as well as pharmacokinetic properties. The normal bone-to-soft tissue ratio observed for rhenium-188 HEDP prepared using BARC-HEDP kit and Pars-HEDP kit was 1.993 and 1.416, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Both HEDP kits provided a user-friendly solution for the preparation of rhenium-188 HEDP. While Pars-HEDP-kit permits the addition of only 2 mL of rhenium-188 perrhenate solution per kit vial, BARC-HEDP-kit allows up to 5 mL. This feature permits the preparation of patient dose of rhenium-188 HEDP even with older generators providing rhenium-188 perrhenate having a low radioactive concentration (activity/mL). In addition, availability of an indigenous product is always preferable over imported options.