Cargando…

Identification of mosquitoes (Diptera: Culicidae): an external quality assessment of medical entomology laboratories in the MediLabSecure Network

BACKGROUND: Identification of vectors is of prime importance in the field of medical entomology for both operational and research purposes. An external quality assessment of mosquito identification capacities was carried out within the MediLabSecure Network, which is composed of laboratories located...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Jourdain, Frédéric, Picard, Marie, Sulesco, Tatiana, Haddad, Nabil, Harrat, Zoubir, Sawalha, Samer Saleh, Günay, Filiz, Kanani, Khalil, Shaibi, Taher, Akhramenko, Denys, Sarih, M’hammed, Velo, Enkelejda, Paronyan, Lusine, Pajovic, Igor, Faraj, Chafika, Sikharulidze, Irakli, Putkaradze, David, Maric, Jelena, Bosevska, Golubinka, Janceska, Elizabeta, Bouattour, Ali, Hamidi, Afrim, Sherifi, Kurtesh, Alten, Bülent, Petrić, Dušan, Robert, Vincent
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: BioMed Central 2018
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6199703/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/30352609
http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s13071-018-3127-7
_version_ 1783365180348956672
author Jourdain, Frédéric
Picard, Marie
Sulesco, Tatiana
Haddad, Nabil
Harrat, Zoubir
Sawalha, Samer Saleh
Günay, Filiz
Kanani, Khalil
Shaibi, Taher
Akhramenko, Denys
Sarih, M’hammed
Velo, Enkelejda
Paronyan, Lusine
Pajovic, Igor
Faraj, Chafika
Sikharulidze, Irakli
Putkaradze, David
Maric, Jelena
Bosevska, Golubinka
Janceska, Elizabeta
Bouattour, Ali
Hamidi, Afrim
Sherifi, Kurtesh
Alten, Bülent
Petrić, Dušan
Robert, Vincent
author_facet Jourdain, Frédéric
Picard, Marie
Sulesco, Tatiana
Haddad, Nabil
Harrat, Zoubir
Sawalha, Samer Saleh
Günay, Filiz
Kanani, Khalil
Shaibi, Taher
Akhramenko, Denys
Sarih, M’hammed
Velo, Enkelejda
Paronyan, Lusine
Pajovic, Igor
Faraj, Chafika
Sikharulidze, Irakli
Putkaradze, David
Maric, Jelena
Bosevska, Golubinka
Janceska, Elizabeta
Bouattour, Ali
Hamidi, Afrim
Sherifi, Kurtesh
Alten, Bülent
Petrić, Dušan
Robert, Vincent
author_sort Jourdain, Frédéric
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Identification of vectors is of prime importance in the field of medical entomology for both operational and research purposes. An external quality assessment of mosquito identification capacities was carried out within the MediLabSecure Network, which is composed of laboratories located in 19 countries close to the European Union around the Mediterranean and Black seas. METHODS: A set of blind samples consisting of 7 or 8 adult mosquitoes and 4 larvae was given to each participant laboratory. In all, 138 adult mosquitoes and 76 larvae of different species were distributed for genus and species identification. RESULTS: All identifications were exclusively morphology based. Overall, 81% of identifications were correct at the genus level, 64% at the species level. The results were highly varied among the 19 participating laboratories. The levels of correct identifications were: 100% (three laboratories), 90–95% (four laboratories), 50–75% (six laboratories) and < 50% (six laboratories). CONCLUSIONS: This evaluation showed the need to maintain efforts in capacity building and quality control in the field of medical entomology and, more specifically, in the morphological identification of the Culicidae. ELECTRONIC SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL: The online version of this article (10.1186/s13071-018-3127-7) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-6199703
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2018
publisher BioMed Central
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-61997032018-10-31 Identification of mosquitoes (Diptera: Culicidae): an external quality assessment of medical entomology laboratories in the MediLabSecure Network Jourdain, Frédéric Picard, Marie Sulesco, Tatiana Haddad, Nabil Harrat, Zoubir Sawalha, Samer Saleh Günay, Filiz Kanani, Khalil Shaibi, Taher Akhramenko, Denys Sarih, M’hammed Velo, Enkelejda Paronyan, Lusine Pajovic, Igor Faraj, Chafika Sikharulidze, Irakli Putkaradze, David Maric, Jelena Bosevska, Golubinka Janceska, Elizabeta Bouattour, Ali Hamidi, Afrim Sherifi, Kurtesh Alten, Bülent Petrić, Dušan Robert, Vincent Parasit Vectors Research BACKGROUND: Identification of vectors is of prime importance in the field of medical entomology for both operational and research purposes. An external quality assessment of mosquito identification capacities was carried out within the MediLabSecure Network, which is composed of laboratories located in 19 countries close to the European Union around the Mediterranean and Black seas. METHODS: A set of blind samples consisting of 7 or 8 adult mosquitoes and 4 larvae was given to each participant laboratory. In all, 138 adult mosquitoes and 76 larvae of different species were distributed for genus and species identification. RESULTS: All identifications were exclusively morphology based. Overall, 81% of identifications were correct at the genus level, 64% at the species level. The results were highly varied among the 19 participating laboratories. The levels of correct identifications were: 100% (three laboratories), 90–95% (four laboratories), 50–75% (six laboratories) and < 50% (six laboratories). CONCLUSIONS: This evaluation showed the need to maintain efforts in capacity building and quality control in the field of medical entomology and, more specifically, in the morphological identification of the Culicidae. ELECTRONIC SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL: The online version of this article (10.1186/s13071-018-3127-7) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users. BioMed Central 2018-10-23 /pmc/articles/PMC6199703/ /pubmed/30352609 http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s13071-018-3127-7 Text en © The Author(s). 2018 Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.
spellingShingle Research
Jourdain, Frédéric
Picard, Marie
Sulesco, Tatiana
Haddad, Nabil
Harrat, Zoubir
Sawalha, Samer Saleh
Günay, Filiz
Kanani, Khalil
Shaibi, Taher
Akhramenko, Denys
Sarih, M’hammed
Velo, Enkelejda
Paronyan, Lusine
Pajovic, Igor
Faraj, Chafika
Sikharulidze, Irakli
Putkaradze, David
Maric, Jelena
Bosevska, Golubinka
Janceska, Elizabeta
Bouattour, Ali
Hamidi, Afrim
Sherifi, Kurtesh
Alten, Bülent
Petrić, Dušan
Robert, Vincent
Identification of mosquitoes (Diptera: Culicidae): an external quality assessment of medical entomology laboratories in the MediLabSecure Network
title Identification of mosquitoes (Diptera: Culicidae): an external quality assessment of medical entomology laboratories in the MediLabSecure Network
title_full Identification of mosquitoes (Diptera: Culicidae): an external quality assessment of medical entomology laboratories in the MediLabSecure Network
title_fullStr Identification of mosquitoes (Diptera: Culicidae): an external quality assessment of medical entomology laboratories in the MediLabSecure Network
title_full_unstemmed Identification of mosquitoes (Diptera: Culicidae): an external quality assessment of medical entomology laboratories in the MediLabSecure Network
title_short Identification of mosquitoes (Diptera: Culicidae): an external quality assessment of medical entomology laboratories in the MediLabSecure Network
title_sort identification of mosquitoes (diptera: culicidae): an external quality assessment of medical entomology laboratories in the medilabsecure network
topic Research
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6199703/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/30352609
http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s13071-018-3127-7
work_keys_str_mv AT jourdainfrederic identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT picardmarie identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT sulescotatiana identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT haddadnabil identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT harratzoubir identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT sawalhasamersaleh identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT gunayfiliz identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT kananikhalil identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT shaibitaher identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT akhramenkodenys identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT sarihmhammed identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT veloenkelejda identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT paronyanlusine identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT pajovicigor identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT farajchafika identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT sikharulidzeirakli identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT putkaradzedavid identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT maricjelena identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT bosevskagolubinka identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT janceskaelizabeta identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT bouattourali identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT hamidiafrim identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT sherifikurtesh identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT altenbulent identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT petricdusan identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork
AT robertvincent identificationofmosquitoesdipteraculicidaeanexternalqualityassessmentofmedicalentomologylaboratoriesinthemedilabsecurenetwork