Factors increasing risk of failure following hip arthroscopy: a case control study

We aimed to identify factors such as pre-arthroscopy and intra-operative variables that were associated with failure of hip arthroscopy as a joint preserving operation. We performed a retrospective analysis of a database containing 344 consecutive hip arthroscopies performed at our institution. Forty-four hips were identified that underwent a subsequent arthroplasty procedure following their hip arthroscopy (cases). Sixty-six control hips (hip arthroscopy with no subsequent arthroplasty) were randomly selected from the same database. Cases and controls were matched for age, sex and follow-up (P = 0.59, 0.48, 0.10, respectively). Pre-operative radiographs/MRI scans plus intra-operative findings were analysed to identify factors associated with failure. Both a lower centre edge angle and higher acetabular index on pre-operative radiographs were associated with higher rates of failure (P < 0.001). The presence of any acetabular wear at operation was also associated with failure (P < 0.001). Highest rates of failure were seen in hips with both features of dysplasia on pre-operative radiographs and any intra-operative acetabular wear (relative risk: 5, odds ratio: 9.13, P < 0.001). Dysplastic features on pre-operative radiographs and the finding of acetabular wear at hip arthroscopy increase the risk of subsequent arthroplasty. Identification of these features pre-operatively with evolving imaging techniques would improve the results of hip arthroscopy as joint preserving surgery.