Estimating bone mass in children: can bone health index replace dual energy x-ray absorptiometry?

BACKGROUND: Bisphosphonates have been shown to increase metacarpal cortical width. Bone health index is computed from hand radiographs by measuring cortical thickness, width and length of the three middle metacarpals, and may potentially help predict fracture risk in children. OBJECTIVE: To compare bone health index with bone mineral density as measured from dual energy X-ray absorptiometry scans in patients with and without bisphosphonate treatment. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Two hundred ninety-three Caucasian patients (mean age: 11.5±3.7 years) were included. We documented absolute values and z-scores for whole-body less head and lumbar spine bone mineral density then correlated these with the bone health index, which were acquired on the same day, in different patient groups, depending on their ethnicity and diagnosis. RESULTS: Bone health index showed moderate to strong correlation with absolute values for whole-body (r=0.52) and lumbar spine (r=0.70) bone mineral density in those not treated with bisphosphonates and moderate correlation absolute values for whole-body (r=0.54) and lumber spine (r=0.51) bone mineral density for those treated with bisphosphonates. There was weak correlation of z-scores, ranging from r=0.11 to r=0.35 in both groups. CONCLUSION: The lack of a strong correlation between dual energy X-ray absorptiometry and bone health index suggests that they may be assessing different parameters.