Genetic analysis of admixture and hybrid patterns of Populus hopeiensis and P. tomentosa

Hybridization and introgression have resulted in reticulate evolution within the genus Populus. Consequently, the origin and evolutionary history of some hybrids has become blurred. P. hopeiensis and P. tomentosa are endemic to China, and there is still controversy about their origin. We employ phylogeny, Bayesian estimation of admixture, and approximate Bayesian computation to investigate their origin with 10 nuclear DNA and 6 cpDNA regions. The combined evidences firmly support the hypothesis that they are hybrids and dominated by F(1)s. P. hopeiensis was generated via hybridization between the paternal species P. alba and maternal species P. davidiana. Surprisingly, P. tomentosa was divided into two genetic types with different maternal parents. P. adenopoda hybridized with P. alba directly to generate the first genetic type (mb1) and hybridized with P. davidiana followed by P. alba to generate the second (mb2). In both genetic types, P. alba acted as the male parent. The maternal parent was P. adenopoda and P. davidiana for mb1 and mb2, respectively. Hybridization not only generated these hybrids but also resulted in a unidirectional gene flow from P. davidiana to P. adenopoda. The Populus species have maintained a delicate balance between their genetic integrity and gene exchange.