Cargando…
Including gaming disorder in the ICD-11: The need to do so from a clinical and public health perspective: Commentary on: A weak scientific basis for gaming disorder: Let us err on the side of caution (van Rooij et al., 2018)
The proposed introduction of gaming disorder (GD) in the 11th revision of the International Classification of Diseases (ICD-11) developed by the World Health Organization (WHO) has led to a lively debate over the past year. Besides the broad support for the decision in the academic press, a recent p...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Akadémiai Kiadó
2018
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6426367/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/30010410 http://dx.doi.org/10.1556/2006.7.2018.59 |
_version_ | 1783404995095298048 |
---|---|
author | Rumpf, Hans-Jürgen Achab, Sophia Billieux, Joël Bowden-Jones, Henrietta Carragher, Natacha Demetrovics, Zsolt Higuchi, Susumu King, Daniel L. Mann, Karl Potenza, Marc Saunders, John B. Abbott, Max Ambekar, Atul Aricak, Osman Tolga Assanangkornchai, Sawitri Bahar, Norharlina Borges, Guilherme Brand, Matthias Chan, Elda Mei-Lo Chung, Thomas Derevensky, Jeff Kashef, Ahmad El Farrell, Michael Fineberg, Naomi A. Gandin, Claudia Gentile, Douglas A. Griffiths, Mark D. Goudriaan, Anna E. Grall-Bronnec, Marie Hao, Wei Hodgins, David C. Ip, Patrick Király, Orsolya Lee, Hae Kook Kuss, Daria Lemmens, Jeroen S. Long, Jiang Lopez-Fernandez, Olatz Mihara, Satoko Petry, Nancy M. Pontes, Halley M. Rahimi-Movaghar, Afarin Rehbein, Florian Rehm, Jürgen Scafato, Emanuele Sharma, Manoi Spritzer, Daniel Stein, Dan J. Tam, Philip Weinstein, Aviv Wittchen, Hans-Ulrich Wölfling, Klaus Zullino, Daniele Poznyak, Vladimir |
author_facet | Rumpf, Hans-Jürgen Achab, Sophia Billieux, Joël Bowden-Jones, Henrietta Carragher, Natacha Demetrovics, Zsolt Higuchi, Susumu King, Daniel L. Mann, Karl Potenza, Marc Saunders, John B. Abbott, Max Ambekar, Atul Aricak, Osman Tolga Assanangkornchai, Sawitri Bahar, Norharlina Borges, Guilherme Brand, Matthias Chan, Elda Mei-Lo Chung, Thomas Derevensky, Jeff Kashef, Ahmad El Farrell, Michael Fineberg, Naomi A. Gandin, Claudia Gentile, Douglas A. Griffiths, Mark D. Goudriaan, Anna E. Grall-Bronnec, Marie Hao, Wei Hodgins, David C. Ip, Patrick Király, Orsolya Lee, Hae Kook Kuss, Daria Lemmens, Jeroen S. Long, Jiang Lopez-Fernandez, Olatz Mihara, Satoko Petry, Nancy M. Pontes, Halley M. Rahimi-Movaghar, Afarin Rehbein, Florian Rehm, Jürgen Scafato, Emanuele Sharma, Manoi Spritzer, Daniel Stein, Dan J. Tam, Philip Weinstein, Aviv Wittchen, Hans-Ulrich Wölfling, Klaus Zullino, Daniele Poznyak, Vladimir |
author_sort | Rumpf, Hans-Jürgen |
collection | PubMed |
description | The proposed introduction of gaming disorder (GD) in the 11th revision of the International Classification of Diseases (ICD-11) developed by the World Health Organization (WHO) has led to a lively debate over the past year. Besides the broad support for the decision in the academic press, a recent publication by van Rooij et al. (2018) repeated the criticism raised against the inclusion of GD in ICD-11 by Aarseth et al. (2017). We argue that this group of researchers fails to recognize the clinical and public health considerations, which support the WHO perspective. It is important to recognize a range of biases that may influence this debate; in particular, the gaming industry may wish to diminish its responsibility by claiming that GD is not a public health problem, a position which maybe supported by arguments from scholars based in media psychology, computer games research, communication science, and related disciplines. However, just as with any other disease or disorder in the ICD-11, the decision whether or not to include GD is based on clinical evidence and public health needs. Therefore, we reiterate our conclusion that including GD reflects the essence of the ICD and will facilitate treatment and prevention for those who need it. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-6426367 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2018 |
publisher | Akadémiai Kiadó |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-64263672019-04-24 Including gaming disorder in the ICD-11: The need to do so from a clinical and public health perspective: Commentary on: A weak scientific basis for gaming disorder: Let us err on the side of caution (van Rooij et al., 2018) Rumpf, Hans-Jürgen Achab, Sophia Billieux, Joël Bowden-Jones, Henrietta Carragher, Natacha Demetrovics, Zsolt Higuchi, Susumu King, Daniel L. Mann, Karl Potenza, Marc Saunders, John B. Abbott, Max Ambekar, Atul Aricak, Osman Tolga Assanangkornchai, Sawitri Bahar, Norharlina Borges, Guilherme Brand, Matthias Chan, Elda Mei-Lo Chung, Thomas Derevensky, Jeff Kashef, Ahmad El Farrell, Michael Fineberg, Naomi A. Gandin, Claudia Gentile, Douglas A. Griffiths, Mark D. Goudriaan, Anna E. Grall-Bronnec, Marie Hao, Wei Hodgins, David C. Ip, Patrick Király, Orsolya Lee, Hae Kook Kuss, Daria Lemmens, Jeroen S. Long, Jiang Lopez-Fernandez, Olatz Mihara, Satoko Petry, Nancy M. Pontes, Halley M. Rahimi-Movaghar, Afarin Rehbein, Florian Rehm, Jürgen Scafato, Emanuele Sharma, Manoi Spritzer, Daniel Stein, Dan J. Tam, Philip Weinstein, Aviv Wittchen, Hans-Ulrich Wölfling, Klaus Zullino, Daniele Poznyak, Vladimir J Behav Addict Commentary The proposed introduction of gaming disorder (GD) in the 11th revision of the International Classification of Diseases (ICD-11) developed by the World Health Organization (WHO) has led to a lively debate over the past year. Besides the broad support for the decision in the academic press, a recent publication by van Rooij et al. (2018) repeated the criticism raised against the inclusion of GD in ICD-11 by Aarseth et al. (2017). We argue that this group of researchers fails to recognize the clinical and public health considerations, which support the WHO perspective. It is important to recognize a range of biases that may influence this debate; in particular, the gaming industry may wish to diminish its responsibility by claiming that GD is not a public health problem, a position which maybe supported by arguments from scholars based in media psychology, computer games research, communication science, and related disciplines. However, just as with any other disease or disorder in the ICD-11, the decision whether or not to include GD is based on clinical evidence and public health needs. Therefore, we reiterate our conclusion that including GD reflects the essence of the ICD and will facilitate treatment and prevention for those who need it. Akadémiai Kiadó 2018-07-02 2018-09 /pmc/articles/PMC6426367/ /pubmed/30010410 http://dx.doi.org/10.1556/2006.7.2018.59 Text en © 2018 The Author(s) http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium for non-commercial purposes, provided the original author and source are credited, a link to the CC License is provided, and changes – if any – are indicated. |
spellingShingle | Commentary Rumpf, Hans-Jürgen Achab, Sophia Billieux, Joël Bowden-Jones, Henrietta Carragher, Natacha Demetrovics, Zsolt Higuchi, Susumu King, Daniel L. Mann, Karl Potenza, Marc Saunders, John B. Abbott, Max Ambekar, Atul Aricak, Osman Tolga Assanangkornchai, Sawitri Bahar, Norharlina Borges, Guilherme Brand, Matthias Chan, Elda Mei-Lo Chung, Thomas Derevensky, Jeff Kashef, Ahmad El Farrell, Michael Fineberg, Naomi A. Gandin, Claudia Gentile, Douglas A. Griffiths, Mark D. Goudriaan, Anna E. Grall-Bronnec, Marie Hao, Wei Hodgins, David C. Ip, Patrick Király, Orsolya Lee, Hae Kook Kuss, Daria Lemmens, Jeroen S. Long, Jiang Lopez-Fernandez, Olatz Mihara, Satoko Petry, Nancy M. Pontes, Halley M. Rahimi-Movaghar, Afarin Rehbein, Florian Rehm, Jürgen Scafato, Emanuele Sharma, Manoi Spritzer, Daniel Stein, Dan J. Tam, Philip Weinstein, Aviv Wittchen, Hans-Ulrich Wölfling, Klaus Zullino, Daniele Poznyak, Vladimir Including gaming disorder in the ICD-11: The need to do so from a clinical and public health perspective: Commentary on: A weak scientific basis for gaming disorder: Let us err on the side of caution (van Rooij et al., 2018) |
title | Including gaming disorder in the ICD-11: The need to do so from a clinical and public health perspective: Commentary on: A weak scientific basis for gaming disorder: Let us err on the side of caution (van Rooij et al., 2018) |
title_full | Including gaming disorder in the ICD-11: The need to do so from a clinical and public health perspective: Commentary on: A weak scientific basis for gaming disorder: Let us err on the side of caution (van Rooij et al., 2018) |
title_fullStr | Including gaming disorder in the ICD-11: The need to do so from a clinical and public health perspective: Commentary on: A weak scientific basis for gaming disorder: Let us err on the side of caution (van Rooij et al., 2018) |
title_full_unstemmed | Including gaming disorder in the ICD-11: The need to do so from a clinical and public health perspective: Commentary on: A weak scientific basis for gaming disorder: Let us err on the side of caution (van Rooij et al., 2018) |
title_short | Including gaming disorder in the ICD-11: The need to do so from a clinical and public health perspective: Commentary on: A weak scientific basis for gaming disorder: Let us err on the side of caution (van Rooij et al., 2018) |
title_sort | including gaming disorder in the icd-11: the need to do so from a clinical and public health perspective: commentary on: a weak scientific basis for gaming disorder: let us err on the side of caution (van rooij et al., 2018) |
topic | Commentary |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6426367/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/30010410 http://dx.doi.org/10.1556/2006.7.2018.59 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT rumpfhansjurgen includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT achabsophia includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT billieuxjoel includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT bowdenjoneshenrietta includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT carraghernatacha includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT demetrovicszsolt includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT higuchisusumu includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT kingdaniell includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT mannkarl includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT potenzamarc includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT saundersjohnb includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT abbottmax includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT ambekaratul includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT aricakosmantolga includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT assanangkornchaisawitri includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT baharnorharlina includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT borgesguilherme includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT brandmatthias includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT chaneldameilo includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT chungthomas includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT derevenskyjeff includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT kashefahmadel includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT farrellmichael includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT finebergnaomia includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT gandinclaudia includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT gentiledouglasa includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT griffithsmarkd includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT goudriaanannae includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT grallbronnecmarie includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT haowei includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT hodginsdavidc includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT ippatrick includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT kiralyorsolya includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT leehaekook includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT kussdaria includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT lemmensjeroens includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT longjiang includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT lopezfernandezolatz includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT miharasatoko includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT petrynancym includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT ponteshalleym includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT rahimimovagharafarin includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT rehbeinflorian includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT rehmjurgen includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT scafatoemanuele includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT sharmamanoi includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT spritzerdaniel includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT steindanj includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT tamphilip includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT weinsteinaviv includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT wittchenhansulrich includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT wolflingklaus includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT zullinodaniele includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 AT poznyakvladimir includinggamingdisorderintheicd11theneedtodosofromaclinicalandpublichealthperspectivecommentaryonaweakscientificbasisforgamingdisorderletuserronthesideofcautionvanrooijetal2018 |