Cargando…

The mTST – An mHealth approach for training and quality assurance of tuberculin skin test administration and reading

BACKGROUND: The Tuberculin Skin Test (TST) is a relatively simple test for detecting latent tuberculosis infection (LTBI) but requires regular quality assurance to ensure proper technique for administration and reading. The objective of this study was to estimate the accuracy and reproducibility of...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Moayedi-Nia, Saeedeh, Barss, Leila, Oxlade, Olivia, Valiquette, Chantal, Ly, Mei-Xin, Campbell, Jonathon R., Lan, Zhiyi, Nsengiyumva, Placide, Fregonese, Federica, Lisboa Bastos, Mayara, Sampath, Danielle, Winters, Nicholas, Menzies, Dick
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Public Library of Science 2019
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6469794/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/30995275
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0215240
_version_ 1783411681799438336
author Moayedi-Nia, Saeedeh
Barss, Leila
Oxlade, Olivia
Valiquette, Chantal
Ly, Mei-Xin
Campbell, Jonathon R.
Lan, Zhiyi
Nsengiyumva, Placide
Fregonese, Federica
Lisboa Bastos, Mayara
Sampath, Danielle
Winters, Nicholas
Menzies, Dick
author_facet Moayedi-Nia, Saeedeh
Barss, Leila
Oxlade, Olivia
Valiquette, Chantal
Ly, Mei-Xin
Campbell, Jonathon R.
Lan, Zhiyi
Nsengiyumva, Placide
Fregonese, Federica
Lisboa Bastos, Mayara
Sampath, Danielle
Winters, Nicholas
Menzies, Dick
author_sort Moayedi-Nia, Saeedeh
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: The Tuberculin Skin Test (TST) is a relatively simple test for detecting latent tuberculosis infection (LTBI) but requires regular quality assurance to ensure proper technique for administration and reading. The objective of this study was to estimate the accuracy and reproducibility of an mhealth approach (the mTST) to measure the size of swelling immediately following TST administration (TST injection bleb) and after 48–72 hours (TST induration). METHODS: Five non-clinical and one clinical reviewer measured the size of TST injection blebs, and TST indurations using smartphone acquired photos of sites of TST administration and readings in patients, or saline injections in volunteers. The reference standard was the onsite measurement (measured by an experienced TB nurse) of the actual TST injection bleb, or induration. Agreement of reviewers’ measurements with the reference standard, as well as agreement within and between reviewers, was estimated using Cohen's kappa coefficient. RESULTS: Using the mTST method to assess bleb size in 64 photos of different TST injections, agreement between reviewers, and the reference standard was very good to excellent (κ ranged from 0.75 to 0.87), and within-reviewer reproducibility of readings was excellent (κ ranged from 0.86 to 0.96). Using the mTST method to assess TST induration in 72 photos, reviewers were able to detect no induration (<5mm) and induration of 15mm or greater with accuracy of 95% and 92% respectively, but accuracy was only 20% and 77% for reactions of 5-9mm and 10-14mm respectively. CONCLUSION: The mTST approach appears to be a reliable tool to assess TST administration. The mTST approach was accurate to read indurations of 0-4mm or 15+mm, but less accurate for reactions of 5-14mm. We believe the mTST approach could be useful for training and quality assurance in locations where on-site supervision is not possible.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-6469794
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2019
publisher Public Library of Science
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-64697942019-05-03 The mTST – An mHealth approach for training and quality assurance of tuberculin skin test administration and reading Moayedi-Nia, Saeedeh Barss, Leila Oxlade, Olivia Valiquette, Chantal Ly, Mei-Xin Campbell, Jonathon R. Lan, Zhiyi Nsengiyumva, Placide Fregonese, Federica Lisboa Bastos, Mayara Sampath, Danielle Winters, Nicholas Menzies, Dick PLoS One Research Article BACKGROUND: The Tuberculin Skin Test (TST) is a relatively simple test for detecting latent tuberculosis infection (LTBI) but requires regular quality assurance to ensure proper technique for administration and reading. The objective of this study was to estimate the accuracy and reproducibility of an mhealth approach (the mTST) to measure the size of swelling immediately following TST administration (TST injection bleb) and after 48–72 hours (TST induration). METHODS: Five non-clinical and one clinical reviewer measured the size of TST injection blebs, and TST indurations using smartphone acquired photos of sites of TST administration and readings in patients, or saline injections in volunteers. The reference standard was the onsite measurement (measured by an experienced TB nurse) of the actual TST injection bleb, or induration. Agreement of reviewers’ measurements with the reference standard, as well as agreement within and between reviewers, was estimated using Cohen's kappa coefficient. RESULTS: Using the mTST method to assess bleb size in 64 photos of different TST injections, agreement between reviewers, and the reference standard was very good to excellent (κ ranged from 0.75 to 0.87), and within-reviewer reproducibility of readings was excellent (κ ranged from 0.86 to 0.96). Using the mTST method to assess TST induration in 72 photos, reviewers were able to detect no induration (<5mm) and induration of 15mm or greater with accuracy of 95% and 92% respectively, but accuracy was only 20% and 77% for reactions of 5-9mm and 10-14mm respectively. CONCLUSION: The mTST approach appears to be a reliable tool to assess TST administration. The mTST approach was accurate to read indurations of 0-4mm or 15+mm, but less accurate for reactions of 5-14mm. We believe the mTST approach could be useful for training and quality assurance in locations where on-site supervision is not possible. Public Library of Science 2019-04-17 /pmc/articles/PMC6469794/ /pubmed/30995275 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0215240 Text en © 2019 Moayedi-Nia et al http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
spellingShingle Research Article
Moayedi-Nia, Saeedeh
Barss, Leila
Oxlade, Olivia
Valiquette, Chantal
Ly, Mei-Xin
Campbell, Jonathon R.
Lan, Zhiyi
Nsengiyumva, Placide
Fregonese, Federica
Lisboa Bastos, Mayara
Sampath, Danielle
Winters, Nicholas
Menzies, Dick
The mTST – An mHealth approach for training and quality assurance of tuberculin skin test administration and reading
title The mTST – An mHealth approach for training and quality assurance of tuberculin skin test administration and reading
title_full The mTST – An mHealth approach for training and quality assurance of tuberculin skin test administration and reading
title_fullStr The mTST – An mHealth approach for training and quality assurance of tuberculin skin test administration and reading
title_full_unstemmed The mTST – An mHealth approach for training and quality assurance of tuberculin skin test administration and reading
title_short The mTST – An mHealth approach for training and quality assurance of tuberculin skin test administration and reading
title_sort mtst – an mhealth approach for training and quality assurance of tuberculin skin test administration and reading
topic Research Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6469794/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/30995275
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0215240
work_keys_str_mv AT moayediniasaeedeh themtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT barssleila themtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT oxladeolivia themtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT valiquettechantal themtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT lymeixin themtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT campbelljonathonr themtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT lanzhiyi themtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT nsengiyumvaplacide themtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT fregonesefederica themtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT lisboabastosmayara themtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT sampathdanielle themtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT wintersnicholas themtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT menziesdick themtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT moayediniasaeedeh mtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT barssleila mtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT oxladeolivia mtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT valiquettechantal mtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT lymeixin mtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT campbelljonathonr mtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT lanzhiyi mtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT nsengiyumvaplacide mtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT fregonesefederica mtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT lisboabastosmayara mtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT sampathdanielle mtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT wintersnicholas mtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading
AT menziesdick mtstanmhealthapproachfortrainingandqualityassuranceoftuberculinskintestadministrationandreading