Cargando…

Comprehensive analysis of coding variants highlights genetic complexity in developmental and epileptic encephalopathy

Although there are many known Mendelian genes linked to epileptic or developmental and epileptic encephalopathy (EE/DEE), its genetic architecture is not fully explained. Here, we address this incompleteness by analyzing exomes of 743 EE/DEE cases and 2366 controls. We observe that damaging ultra-ra...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Takata, Atsushi, Nakashima, Mitsuko, Saitsu, Hirotomo, Mizuguchi, Takeshi, Mitsuhashi, Satomi, Takahashi, Yukitoshi, Okamoto, Nobuhiko, Osaka, Hitoshi, Nakamura, Kazuyuki, Tohyama, Jun, Haginoya, Kazuhiro, Takeshita, Saoko, Kuki, Ichiro, Okanishi, Tohru, Goto, Tomohide, Sasaki, Masayuki, Sakai, Yasunari, Miyake, Noriko, Miyatake, Satoko, Tsuchida, Naomi, Iwama, Kazuhiro, Minase, Gaku, Sekiguchi, Futoshi, Fujita, Atsushi, Imagawa, Eri, Koshimizu, Eriko, Uchiyama, Yuri, Hamanaka, Kohei, Ohba, Chihiro, Itai, Toshiyuki, Aoi, Hiromi, Saida, Ken, Sakaguchi, Tomohiro, Den, Kouhei, Takahashi, Rina, Ikeda, Hiroko, Yamaguchi, Tokito, Tsukamoto, Kazuki, Yoshitomi, Shinsaku, Oboshi, Taikan, Imai, Katsumi, Kimizu, Tomokazu, Kobayashi, Yu, Kubota, Masaya, Kashii, Hirofumi, Baba, Shimpei, Iai, Mizue, Kira, Ryutaro, Hara, Munetsugu, Ohta, Masayasu, Miyata, Yohane, Miyata, Rie, Takanashi, Jun-ichi, Matsui, Jun, Yokochi, Kenji, Shimono, Masayuki, Amamoto, Masano, Takayama, Rumiko, Hirabayashi, Shinichi, Aiba, Kaori, Matsumoto, Hiroshi, Nabatame, Shin, Shiihara, Takashi, Kato, Mitsuhiro, Matsumoto, Naomichi
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Nature Publishing Group UK 2019
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6555845/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31175295
http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41467-019-10482-9
_version_ 1783425222805815296
author Takata, Atsushi
Nakashima, Mitsuko
Saitsu, Hirotomo
Mizuguchi, Takeshi
Mitsuhashi, Satomi
Takahashi, Yukitoshi
Okamoto, Nobuhiko
Osaka, Hitoshi
Nakamura, Kazuyuki
Tohyama, Jun
Haginoya, Kazuhiro
Takeshita, Saoko
Kuki, Ichiro
Okanishi, Tohru
Goto, Tomohide
Sasaki, Masayuki
Sakai, Yasunari
Miyake, Noriko
Miyatake, Satoko
Tsuchida, Naomi
Iwama, Kazuhiro
Minase, Gaku
Sekiguchi, Futoshi
Fujita, Atsushi
Imagawa, Eri
Koshimizu, Eriko
Uchiyama, Yuri
Hamanaka, Kohei
Ohba, Chihiro
Itai, Toshiyuki
Aoi, Hiromi
Saida, Ken
Sakaguchi, Tomohiro
Den, Kouhei
Takahashi, Rina
Ikeda, Hiroko
Yamaguchi, Tokito
Tsukamoto, Kazuki
Yoshitomi, Shinsaku
Oboshi, Taikan
Imai, Katsumi
Kimizu, Tomokazu
Kobayashi, Yu
Kubota, Masaya
Kashii, Hirofumi
Baba, Shimpei
Iai, Mizue
Kira, Ryutaro
Hara, Munetsugu
Ohta, Masayasu
Miyata, Yohane
Miyata, Rie
Takanashi, Jun-ichi
Matsui, Jun
Yokochi, Kenji
Shimono, Masayuki
Amamoto, Masano
Takayama, Rumiko
Hirabayashi, Shinichi
Aiba, Kaori
Matsumoto, Hiroshi
Nabatame, Shin
Shiihara, Takashi
Kato, Mitsuhiro
Matsumoto, Naomichi
author_facet Takata, Atsushi
Nakashima, Mitsuko
Saitsu, Hirotomo
Mizuguchi, Takeshi
Mitsuhashi, Satomi
Takahashi, Yukitoshi
Okamoto, Nobuhiko
Osaka, Hitoshi
Nakamura, Kazuyuki
Tohyama, Jun
Haginoya, Kazuhiro
Takeshita, Saoko
Kuki, Ichiro
Okanishi, Tohru
Goto, Tomohide
Sasaki, Masayuki
Sakai, Yasunari
Miyake, Noriko
Miyatake, Satoko
Tsuchida, Naomi
Iwama, Kazuhiro
Minase, Gaku
Sekiguchi, Futoshi
Fujita, Atsushi
Imagawa, Eri
Koshimizu, Eriko
Uchiyama, Yuri
Hamanaka, Kohei
Ohba, Chihiro
Itai, Toshiyuki
Aoi, Hiromi
Saida, Ken
Sakaguchi, Tomohiro
Den, Kouhei
Takahashi, Rina
Ikeda, Hiroko
Yamaguchi, Tokito
Tsukamoto, Kazuki
Yoshitomi, Shinsaku
Oboshi, Taikan
Imai, Katsumi
Kimizu, Tomokazu
Kobayashi, Yu
Kubota, Masaya
Kashii, Hirofumi
Baba, Shimpei
Iai, Mizue
Kira, Ryutaro
Hara, Munetsugu
Ohta, Masayasu
Miyata, Yohane
Miyata, Rie
Takanashi, Jun-ichi
Matsui, Jun
Yokochi, Kenji
Shimono, Masayuki
Amamoto, Masano
Takayama, Rumiko
Hirabayashi, Shinichi
Aiba, Kaori
Matsumoto, Hiroshi
Nabatame, Shin
Shiihara, Takashi
Kato, Mitsuhiro
Matsumoto, Naomichi
author_sort Takata, Atsushi
collection PubMed
description Although there are many known Mendelian genes linked to epileptic or developmental and epileptic encephalopathy (EE/DEE), its genetic architecture is not fully explained. Here, we address this incompleteness by analyzing exomes of 743 EE/DEE cases and 2366 controls. We observe that damaging ultra-rare variants (dURVs) unique to an individual are significantly overrepresented in EE/DEE, both in known EE/DEE genes and the other non-EE/DEE genes. Importantly, enrichment of dURVs in non-EE/DEE genes is significant, even in the subset of cases with diagnostic dURVs (P = 0.000215), suggesting oligogenic contribution of non-EE/DEE gene dURVs. Gene-based analysis identifies exome-wide significant (P = 2.04 × 10(−6)) enrichment of damaging de novo mutations in NF1, a gene primarily linked to neurofibromatosis, in infantile spasm. Together with accumulating evidence for roles of oligogenic or modifier variants in severe neurodevelopmental disorders, our results highlight genetic complexity in EE/DEE, and indicate that EE/DEE is not an aggregate of simple Mendelian disorders.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-6555845
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2019
publisher Nature Publishing Group UK
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-65558452019-06-21 Comprehensive analysis of coding variants highlights genetic complexity in developmental and epileptic encephalopathy Takata, Atsushi Nakashima, Mitsuko Saitsu, Hirotomo Mizuguchi, Takeshi Mitsuhashi, Satomi Takahashi, Yukitoshi Okamoto, Nobuhiko Osaka, Hitoshi Nakamura, Kazuyuki Tohyama, Jun Haginoya, Kazuhiro Takeshita, Saoko Kuki, Ichiro Okanishi, Tohru Goto, Tomohide Sasaki, Masayuki Sakai, Yasunari Miyake, Noriko Miyatake, Satoko Tsuchida, Naomi Iwama, Kazuhiro Minase, Gaku Sekiguchi, Futoshi Fujita, Atsushi Imagawa, Eri Koshimizu, Eriko Uchiyama, Yuri Hamanaka, Kohei Ohba, Chihiro Itai, Toshiyuki Aoi, Hiromi Saida, Ken Sakaguchi, Tomohiro Den, Kouhei Takahashi, Rina Ikeda, Hiroko Yamaguchi, Tokito Tsukamoto, Kazuki Yoshitomi, Shinsaku Oboshi, Taikan Imai, Katsumi Kimizu, Tomokazu Kobayashi, Yu Kubota, Masaya Kashii, Hirofumi Baba, Shimpei Iai, Mizue Kira, Ryutaro Hara, Munetsugu Ohta, Masayasu Miyata, Yohane Miyata, Rie Takanashi, Jun-ichi Matsui, Jun Yokochi, Kenji Shimono, Masayuki Amamoto, Masano Takayama, Rumiko Hirabayashi, Shinichi Aiba, Kaori Matsumoto, Hiroshi Nabatame, Shin Shiihara, Takashi Kato, Mitsuhiro Matsumoto, Naomichi Nat Commun Article Although there are many known Mendelian genes linked to epileptic or developmental and epileptic encephalopathy (EE/DEE), its genetic architecture is not fully explained. Here, we address this incompleteness by analyzing exomes of 743 EE/DEE cases and 2366 controls. We observe that damaging ultra-rare variants (dURVs) unique to an individual are significantly overrepresented in EE/DEE, both in known EE/DEE genes and the other non-EE/DEE genes. Importantly, enrichment of dURVs in non-EE/DEE genes is significant, even in the subset of cases with diagnostic dURVs (P = 0.000215), suggesting oligogenic contribution of non-EE/DEE gene dURVs. Gene-based analysis identifies exome-wide significant (P = 2.04 × 10(−6)) enrichment of damaging de novo mutations in NF1, a gene primarily linked to neurofibromatosis, in infantile spasm. Together with accumulating evidence for roles of oligogenic or modifier variants in severe neurodevelopmental disorders, our results highlight genetic complexity in EE/DEE, and indicate that EE/DEE is not an aggregate of simple Mendelian disorders. Nature Publishing Group UK 2019-06-07 /pmc/articles/PMC6555845/ /pubmed/31175295 http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41467-019-10482-9 Text en © The Author(s) 2019 Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
spellingShingle Article
Takata, Atsushi
Nakashima, Mitsuko
Saitsu, Hirotomo
Mizuguchi, Takeshi
Mitsuhashi, Satomi
Takahashi, Yukitoshi
Okamoto, Nobuhiko
Osaka, Hitoshi
Nakamura, Kazuyuki
Tohyama, Jun
Haginoya, Kazuhiro
Takeshita, Saoko
Kuki, Ichiro
Okanishi, Tohru
Goto, Tomohide
Sasaki, Masayuki
Sakai, Yasunari
Miyake, Noriko
Miyatake, Satoko
Tsuchida, Naomi
Iwama, Kazuhiro
Minase, Gaku
Sekiguchi, Futoshi
Fujita, Atsushi
Imagawa, Eri
Koshimizu, Eriko
Uchiyama, Yuri
Hamanaka, Kohei
Ohba, Chihiro
Itai, Toshiyuki
Aoi, Hiromi
Saida, Ken
Sakaguchi, Tomohiro
Den, Kouhei
Takahashi, Rina
Ikeda, Hiroko
Yamaguchi, Tokito
Tsukamoto, Kazuki
Yoshitomi, Shinsaku
Oboshi, Taikan
Imai, Katsumi
Kimizu, Tomokazu
Kobayashi, Yu
Kubota, Masaya
Kashii, Hirofumi
Baba, Shimpei
Iai, Mizue
Kira, Ryutaro
Hara, Munetsugu
Ohta, Masayasu
Miyata, Yohane
Miyata, Rie
Takanashi, Jun-ichi
Matsui, Jun
Yokochi, Kenji
Shimono, Masayuki
Amamoto, Masano
Takayama, Rumiko
Hirabayashi, Shinichi
Aiba, Kaori
Matsumoto, Hiroshi
Nabatame, Shin
Shiihara, Takashi
Kato, Mitsuhiro
Matsumoto, Naomichi
Comprehensive analysis of coding variants highlights genetic complexity in developmental and epileptic encephalopathy
title Comprehensive analysis of coding variants highlights genetic complexity in developmental and epileptic encephalopathy
title_full Comprehensive analysis of coding variants highlights genetic complexity in developmental and epileptic encephalopathy
title_fullStr Comprehensive analysis of coding variants highlights genetic complexity in developmental and epileptic encephalopathy
title_full_unstemmed Comprehensive analysis of coding variants highlights genetic complexity in developmental and epileptic encephalopathy
title_short Comprehensive analysis of coding variants highlights genetic complexity in developmental and epileptic encephalopathy
title_sort comprehensive analysis of coding variants highlights genetic complexity in developmental and epileptic encephalopathy
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6555845/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31175295
http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41467-019-10482-9
work_keys_str_mv AT takataatsushi comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT nakashimamitsuko comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT saitsuhirotomo comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT mizuguchitakeshi comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT mitsuhashisatomi comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT takahashiyukitoshi comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT okamotonobuhiko comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT osakahitoshi comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT nakamurakazuyuki comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT tohyamajun comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT haginoyakazuhiro comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT takeshitasaoko comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT kukiichiro comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT okanishitohru comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT gototomohide comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT sasakimasayuki comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT sakaiyasunari comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT miyakenoriko comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT miyatakesatoko comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT tsuchidanaomi comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT iwamakazuhiro comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT minasegaku comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT sekiguchifutoshi comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT fujitaatsushi comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT imagawaeri comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT koshimizueriko comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT uchiyamayuri comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT hamanakakohei comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT ohbachihiro comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT itaitoshiyuki comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT aoihiromi comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT saidaken comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT sakaguchitomohiro comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT denkouhei comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT takahashirina comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT ikedahiroko comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT yamaguchitokito comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT tsukamotokazuki comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT yoshitomishinsaku comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT oboshitaikan comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT imaikatsumi comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT kimizutomokazu comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT kobayashiyu comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT kubotamasaya comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT kashiihirofumi comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT babashimpei comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT iaimizue comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT kiraryutaro comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT haramunetsugu comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT ohtamasayasu comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT miyatayohane comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT miyatarie comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT takanashijunichi comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT matsuijun comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT yokochikenji comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT shimonomasayuki comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT amamotomasano comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT takayamarumiko comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT hirabayashishinichi comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT aibakaori comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT matsumotohiroshi comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT nabatameshin comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT shiiharatakashi comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT katomitsuhiro comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy
AT matsumotonaomichi comprehensiveanalysisofcodingvariantshighlightsgeneticcomplexityindevelopmentalandepilepticencephalopathy