Cargando…

The general practice perspective on barriers to integration between primary and social care: a London, United Kingdom-based qualitative interview study

OBJECTIVE: There is an ongoing challenge of effective integration between primary and social care in the United Kingdom; current systems have led to fragmentation of services preventing holistic patient-centred care for vulnerable populations. To improve clinical outcomes and achieve financial effic...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Naqvi, Danial, Malik, Anam, Al-Zubaidy, Mohaimen, Naqvi, Falak, Tahir, Anas, Tarfiee, Ali, Vara, Sarina, Meyer, Edgar
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: BMJ Publishing Group 2019
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6707672/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31434776
http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2019-029702
_version_ 1783445899063590912
author Naqvi, Danial
Malik, Anam
Al-Zubaidy, Mohaimen
Naqvi, Falak
Tahir, Anas
Tarfiee, Ali
Vara, Sarina
Meyer, Edgar
author_facet Naqvi, Danial
Malik, Anam
Al-Zubaidy, Mohaimen
Naqvi, Falak
Tahir, Anas
Tarfiee, Ali
Vara, Sarina
Meyer, Edgar
author_sort Naqvi, Danial
collection PubMed
description OBJECTIVE: There is an ongoing challenge of effective integration between primary and social care in the United Kingdom; current systems have led to fragmentation of services preventing holistic patient-centred care for vulnerable populations. To improve clinical outcomes and achieve financial efficiencies, the barriers to integration need to be identified and addressed. This study aims to explore the unique perspectives of frontline staff (general practitioners and practice managers) towards these barriers to integration. DESIGN: Qualitative study using semistructured interviews and thematic analysis to obtain results. SETTING: General practices within London. PARTICIPANTS: 18 general practitioners (GPs) and 7 practice managers (PMs) based in London with experience of working with social care. RESULTS: The study identified three overarching themes where frontline staff believed problems exist: accessing social services, interprofessional relationships and infrastructure. Issues with contacting staff from other sectors creates delays in referrals for patient care and perpetuates existing logistical challenges. Likewise, professionals noted a hostile working culture between sectors that has resulted in silo working mentalities. In addition to staff being overworked as well as often inefficient multidisciplinary team meetings, poor relationships across sectors cause a diffusion of responsibility, impacting the speed with which patient requests are responded to. Furthermore, participants identified that a lack of interoperability between information systems, lack of pooled budgets and misaligned incentives between managerial staff compound the infrastructural divide between both sectors. CONCLUSION: In this study, primary care staff identify intangible barriers to integration such as poor interprofessional relationships, in addition to more well-described structural issues such as insufficient funding and difficulty accessing social care. Participants believe that educating the next generation of medical professionals may lead to the development of collaborative, instead of siloed, working cultures and that change is needed at both an interpersonal and institutional level to successfully integrate care.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-6707672
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2019
publisher BMJ Publishing Group
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-67076722019-09-06 The general practice perspective on barriers to integration between primary and social care: a London, United Kingdom-based qualitative interview study Naqvi, Danial Malik, Anam Al-Zubaidy, Mohaimen Naqvi, Falak Tahir, Anas Tarfiee, Ali Vara, Sarina Meyer, Edgar BMJ Open Qualitative Research OBJECTIVE: There is an ongoing challenge of effective integration between primary and social care in the United Kingdom; current systems have led to fragmentation of services preventing holistic patient-centred care for vulnerable populations. To improve clinical outcomes and achieve financial efficiencies, the barriers to integration need to be identified and addressed. This study aims to explore the unique perspectives of frontline staff (general practitioners and practice managers) towards these barriers to integration. DESIGN: Qualitative study using semistructured interviews and thematic analysis to obtain results. SETTING: General practices within London. PARTICIPANTS: 18 general practitioners (GPs) and 7 practice managers (PMs) based in London with experience of working with social care. RESULTS: The study identified three overarching themes where frontline staff believed problems exist: accessing social services, interprofessional relationships and infrastructure. Issues with contacting staff from other sectors creates delays in referrals for patient care and perpetuates existing logistical challenges. Likewise, professionals noted a hostile working culture between sectors that has resulted in silo working mentalities. In addition to staff being overworked as well as often inefficient multidisciplinary team meetings, poor relationships across sectors cause a diffusion of responsibility, impacting the speed with which patient requests are responded to. Furthermore, participants identified that a lack of interoperability between information systems, lack of pooled budgets and misaligned incentives between managerial staff compound the infrastructural divide between both sectors. CONCLUSION: In this study, primary care staff identify intangible barriers to integration such as poor interprofessional relationships, in addition to more well-described structural issues such as insufficient funding and difficulty accessing social care. Participants believe that educating the next generation of medical professionals may lead to the development of collaborative, instead of siloed, working cultures and that change is needed at both an interpersonal and institutional level to successfully integrate care. BMJ Publishing Group 2019-08-20 /pmc/articles/PMC6707672/ /pubmed/31434776 http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2019-029702 Text en © Author(s) (or their employer(s)) 2019. Re-use permitted under CC BY-NC. No commercial re-use. See rights and permissions. Published by BMJ. This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited, appropriate credit is given, any changes made indicated, and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/.
spellingShingle Qualitative Research
Naqvi, Danial
Malik, Anam
Al-Zubaidy, Mohaimen
Naqvi, Falak
Tahir, Anas
Tarfiee, Ali
Vara, Sarina
Meyer, Edgar
The general practice perspective on barriers to integration between primary and social care: a London, United Kingdom-based qualitative interview study
title The general practice perspective on barriers to integration between primary and social care: a London, United Kingdom-based qualitative interview study
title_full The general practice perspective on barriers to integration between primary and social care: a London, United Kingdom-based qualitative interview study
title_fullStr The general practice perspective on barriers to integration between primary and social care: a London, United Kingdom-based qualitative interview study
title_full_unstemmed The general practice perspective on barriers to integration between primary and social care: a London, United Kingdom-based qualitative interview study
title_short The general practice perspective on barriers to integration between primary and social care: a London, United Kingdom-based qualitative interview study
title_sort general practice perspective on barriers to integration between primary and social care: a london, united kingdom-based qualitative interview study
topic Qualitative Research
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6707672/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31434776
http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2019-029702
work_keys_str_mv AT naqvidanial thegeneralpracticeperspectiveonbarrierstointegrationbetweenprimaryandsocialcarealondonunitedkingdombasedqualitativeinterviewstudy
AT malikanam thegeneralpracticeperspectiveonbarrierstointegrationbetweenprimaryandsocialcarealondonunitedkingdombasedqualitativeinterviewstudy
AT alzubaidymohaimen thegeneralpracticeperspectiveonbarrierstointegrationbetweenprimaryandsocialcarealondonunitedkingdombasedqualitativeinterviewstudy
AT naqvifalak thegeneralpracticeperspectiveonbarrierstointegrationbetweenprimaryandsocialcarealondonunitedkingdombasedqualitativeinterviewstudy
AT tahiranas thegeneralpracticeperspectiveonbarrierstointegrationbetweenprimaryandsocialcarealondonunitedkingdombasedqualitativeinterviewstudy
AT tarfieeali thegeneralpracticeperspectiveonbarrierstointegrationbetweenprimaryandsocialcarealondonunitedkingdombasedqualitativeinterviewstudy
AT varasarina thegeneralpracticeperspectiveonbarrierstointegrationbetweenprimaryandsocialcarealondonunitedkingdombasedqualitativeinterviewstudy
AT meyeredgar thegeneralpracticeperspectiveonbarrierstointegrationbetweenprimaryandsocialcarealondonunitedkingdombasedqualitativeinterviewstudy
AT naqvidanial generalpracticeperspectiveonbarrierstointegrationbetweenprimaryandsocialcarealondonunitedkingdombasedqualitativeinterviewstudy
AT malikanam generalpracticeperspectiveonbarrierstointegrationbetweenprimaryandsocialcarealondonunitedkingdombasedqualitativeinterviewstudy
AT alzubaidymohaimen generalpracticeperspectiveonbarrierstointegrationbetweenprimaryandsocialcarealondonunitedkingdombasedqualitativeinterviewstudy
AT naqvifalak generalpracticeperspectiveonbarrierstointegrationbetweenprimaryandsocialcarealondonunitedkingdombasedqualitativeinterviewstudy
AT tahiranas generalpracticeperspectiveonbarrierstointegrationbetweenprimaryandsocialcarealondonunitedkingdombasedqualitativeinterviewstudy
AT tarfieeali generalpracticeperspectiveonbarrierstointegrationbetweenprimaryandsocialcarealondonunitedkingdombasedqualitativeinterviewstudy
AT varasarina generalpracticeperspectiveonbarrierstointegrationbetweenprimaryandsocialcarealondonunitedkingdombasedqualitativeinterviewstudy
AT meyeredgar generalpracticeperspectiveonbarrierstointegrationbetweenprimaryandsocialcarealondonunitedkingdombasedqualitativeinterviewstudy