Cargando…
The proximal hamstring avulsion clinical trial (PHACT)—a randomised controlled non-inferiority trial of operative versus non-operative treatment of proximal hamstrings avulsions: study protocol
INTRODUCTION: The treatment of proximal hamstring avulsions is controversial. While several trials have investigated the outcome for patients treated surgically, there is today no prospective trial comparing operative treatment with non-operative treatment. This protocol describes the design for the...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
BMJ Publishing Group
2019
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6747659/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31519683 http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2019-031607 |
_version_ | 1783451949716209664 |
---|---|
author | Pihl, Elsa Kristoffersen, Målfrid Holen Rosenlund, Anne-Mari Laszlo, Sofia Berglöf, Mida Ribom, Eva Eriksson, Karl Frihagen, Frede Mattila, Ville M Schilcher, Jörg Eklund, Martin Snellman, Greta Skorpil, Mikael Sköldenberg, Olof Hedbeck, Carl Johan Jonsson, Kenneth |
author_facet | Pihl, Elsa Kristoffersen, Målfrid Holen Rosenlund, Anne-Mari Laszlo, Sofia Berglöf, Mida Ribom, Eva Eriksson, Karl Frihagen, Frede Mattila, Ville M Schilcher, Jörg Eklund, Martin Snellman, Greta Skorpil, Mikael Sköldenberg, Olof Hedbeck, Carl Johan Jonsson, Kenneth |
author_sort | Pihl, Elsa |
collection | PubMed |
description | INTRODUCTION: The treatment of proximal hamstring avulsions is controversial. While several trials have investigated the outcome for patients treated surgically, there is today no prospective trial comparing operative treatment with non-operative treatment. This protocol describes the design for the proximal hamstring avulsion clinical trial (PHACT)—the first randomised controlled trial of operative versus non-operative treatment for proximal hamstring avulsions. METHODS AND ANALYSIS: PHACT is a multicentre randomised controlled trial conducted across Sweden, Norway and Finland. Eligible patients (60 participants/treatment arm) with a proximal hamstring avulsion of at least two of three tendons will be randomised to either operative or non-operative treatment. Participants allocated to surgery will undergo reinsertion of the tendons with suture anchors. The rehabilitation programme will be the same for both treatment groups. When patient or surgeon equipoise for treatment alternatives cannot be reached and randomisation therefore is not possible, patients will be invited to participate in a parallel observational non-randomised cohort. The primary outcome will be the patient-reported outcome measure Perth hamstring assessment tool at 24 months. Secondary outcomes include the Lower Extremity Functional Score, physical performance and muscle strength tests, patient satisfaction and MR imaging. Data analysis will be blinded and intention-to-treat analysis will be preformed. ETHICS AND DISSEMINATION: Ethical approval has been granted by the Ethical Committee of Uppsala University (DNR: 2017–170) and by the Norwegian ethical board (REC: 2017/1911). The study will be conducted in agreement with the Helsinki declaration. The findings will be disseminated in peer-reviewed publications. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: NCT03311997 |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-6747659 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2019 |
publisher | BMJ Publishing Group |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-67476592019-09-27 The proximal hamstring avulsion clinical trial (PHACT)—a randomised controlled non-inferiority trial of operative versus non-operative treatment of proximal hamstrings avulsions: study protocol Pihl, Elsa Kristoffersen, Målfrid Holen Rosenlund, Anne-Mari Laszlo, Sofia Berglöf, Mida Ribom, Eva Eriksson, Karl Frihagen, Frede Mattila, Ville M Schilcher, Jörg Eklund, Martin Snellman, Greta Skorpil, Mikael Sköldenberg, Olof Hedbeck, Carl Johan Jonsson, Kenneth BMJ Open Sports and Exercise Medicine INTRODUCTION: The treatment of proximal hamstring avulsions is controversial. While several trials have investigated the outcome for patients treated surgically, there is today no prospective trial comparing operative treatment with non-operative treatment. This protocol describes the design for the proximal hamstring avulsion clinical trial (PHACT)—the first randomised controlled trial of operative versus non-operative treatment for proximal hamstring avulsions. METHODS AND ANALYSIS: PHACT is a multicentre randomised controlled trial conducted across Sweden, Norway and Finland. Eligible patients (60 participants/treatment arm) with a proximal hamstring avulsion of at least two of three tendons will be randomised to either operative or non-operative treatment. Participants allocated to surgery will undergo reinsertion of the tendons with suture anchors. The rehabilitation programme will be the same for both treatment groups. When patient or surgeon equipoise for treatment alternatives cannot be reached and randomisation therefore is not possible, patients will be invited to participate in a parallel observational non-randomised cohort. The primary outcome will be the patient-reported outcome measure Perth hamstring assessment tool at 24 months. Secondary outcomes include the Lower Extremity Functional Score, physical performance and muscle strength tests, patient satisfaction and MR imaging. Data analysis will be blinded and intention-to-treat analysis will be preformed. ETHICS AND DISSEMINATION: Ethical approval has been granted by the Ethical Committee of Uppsala University (DNR: 2017–170) and by the Norwegian ethical board (REC: 2017/1911). The study will be conducted in agreement with the Helsinki declaration. The findings will be disseminated in peer-reviewed publications. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: NCT03311997 BMJ Publishing Group 2019-09-13 /pmc/articles/PMC6747659/ /pubmed/31519683 http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2019-031607 Text en © Author(s) (or their employer(s)) 2019. Re-use permitted under CC BY-NC. No commercial re-use. See rights and permissions. Published by BMJ. This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited, appropriate credit is given, any changes made indicated, and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/. |
spellingShingle | Sports and Exercise Medicine Pihl, Elsa Kristoffersen, Målfrid Holen Rosenlund, Anne-Mari Laszlo, Sofia Berglöf, Mida Ribom, Eva Eriksson, Karl Frihagen, Frede Mattila, Ville M Schilcher, Jörg Eklund, Martin Snellman, Greta Skorpil, Mikael Sköldenberg, Olof Hedbeck, Carl Johan Jonsson, Kenneth The proximal hamstring avulsion clinical trial (PHACT)—a randomised controlled non-inferiority trial of operative versus non-operative treatment of proximal hamstrings avulsions: study protocol |
title | The proximal hamstring avulsion clinical trial (PHACT)—a randomised controlled non-inferiority trial of operative versus non-operative treatment of proximal hamstrings avulsions: study protocol |
title_full | The proximal hamstring avulsion clinical trial (PHACT)—a randomised controlled non-inferiority trial of operative versus non-operative treatment of proximal hamstrings avulsions: study protocol |
title_fullStr | The proximal hamstring avulsion clinical trial (PHACT)—a randomised controlled non-inferiority trial of operative versus non-operative treatment of proximal hamstrings avulsions: study protocol |
title_full_unstemmed | The proximal hamstring avulsion clinical trial (PHACT)—a randomised controlled non-inferiority trial of operative versus non-operative treatment of proximal hamstrings avulsions: study protocol |
title_short | The proximal hamstring avulsion clinical trial (PHACT)—a randomised controlled non-inferiority trial of operative versus non-operative treatment of proximal hamstrings avulsions: study protocol |
title_sort | proximal hamstring avulsion clinical trial (phact)—a randomised controlled non-inferiority trial of operative versus non-operative treatment of proximal hamstrings avulsions: study protocol |
topic | Sports and Exercise Medicine |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6747659/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31519683 http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2019-031607 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT pihlelsa theproximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT kristoffersenmalfridholen theproximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT rosenlundannemari theproximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT laszlosofia theproximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT berglofmida theproximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT ribomeva theproximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT erikssonkarl theproximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT frihagenfrede theproximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT mattilavillem theproximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT schilcherjorg theproximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT eklundmartin theproximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT snellmangreta theproximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT skorpilmikael theproximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT skoldenbergolof theproximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT hedbeckcarljohan theproximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT jonssonkenneth theproximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT pihlelsa proximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT kristoffersenmalfridholen proximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT rosenlundannemari proximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT laszlosofia proximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT berglofmida proximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT ribomeva proximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT erikssonkarl proximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT frihagenfrede proximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT mattilavillem proximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT schilcherjorg proximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT eklundmartin proximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT snellmangreta proximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT skorpilmikael proximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT skoldenbergolof proximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT hedbeckcarljohan proximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol AT jonssonkenneth proximalhamstringavulsionclinicaltrialphactarandomisedcontrollednoninferioritytrialofoperativeversusnonoperativetreatmentofproximalhamstringsavulsionsstudyprotocol |