Cargando…

A Fully Integrated Real-Time Detection, Diagnosis, and Control of Community Diarrheal Disease Clusters and Outbreaks (the INTEGRATE Project): Protocol for an Enhanced Surveillance System

BACKGROUND: Diarrheal disease, which affects 1 in 4 people in the United Kingdom annually, is the most common cause of outbreaks in community and health care settings. Traditional surveillance methods tend to detect point-source outbreaks of diarrhea and vomiting; they are less effective at identify...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: McIntyre, Kirsty Marie, Bolton, Frederick J, Christley, Rob M, Cleary, Paul, Deja, Elizabeth, Durie, Ann E, Diggle, Peter J, Hughes, Dyfrig A, de Lusignan, Simon, Orton, Lois, Radford, Alan D, Elliot, Alex J, Smith, Gillian E, Snape, Darlene A, Stanistreet, Debbi, Vivancos, Roberto, Winstanley, Craig, O’Brien, Sarah J
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: JMIR Publications 2019
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6787530/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31573952
http://dx.doi.org/10.2196/13941
_version_ 1783458284265537536
author McIntyre, Kirsty Marie
Bolton, Frederick J
Christley, Rob M
Cleary, Paul
Deja, Elizabeth
Durie, Ann E
Diggle, Peter J
Hughes, Dyfrig A
de Lusignan, Simon
Orton, Lois
Radford, Alan D
Elliot, Alex J
Smith, Gillian E
Snape, Darlene A
Stanistreet, Debbi
Vivancos, Roberto
Winstanley, Craig
O’Brien, Sarah J
author_facet McIntyre, Kirsty Marie
Bolton, Frederick J
Christley, Rob M
Cleary, Paul
Deja, Elizabeth
Durie, Ann E
Diggle, Peter J
Hughes, Dyfrig A
de Lusignan, Simon
Orton, Lois
Radford, Alan D
Elliot, Alex J
Smith, Gillian E
Snape, Darlene A
Stanistreet, Debbi
Vivancos, Roberto
Winstanley, Craig
O’Brien, Sarah J
author_sort McIntyre, Kirsty Marie
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Diarrheal disease, which affects 1 in 4 people in the United Kingdom annually, is the most common cause of outbreaks in community and health care settings. Traditional surveillance methods tend to detect point-source outbreaks of diarrhea and vomiting; they are less effective at identifying low-level and intermittent food supply contamination. Furthermore, it can take up to 9 weeks for infections to be confirmed, reducing slow-burn outbreak recognition, potentially impacting hundreds or thousands of people over wide geographical areas. There is a need to address fundamental problems in traditional diarrheal disease surveillance because of underreporting and subsequent unconfirmed infection by patients and general practitioners (GPs); varying submission practices and selective testing of samples in laboratories; limitations in traditional microbiological diagnostics, meaning that the timeliness of sample testing and etiology of most cases remains unknown; and poorly integrated human and animal surveillance systems, meaning that identification of zoonoses is delayed or missed. OBJECTIVE: This study aims to detect anomalous patterns in the incidence of gastrointestinal disease in the (human) community; to target sampling; to test traditional diagnostic methods against rapid, modern, and sensitive molecular and genomic microbiology methods that identify and characterize responsible pathogens rapidly and more completely; and to determine the cost-effectiveness of rapid, modern, sensitive molecular and genomic microbiology methods. METHODS: Syndromic surveillance will be used to aid identification of anomalous patterns in microbiological events based on temporal associations, demographic similarities among patients and animals, and changes in trends in acute gastroenteritis cases using a point process statistical model. Stool samples will be obtained from patients’ consulting GPs, to improve the timeliness of cluster detection and characterize the pathogens responsible, allowing health protection professionals to investigate and control outbreaks quickly, limiting their size and impact. The cost-effectiveness of the proposed system will be examined using formal cost-utility analysis to inform decisions on national implementation. RESULTS: The project commenced on April 1, 2013. Favorable approval was obtained from the Research Ethics Committee on June 15, 2015, and the first patient was recruited on October 13, 2015, with 1407 patients recruited and samples processed using traditional laboratory techniques as of March 2017. CONCLUSIONS: The overall aim of this study is to create a new One Health paradigm for detecting and investigating diarrhea and vomiting in the community in near-real time, shifting from passive human surveillance and management of laboratory-confirmed infection toward an integrated, interdisciplinary enhanced surveillance system including management of people with symptoms. INTERNATIONAL REGISTERED REPORT IDENTIFIER (IRRID): DERR1-10.2196/13941
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-6787530
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2019
publisher JMIR Publications
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-67875302019-10-31 A Fully Integrated Real-Time Detection, Diagnosis, and Control of Community Diarrheal Disease Clusters and Outbreaks (the INTEGRATE Project): Protocol for an Enhanced Surveillance System McIntyre, Kirsty Marie Bolton, Frederick J Christley, Rob M Cleary, Paul Deja, Elizabeth Durie, Ann E Diggle, Peter J Hughes, Dyfrig A de Lusignan, Simon Orton, Lois Radford, Alan D Elliot, Alex J Smith, Gillian E Snape, Darlene A Stanistreet, Debbi Vivancos, Roberto Winstanley, Craig O’Brien, Sarah J JMIR Res Protoc Protocol BACKGROUND: Diarrheal disease, which affects 1 in 4 people in the United Kingdom annually, is the most common cause of outbreaks in community and health care settings. Traditional surveillance methods tend to detect point-source outbreaks of diarrhea and vomiting; they are less effective at identifying low-level and intermittent food supply contamination. Furthermore, it can take up to 9 weeks for infections to be confirmed, reducing slow-burn outbreak recognition, potentially impacting hundreds or thousands of people over wide geographical areas. There is a need to address fundamental problems in traditional diarrheal disease surveillance because of underreporting and subsequent unconfirmed infection by patients and general practitioners (GPs); varying submission practices and selective testing of samples in laboratories; limitations in traditional microbiological diagnostics, meaning that the timeliness of sample testing and etiology of most cases remains unknown; and poorly integrated human and animal surveillance systems, meaning that identification of zoonoses is delayed or missed. OBJECTIVE: This study aims to detect anomalous patterns in the incidence of gastrointestinal disease in the (human) community; to target sampling; to test traditional diagnostic methods against rapid, modern, and sensitive molecular and genomic microbiology methods that identify and characterize responsible pathogens rapidly and more completely; and to determine the cost-effectiveness of rapid, modern, sensitive molecular and genomic microbiology methods. METHODS: Syndromic surveillance will be used to aid identification of anomalous patterns in microbiological events based on temporal associations, demographic similarities among patients and animals, and changes in trends in acute gastroenteritis cases using a point process statistical model. Stool samples will be obtained from patients’ consulting GPs, to improve the timeliness of cluster detection and characterize the pathogens responsible, allowing health protection professionals to investigate and control outbreaks quickly, limiting their size and impact. The cost-effectiveness of the proposed system will be examined using formal cost-utility analysis to inform decisions on national implementation. RESULTS: The project commenced on April 1, 2013. Favorable approval was obtained from the Research Ethics Committee on June 15, 2015, and the first patient was recruited on October 13, 2015, with 1407 patients recruited and samples processed using traditional laboratory techniques as of March 2017. CONCLUSIONS: The overall aim of this study is to create a new One Health paradigm for detecting and investigating diarrhea and vomiting in the community in near-real time, shifting from passive human surveillance and management of laboratory-confirmed infection toward an integrated, interdisciplinary enhanced surveillance system including management of people with symptoms. INTERNATIONAL REGISTERED REPORT IDENTIFIER (IRRID): DERR1-10.2196/13941 JMIR Publications 2019-09-26 /pmc/articles/PMC6787530/ /pubmed/31573952 http://dx.doi.org/10.2196/13941 Text en ©Kirsty Marie McIntyre, Frederick J Bolton, Rob M Christley, Paul Cleary, Elizabeth Deja, Ann E Durie, Peter J Diggle, Dyfrig A Hughes, Simon de Lusignan, Lois Orton, Alan D Radford, Alex J Elliot, Gillian E Smith, Darlene A Snape, Debbi Stanistreet, Roberto Vivancos, Craig Winstanley, Sarah J O’Brien. Originally published in JMIR Research Protocols (http://www.researchprotocols.org), 26.09.2019 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work, first published in JMIR Research Protocols, is properly cited. The complete bibliographic information, a link to the original publication on http://www.researchprotocols.org, as well as this copyright and license information must be included.
spellingShingle Protocol
McIntyre, Kirsty Marie
Bolton, Frederick J
Christley, Rob M
Cleary, Paul
Deja, Elizabeth
Durie, Ann E
Diggle, Peter J
Hughes, Dyfrig A
de Lusignan, Simon
Orton, Lois
Radford, Alan D
Elliot, Alex J
Smith, Gillian E
Snape, Darlene A
Stanistreet, Debbi
Vivancos, Roberto
Winstanley, Craig
O’Brien, Sarah J
A Fully Integrated Real-Time Detection, Diagnosis, and Control of Community Diarrheal Disease Clusters and Outbreaks (the INTEGRATE Project): Protocol for an Enhanced Surveillance System
title A Fully Integrated Real-Time Detection, Diagnosis, and Control of Community Diarrheal Disease Clusters and Outbreaks (the INTEGRATE Project): Protocol for an Enhanced Surveillance System
title_full A Fully Integrated Real-Time Detection, Diagnosis, and Control of Community Diarrheal Disease Clusters and Outbreaks (the INTEGRATE Project): Protocol for an Enhanced Surveillance System
title_fullStr A Fully Integrated Real-Time Detection, Diagnosis, and Control of Community Diarrheal Disease Clusters and Outbreaks (the INTEGRATE Project): Protocol for an Enhanced Surveillance System
title_full_unstemmed A Fully Integrated Real-Time Detection, Diagnosis, and Control of Community Diarrheal Disease Clusters and Outbreaks (the INTEGRATE Project): Protocol for an Enhanced Surveillance System
title_short A Fully Integrated Real-Time Detection, Diagnosis, and Control of Community Diarrheal Disease Clusters and Outbreaks (the INTEGRATE Project): Protocol for an Enhanced Surveillance System
title_sort fully integrated real-time detection, diagnosis, and control of community diarrheal disease clusters and outbreaks (the integrate project): protocol for an enhanced surveillance system
topic Protocol
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6787530/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31573952
http://dx.doi.org/10.2196/13941
work_keys_str_mv AT mcintyrekirstymarie afullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT boltonfrederickj afullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT christleyrobm afullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT clearypaul afullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT dejaelizabeth afullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT durieanne afullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT digglepeterj afullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT hughesdyfriga afullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT delusignansimon afullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT ortonlois afullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT radfordaland afullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT elliotalexj afullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT smithgilliane afullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT snapedarlenea afullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT stanistreetdebbi afullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT vivancosroberto afullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT winstanleycraig afullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT obriensarahj afullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT mcintyrekirstymarie fullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT boltonfrederickj fullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT christleyrobm fullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT clearypaul fullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT dejaelizabeth fullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT durieanne fullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT digglepeterj fullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT hughesdyfriga fullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT delusignansimon fullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT ortonlois fullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT radfordaland fullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT elliotalexj fullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT smithgilliane fullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT snapedarlenea fullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT stanistreetdebbi fullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT vivancosroberto fullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT winstanleycraig fullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem
AT obriensarahj fullyintegratedrealtimedetectiondiagnosisandcontrolofcommunitydiarrhealdiseaseclustersandoutbreakstheintegrateprojectprotocolforanenhancedsurveillancesystem