Cargando…

A Novel Approach to Assess Sleep-Related Rhythmic Movement Disorder in Children Using Automatic 3D Analysis

Background: Unlike other episodic sleep disorders in childhood, there are no agreed severity indices for rhythmic movement disorder. While movements can be characterized in detail by polysomnography, in our experience most children inhibit rhythmic movement during polysomnography. Actigraphy and hom...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Gall, Markus, Kohn, Bernhard, Wiesmeyr, Christoph, van Sluijs, Rachel M., Wilhelm, Elisabeth, Rondei, Quincy, Jäger, Lukas, Achermann, Peter, Landolt, Hans-Peter, Jenni, Oskar G., Riener, Robert, Garn, Heinrich, Hill, Catherine M.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Frontiers Media S.A. 2019
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6806394/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31681030
http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fpsyt.2019.00709
_version_ 1783461618530648064
author Gall, Markus
Kohn, Bernhard
Wiesmeyr, Christoph
van Sluijs, Rachel M.
Wilhelm, Elisabeth
Rondei, Quincy
Jäger, Lukas
Achermann, Peter
Landolt, Hans-Peter
Jenni, Oskar G.
Riener, Robert
Garn, Heinrich
Hill, Catherine M.
author_facet Gall, Markus
Kohn, Bernhard
Wiesmeyr, Christoph
van Sluijs, Rachel M.
Wilhelm, Elisabeth
Rondei, Quincy
Jäger, Lukas
Achermann, Peter
Landolt, Hans-Peter
Jenni, Oskar G.
Riener, Robert
Garn, Heinrich
Hill, Catherine M.
author_sort Gall, Markus
collection PubMed
description Background: Unlike other episodic sleep disorders in childhood, there are no agreed severity indices for rhythmic movement disorder. While movements can be characterized in detail by polysomnography, in our experience most children inhibit rhythmic movement during polysomnography. Actigraphy and home video allow assessment in the child’s own environment, but both have limitations. Standard actigraphy analysis algorithms fail to differentiate rhythmic movements from other movements. Manual annotation of 2D video is time consuming. We aimed to develop a sensitive, reliable method to detect and quantify rhythmic movements using marker free and automatic 3D video analysis. Method: Patients with rhythmic movement disorder (n = 6, 4 male) between age 5 and 14 years (M: 9.0 years, SD: 4.2 years) spent three nights in the sleep laboratory as part of a feasibility study (https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT03528096). 2D and 3D video data recorded during the adaptation and baseline nights were analyzed. One ceiling-mounted camera captured 3D depth images, while another recorded 2D video. We developed algorithms to analyze the characteristics of rhythmic movements and built a classifier to distinguish between rhythmic and non-rhythmic movements based on 3D video data alone. Data from 3D automated analysis were compared to manual 2D video annotations to assess algorithm performance. Novel indices were developed, specifically the rhythmic movement index, frequency index, and duration index, to better characterize severity of rhythmic movement disorder in children. Result: Automatic 3D video analysis demonstrated high levels of agreement with the manual approach indicated by a Cohen’s kappa >0.9 and F1-score >0.9. We also demonstrated how rhythmic movement assessment can be improved using newly introduced indices illustrated with plots for ease of visualization. Conclusion: 3D video technology is widely available and can be readily integrated into sleep laboratory settings. Our automatic 3D video analysis algorithm yields reliable quantitative information about rhythmic movements, reducing the burden of manual scoring. Furthermore, we propose novel rhythmic movement disorder severity indices that offer a means to standardize measurement of this disorder in both clinical and research practice. The significance of the results is limited due to the nature of a feasibility study and its small number of samples. A larger follow up study is needed to confirm presented results.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-6806394
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2019
publisher Frontiers Media S.A.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-68063942019-11-01 A Novel Approach to Assess Sleep-Related Rhythmic Movement Disorder in Children Using Automatic 3D Analysis Gall, Markus Kohn, Bernhard Wiesmeyr, Christoph van Sluijs, Rachel M. Wilhelm, Elisabeth Rondei, Quincy Jäger, Lukas Achermann, Peter Landolt, Hans-Peter Jenni, Oskar G. Riener, Robert Garn, Heinrich Hill, Catherine M. Front Psychiatry Psychiatry Background: Unlike other episodic sleep disorders in childhood, there are no agreed severity indices for rhythmic movement disorder. While movements can be characterized in detail by polysomnography, in our experience most children inhibit rhythmic movement during polysomnography. Actigraphy and home video allow assessment in the child’s own environment, but both have limitations. Standard actigraphy analysis algorithms fail to differentiate rhythmic movements from other movements. Manual annotation of 2D video is time consuming. We aimed to develop a sensitive, reliable method to detect and quantify rhythmic movements using marker free and automatic 3D video analysis. Method: Patients with rhythmic movement disorder (n = 6, 4 male) between age 5 and 14 years (M: 9.0 years, SD: 4.2 years) spent three nights in the sleep laboratory as part of a feasibility study (https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT03528096). 2D and 3D video data recorded during the adaptation and baseline nights were analyzed. One ceiling-mounted camera captured 3D depth images, while another recorded 2D video. We developed algorithms to analyze the characteristics of rhythmic movements and built a classifier to distinguish between rhythmic and non-rhythmic movements based on 3D video data alone. Data from 3D automated analysis were compared to manual 2D video annotations to assess algorithm performance. Novel indices were developed, specifically the rhythmic movement index, frequency index, and duration index, to better characterize severity of rhythmic movement disorder in children. Result: Automatic 3D video analysis demonstrated high levels of agreement with the manual approach indicated by a Cohen’s kappa >0.9 and F1-score >0.9. We also demonstrated how rhythmic movement assessment can be improved using newly introduced indices illustrated with plots for ease of visualization. Conclusion: 3D video technology is widely available and can be readily integrated into sleep laboratory settings. Our automatic 3D video analysis algorithm yields reliable quantitative information about rhythmic movements, reducing the burden of manual scoring. Furthermore, we propose novel rhythmic movement disorder severity indices that offer a means to standardize measurement of this disorder in both clinical and research practice. The significance of the results is limited due to the nature of a feasibility study and its small number of samples. A larger follow up study is needed to confirm presented results. Frontiers Media S.A. 2019-10-16 /pmc/articles/PMC6806394/ /pubmed/31681030 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fpsyt.2019.00709 Text en Copyright © 2019 Gall, Kohn, Wiesmeyr, van Sluijs, Wilhelm, Rondei, Jäger, Achermann, Landolt, Jenni, Riener, Garn and Hill http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
spellingShingle Psychiatry
Gall, Markus
Kohn, Bernhard
Wiesmeyr, Christoph
van Sluijs, Rachel M.
Wilhelm, Elisabeth
Rondei, Quincy
Jäger, Lukas
Achermann, Peter
Landolt, Hans-Peter
Jenni, Oskar G.
Riener, Robert
Garn, Heinrich
Hill, Catherine M.
A Novel Approach to Assess Sleep-Related Rhythmic Movement Disorder in Children Using Automatic 3D Analysis
title A Novel Approach to Assess Sleep-Related Rhythmic Movement Disorder in Children Using Automatic 3D Analysis
title_full A Novel Approach to Assess Sleep-Related Rhythmic Movement Disorder in Children Using Automatic 3D Analysis
title_fullStr A Novel Approach to Assess Sleep-Related Rhythmic Movement Disorder in Children Using Automatic 3D Analysis
title_full_unstemmed A Novel Approach to Assess Sleep-Related Rhythmic Movement Disorder in Children Using Automatic 3D Analysis
title_short A Novel Approach to Assess Sleep-Related Rhythmic Movement Disorder in Children Using Automatic 3D Analysis
title_sort novel approach to assess sleep-related rhythmic movement disorder in children using automatic 3d analysis
topic Psychiatry
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6806394/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31681030
http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fpsyt.2019.00709
work_keys_str_mv AT gallmarkus anovelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT kohnbernhard anovelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT wiesmeyrchristoph anovelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT vansluijsrachelm anovelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT wilhelmelisabeth anovelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT rondeiquincy anovelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT jagerlukas anovelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT achermannpeter anovelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT landolthanspeter anovelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT jennioskarg anovelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT rienerrobert anovelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT garnheinrich anovelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT hillcatherinem anovelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT gallmarkus novelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT kohnbernhard novelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT wiesmeyrchristoph novelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT vansluijsrachelm novelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT wilhelmelisabeth novelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT rondeiquincy novelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT jagerlukas novelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT achermannpeter novelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT landolthanspeter novelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT jennioskarg novelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT rienerrobert novelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT garnheinrich novelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis
AT hillcatherinem novelapproachtoassesssleeprelatedrhythmicmovementdisorderinchildrenusingautomatic3danalysis